Unfortunately SETs and I want fully balanced. It's always something.
Doozy of an amp question
Still looking for my eternal love.
A forever amp. At least for now. I cannot try them out in my system as they are both beasts and it would be a nightmare getting them, paying for an audition and then returning them
I am having to go on instinct.
I have narrowed it down to two very different kinds of amps at two very different price points. And I have chosen these two because of reviews in magazines and the positive comments here and on other forums.
My pre is an Arc Ref 10 and my speakers are Dalis.
I am look at a tube Mc 1502 which I can afford right now or a Sim 861 for which I would have to wait to save for.
I realize it’s tube vs SS but both have their positives and a SS can have tube like characteristics which I like.
I’ve heard Mcintosh and liked it a lot but never heard this model.
I’ve never heard Sim but the reviews and comments about the 861 have been absolutely rhapsodic. And somebody whose opinion I trust said Sim is an excellent brand. But is this a flavor of the month model?
Has anybody heard both these amps. Any thoughts, opinions, advice?
I own the SIM audio 861 upgrading from a SIM audio w8, this amp is phenomenal it will go up against amplifiers in the 40 to $60,000 price range from other companies and be as good or better yes $22,000 is a lot of money but it is a lot better than the 761 at least 25% better or more, I compared both and that's why I decided to buy the 861 it's definitely a beast of an amp at 125 lb but once you hear it you won't buy the 761 It's that much better. |
@roxy1927 If you can I would definitely try to audition your short list if possible. This is coming from someone who has bought amplifiers over the years without auditioning and been disappointed. I have listened to the Simaudio 641 integrated and it was quite incredible. This was setup in a non treated room at a shop in Toronto and it was hooked up to some very nice joseph towers. |
Yes as somebody said above it is the Epicon 8 and I don't want an amp with a fan. I can go into the city and listen to the amps and they want me to listen to the 761 which would save me a lot of money from the 861. Then I read that the 861 on this site is 25% better. That's a lot of better but also a lot of money and I may be overdoing it. I listened to Mcintosh at Harry's of VPI house. It was great but he has quite a setup along with Blades. Unforgettable. But boy is that 1502 heavy but a lot cheaper. |
Without demos, buying is risky and resale value is always consideration. That said, few folks buy HiFi gear looking forward a 'flip'. Mac has a following, but it seems that Mac is a 'love it or not' brand, with little middle ground. I would definitely demo this Mac... I agree that ARC will be a synergistic, high SQ choice. Perhaps you live close enough to a dealer to arrange a demo.
|
I've herd the Mc but not the Sim. Your price point is some where around 17-22K based on the retail of these amps? You have a Ref 10- arguably the best preamp ARC made on of the best every built by anyone. Your sound signature will come from that preamp and then your speakers. The power amp is 3rd on the totem pole. I'd give serious consideration to a pair of ARC Ref 250SE used. You can get them in great shape for 12K if you can manage a little negotiation. A Ref 160s for 12K would be a good option as well. If your preamp was a lesser mortal other amps may be helpful but your preamp is the Formula 1 of automobiles so you need to performance match to it. ARC is designed to perform best with it's own family. |
I haven’t heard the specific amps but I have owned McIntosh C2600/MC 302 and currently Moon /Simaudio 791/860A V2. The Moon is more dynamic and detailed than McIntosh in my opinion. It was an upgrade to me. I believe the Moon amp sounds ‘close’ to Audio Research Amps - I didn’t want to deal with tubes Ultimately follow your ears Mc will have resale and the Moon has a 10 year warranty (neither will leave you high and dry)
|
I must admit I’m a McIntosh fan so with that would be my recommendation, both for sound, build quality, resale value, and being able to be repaired. Since you already like the sound I think you’ll be happy with the amp for a very long time. Also I wouldn’t worry about Bose buying them, they’ve been bought and sold many times throughout their 70 plus years (people forget about Clarion) and they’ve maintained their autonomy producing a first rate product with world class customer service and support. Just my opinion and I hope this helps with your decision. |
Post removed |
I know you are looking for SS benefits in amplification but there is something to be said for the combination or your preamp with the ARC Ref 160. To my ears magic in musicality. I do not like the Mac 1502. To me, recessed mids. I have not heard the SIM 861 but have read and heard good things about it. Also consider auditioning a Burmester 218 or 909. Tube like qualities of liquidity, staging and imaging with solid state control, speed and dynamics. Also, accurate timbre. |
I've worked on a couple of stereo tube amps, one was a Mac. Never again as was pointed out, the weight is killer. If you wish to re-tube the Mac, that's 8 power tubes. There's an old adage. SS amps will require x times the cost of a tube amp for similar tone. Dunno if this still exists tho. Mac has been bought and sold: https://www.strata-gee.com/mcintosh-group-acquired-by-bose-does-this-deal-make-any-sense/ As for making a decision, if possible, work with a local high end audio shop and take them home and try various amps in your price range. Take note: you can't put a review up to your ear and listen to it. As mentioned, there's a synergy that occurs with your equipment and with your room.
