Not Sure If This Is OK Here, But Here Goes


I'm selling a pair of Magnepans on Audiogon and as usual, have had no response. Yesterday, a guy from Argentina (allegedly) contacts me and says he'd like the speakers and gave me an address and phone number of a guy in Miami to ship them to and he'll forward them on to the end buyer.

At first glance, this doesn't pass the smell test. However, he did give me a phone number, which I may call later today. The other issue I have is that I have little to no experience with PayPal. How hard is it to defraud PayPal and leave me without my  money and the lose of my speakers?

jasonduke2

If there's a question- there's no question. The fact you felt the need to reach out should be enough for you to "move on" what model Maggie"s ?

 

This an export transaction in which you are the "exporter of record" you have obligations to both the US and the importing country.  There are required documents, as an example a Commercial Invoice and perhaps other documents.  These documents are required for both the export and import side of the transaction.  Some foreign buyers use a "Forwarding Agent" to manage all these requirements as well as arranging the actual shipment of the goods.  The company  you have been pointed to may be such a company or individual with both knowledge and authority to handle the transaction.

Now there is payment, the safest and simplest traction would be to sell the item to the guy in Miami have him pay you thru PayPal and let him deal with the process of getting it to the end buyer.  You are paid and out of the loop.  You don't own it anymore and you are not exporting it.  He is. Take your money and forget about the rest.

Now, you may be asked to ship the goods to this guy in Florida with the promise that you will he paid by the end buyer.  Problem here, is that you don't know what is going to trigger you getting paid.  You also don't know who is going to pay the freight, handling and duty on the shipment, that could add up to some dollars you don't want to pay.

I have sold lots of stuff on Ebay with a few export sales.  Every time it was an export I just "wrote it off" maybe I would get paid and maybe not.  And maybe I would get a call from customs enforcement.  I got lucky and never had a problem, but finally decided I would not do it anymore and excluded export sales from my listings.

You may just want to wait for a domestic buyer and not get dragged into this mess.

 

 

i've always wondered about transactions using paypal f@f. why do they let you do that-they make no money!

Friends and Family is intended for what it says. If you use it for buying/selling things then you are violating the terms you agreed to when you signed up and  basically cheating them out of what you owe them. Otherwise known as fraud. Sometimes called stealing.  I know many will rationalize why that isn't wrong, but it is wrong

signed,

goody 2 shoes

paypal did absolutely nothing for me when I paid for something and it never arrived. 

You are on your own. But if you get paid in advance, you are safe.

i've always wondered about transactions using paypal f@f. why do they let you do that-they make no money!

Make sure he pays thru paypal first and then wait till it clears when you transfer the funds to your bank!

Just tell the guy your looking for a local sale. Too many variables and unknowns. Unless like Waltersalas says, the guys packing 2-3 digit feedback. 

It’s stressful enough as a seller packing, shipping, insuring and praying the moving company doesn’t screw up. Be patient and put the gear on usam also.

If it's too good to be true, it isn't. If something isn't selling and you want it to move, you have to lower your price. Simple economics - supply and demand.

I am suspicious as a general rule. But in this scenario, as long as you are being paid securely up front, and provide no personal info, it's on him to get your speakers shipped securely for the final leg of the transit.

I've sold to Agoners in Latin America who wanted to work with a freight forwarder. 

The issue I've experienced with freight forwarders is around the packaging of the item. The freight forwarder oftentimes removes the item from the factory protective packaging in favor of their own--much smaller and less cushioned--box. Both times I've shipped to a  freight forwarder, the gear arrived damaged. 

Being Maggies your speakers will sell if the price is reasonable. There's not millions of people buying high end speakers out there so sometimes it may take a month or two to sell something. I agree with others that it isn't worth the potential problems.

I’ve used PayPal routinely for international trabsactions, i.e.,, So. Korea, JPN, FRG, UAE, Qatar, and UK. The most expensive single item was ~$30,000. All transactions and monetary exchanges were smooth. On one occasion, an unexpected shipping delay occurred. I prematurely reached out to PayPal, who shut down the seller’s account until I pleaded on his behalf. I would proceed but with caution as urged by our hobby peers. 

I live in Mexico and we import from Italy.  The process for us is to hire an import company in MEX to negotiate with the Italian manufacturing company.  The Italian company must be paid by the MEX import company before they will ship.

Because of a recent contact by an Argentina importer, I know the process is the same for Argentina.  

If the Miami company is legit, they must be willing to wire the funds to you bank account before you ship.  Import/export companies send hundreds of bank wires and letters of credit a week.

Good luck!

 

My @ cents, people from Argentina, and companies, use US residents as their "mules" to buy things in the USA. Getting stuff like HiFi gear is extremely, and I mean extremely expensive because the import tariffs.

I forget what the tariffs are but they are something like x2 x3 the invoicing. A few years ago, I travelled for business to BsAs 4-5 times, and when I was asked what I like to do and mentioned my HiFi hobby and showed some pictures of my setups this couple jumped off the table. They were all over it. To make the story short, I ended buying a TT, an amp and yes speakers that a "mule" got through customs for me!

I am not saying this person is legit, but what this person is proposing is a common way for them to get things into the country. I also have a similar story with a Brazilian gentleman.

Think of Argentina and Brazil as a modern East Germany in the 70s-80s, their governments are nothing short of Russian style governments. For example, people were dying, still are, and both governments made illegal to import COVID vaccines from the EU, Japan, and USA. They either got a Chinese or Russian vaccines, almost a year after everyone was getting vaccinated.

Just my 2 cents, but people in Argentina have been nothing short kind and hard workers and they make the best they can with the little they have.

Cross your Ts, dot your Is and see if this person is legit. I just don’t dismiss people from other cultures and regions because they do things differently than me.

 

elrod is right! Paypal requires shipment to the buyer's registered address on Paypal.

I agree with @jackd. I had a buyer who said he was from Columbia and of course I thought, "yeah right". He explained to me that they don't have access to equipment like we do in the States. He said the freight forwarder out of Miami would handle the customs paperwork and that I didn't have to worry about it. I was a bit reluctant but went ahead and sent the CD player. Everything worked without a hitch. I received payment and never heard another word. I might ask a few pertinent questions just to make sure it's legit but what he is saying is true.

PayPal won’t cover You if you go through a third party (another words you would be shipping to a different address than that on the buyers account), they will only cover you if items are shipped to the address of the buyer directly, got caught with this a few years ago, sounds like a sca

No Pay pal . You will not be covered.
This is a scam .Don’t bother trying to make it happen.

Had this scenario twice. 100% Total Scam

Run from this bogus offer. Run! You already know the offer is no good. These offers only work on desperate sellers or people who trust in the kindness remote strangers, which you shouldn’t. bogus offers work on a very small percentage of targets but it’s called getting something for nothing. There’s always someone looking to part a person with his money. But if you go forward, I have a bridge in the Everglades for sale. 😀

As a seller, you are not in a favorable position with PayPal. As a buyer you have more control and easier to get your money back. 
I have sold many items internationally and almost all of them, if you go thru customs, you lose any ability to track your shipment so your ability to prove that your shipment actually made it to the buyer diminishes as well as leaving yours of open for the buyer to get their money back and you lose the item you sold. EVERY international transaction, and EVERY transaction here in the states over a certain amount, the buyer has to use PayPal friends and family

Paypal will make you pay more for services to mediate the complaint if you have problems with the sale. They were sued for not protecting sellers before ebay bought them.

 

3rd party transactions are always suspect. And with something big like Maggies, I wouldn’t take the chance. The problem with Friends and Family mode, which seems fool proof as MC mentioned, is it really isn’t. If the buyer pays F&F with a credit card, they can’t dispute via PayPal but they can dispute on the credit card, which is even more of a nut roll. You could use an escrow service of some sort, but that is just another layer. Run, don’t walk. Just not worth the hassle.

In your situation I’d use ZELLE and have the buyer agree that you’ll accept no responsibility for non-delivery or damages. PayPal will hold your money hostage until the speakers are delivered. Great for the buyer but for the seller it’s a great way to get screwed and PayPal ABSOLUTELY will put the screws to you. I can’t stand them.

A buddy tried it once. It was a legit transaction, but the deal was dramatic and shaky. In the end, things worked out, but I don’t think he would do it again. 

I wouldn’t do it, but MC has a good idea with using PP Friends and Family. 
All the best.

JD

It's a scam! I have been thru this scenario twice before on ebay and elsewhere and got screwed don't do it!!

Post removed 

Flip the tables. Ask the buyer to pay using Friends and Family. That way you have the money he has no recourse and the only burden is on you to ship to wherever he wants. 

Normally a foreign buyer would have an intermediary in the U.S. buy the item for them and then ship it to them. The intermediary in Miami is the one who should be buying your item with their PayPal account and address.

OP, the situation would give me pause.  And if you want there's likely a way to conduct the transaction.  I would only consider doing the transaction payment in advance and the buyer pays and provides shipping labels.

The buyer can insure the product and they take ownership prior to shippiing.

@nonoise Thank you for your humor!  I didn't think Shaq ever said 'no'

@noske , I repeat. You never give a stranger your personal info. It is another dynamic when you shop with an established storefront. Even then your info is at some risk due to hackers. 

I have had many phone conversations with scammers and they are usually quite charming until you force them into a corner. 

You never give any stranger your personal info 

@mijostyn 

I often provide my personal info in a transaction.  So that we may talk by phone.  A chat on the phone can easily assist in establishing whether this is a person with whom you wish to do business with.

Or, to put it another way, it easily weeds out obvious scammers, and then you are left with remaining genuine people.  Or, person.

Post removed 

I was curious and looked for your ad but it shows you have 0 items for sale. Did you cancel it?

The first thing a scammer usually tries to do is get you away from the web site by giving you an email address to contact. The new thing is to say "God Bless" at the end of the request. I just sold a $3000 bicycle on eBay. For 6 months all I got were scammers and two legitimate people who did not fit the bike. Going through Venmo and PayPal are the best way to handle these transactions. You never give any stranger your personal info and you only ship to the customer. 

I'd wait a while and see if I got any other offers, and I'd also list it on USAudiomart. 

I believe PayPal has something in place that you have to ship to the/an address on their PayPal account or it's not covered. I may be totally wrong but I won't ship anywhere except the PayPal address.

Of course paypal is terrific and an accepted industry standard. People do try to game it by for example claiming all sorts of nonsense, I know that, but I am only going by what others have said.

Complicated transaction, though, and of course it smells fishy. My preference - for want of a stronger word, maybe "rule"- is to always and only communicate with the buyer to whom you will ship it to. Or, seller, whatever side you are on.

This approach is also consistent with any ordinary rules of contract law.

Keep it simple. Hows that for some original advice.

 

PayPal is secure. I have used it for the past five years without any problems. 

There is a dealer/distributor in the Miami area that does forward gear to guys in that area.  There are several members on AudioShark that use him.  It's there only way to access gear not sold in their countries. 

Post removed