|
I moved from PassLabs to Esoteric to a used ARC LS10 / D240 MkII and haven’t found a need to change until the LS10 was damaged in transit and I let it go. I’ve retained the D240 because it’s fully balanced differential design. 120W pc of musical SS clarity and musicality. They make a higher power D400 set that could even better suit your speakers. I’m not pushing this specific amp series but showing how the used ARC options can work really well when paired well preamp to amp and amp to speakers. I use an upgraded AV preamp now to feed the ARC. Ppl won’t believe how good it sounds. At USD$12-1800 it’s an easy entry test for you to try with your preamp. |
Not a MAC fan and heard the Sim 761 the baby brother of the 861. I loved the 761 and found it similar sonically to the Benchmark AHB2 but not as sterile. I love the AHB2 but the 761 was definitely a better version of the AHB2. The 761 is very detailed just like the AHB2. If you want that detail, then the 861 would be the way to go. If you want Class A warmth or tube sound you are not getting it with the Sim. I have a CODA #16 which is a Class A amp. I would not mind having the 761 or 861 for my office system so I could flip back and forth with my Livingroom CODA #16. |
There are so many BP much better then that Mc parts quality leaves a lot to be desired, I owned a audio store for years belong to many audio clubs what are you speakers is the 1st question how big is your room ,how loud do you want to play it ,your speakers and their efficiency first and foremost. the Coda 50wpc 5.5 pure class A for $6500 a Great Amplifier to start this , Coda has excellent class AB amps that have 3 power to choose from up to 18 wpc to start into pure class A bias , what’s your budget too , Pass Labs some very good classD amps using Gan Fet technologies I have the Latest Very high current monoblocks from classD audio .com excellent and would never know what it is it judt get out of the way of the music ,and power to spare. And under $2500;can competes with much more expensive amps. Lots of good amps out there to choose from.
|
There's no way of knowing in advance how two components will align with each other. Actually, three components, the speakers, power amp, and preamp. I'm not an ARC guy, but I agree with jperry's comments that ARC is the safe choice. Anything else, the results could be anything, and odds for a mismatch are good. |
I can’t answer your question directly and admittedly have not heard the Macintosh amp. I have heard the simaudio. I’ve also owned a couple of SimAudio products and I found them to be very well built, reliable, and competent. I can appreciate the difficulty you have with in-home auditions. Even if you can’t do that, I suggest you try to listen to these components at a dealer location because I think the McIntosh house sound and the sim house sound are quite different. it seems likely if you like one, you may not favor the other. The Macintosh amps I have heard tend to be sweet, critics would say dark and veiled, proponents would say musical. The simaudio Amp is more detailed and transparent, critics would say dry and analytical although that would not be my view, I think it delivers to the speaker the signal it receives without coloring it inany way, not a bad attribute for an amp. Although it’s always better to listen in your own set up, I think if you could hear these two components at dealer locations, you could at least get a good read on which House sound you like because they are very different. |
There is no way I would spend that much money, perhaps get lucky with used, let a good find be the determinant. That SIM 861 is 155lbs shipping weight. They have the pair of Mono Block 400’s, shipping 33 lbs each, and that big MC 1502 is very similar to a pair of MC275’s, split the weight, perhaps start with one Stereo, add the 2nd when another pops up. My right knee has hurt for years, since the last time I lifted my 80lb McIntosh MC2250 out of a low shelf. I think a 3rd meniscus tear.
|