In my case it would be easier to explain that my ears or my mood had warmed up.
Amplifier warm up
I was plalying Boz Scaggs, "Silk Degrees" LP. After side one, I ate dinner. One hour later I played side 2. The second side sounded clearer, more vibrant with better sound stage. I have a Parasound P6 preamp and Parasound Halo A21+ amp. Is it possible that an hour of warm up improved performance?
59 responses Add your response
Yes, that's exactly what happened. These are solid state components. SS takes much longer than tubes to warm up and sound their best. In fact they really should be left on 24/7 if you want them to sound their best. But hey, don't take my word for it. Simply leave them on the next few days and see, er hear, for yourself. |
yes ss gear sounds better when warmed up, running a while i am not sure leaving a power amp on 24-7 is a good idea... stuff does degrade over time with heat... if you are listening every day maybe ok, but if not using for a while, maybe still better to turn off little more green too... if you care about that |
| Post removed |
Yup. Not surprised. Not the least bit. This all seemed preposterous when I first heard about it back in the 90's. But, as usual, if it can be tested super easy then why waste time arguing? Find out for yoursel! So I left my 1970's era Kenwood amp on 24/7. Days then weeks went by with no perceptible change in sound. Like I thought, BS. Oh well. Been on a week, might as well just leave it on. Until one day for some reason it gets turned off. Oh well who cares it doesn't make any difference anyway. Next day turn it on to listen and what the... sounds like crap! This was my first time learning that sometimes when differences are small and you're not used to hearing them, can't recognize them, it helps to listen long enough to get accustomed to the new sound. Because then when it changes you will notice. Looking back its clear the amp was improving the whole time it was on, just at a very slow gradual rate that made it hard to notice until quite some time had gone by. Its like this with a lot of things. AC power improves very gradually through the evening and late into the night. Even when things are left on still the whole system gradually improves when playing music. Differences that are hard to hear when you're unfamiliar and listening to 30 year old Kenwood and JBL are indescribably wonderful late at night with a really good system. Anyone serious about building a really good system, you could do worse than to learn to hear these little changes. |
A lot of the class D (non pro stuff), says "Leave it on". In the summer anything with valves gets turned off.. 15-30 min in the summer time for a tube preamp to warm up.. An hour in the winter though.. I like 60 degrees in the winter, with valve amps and valve preamps.. It takes about 30 min, if I played them the day before..(winter). The speakers sound better on cool crisp days, too. Regards |
+1 millercarbon's point about AC noise. OP, if you really want to do a comparison, make sure you do it during the same period -- all during the day vs. all during the evening. If you're comparing evening to daytime, then you're not eliminating the "noise on the line" factor (which may or may not be a factor where you live, but you'd eliminate it by simply controlling the day/time. |
My new SMc Audio monoblocks do not have a power switch, just power cords to the wall. Steve McCormack recommends leaving them turned on for best sound and turning them off for:
|
It's certainly been my experience that noisy AC lines are a culprit for variability in sonics along with warm up time. With all my gear over the years 1 hr seems to do it for warm up benefits...more just doesn't help much for my ears. But the time of day has huge sonic swings and compelled me to eventually get a PS Audio Power Regenerator. It even measures the distortion coming into the unit and I can see it go from more than 4% THD during peak area usage periods down to 2% late at night or very early in the morning. With the regenerator the output is consistently below 0.1% THD which has seriously enhanced my listening experience. Plus it regulates the voltage to a consistent 120V....otherwise mine fluctuates 118-123V otherwise throughout the day. |
Guys, You need to get off the grid....check this out....better than $10K PS Audio: http://enjoythemusic.com/magazine/equipment/0119/Goal_Zero_Yeti_400_Lithium_Portable_Power_Station_R... You really don't need a Goal Zero with its fan noise. You can buy low distortion sine wave inverters for a few hundred $ and a 100 amp hour battery or two and a big charger and run your system all day before needing to charge. You can listen while charging but it won't sound as good. As good as inverters are (completely off the grid and better sound than practically any line condiioner) they still make noise. My friend is using the Puritan line filter after his 3000 watt inverter and it sounds even better and it isolates each component from each other. Incredible sound....same sound day and night. |
Cold vs hot makes no difference to my ears. But that's just my ears. They're not the finely tuned instruments possessed by true audiophiles. My SS amp manual (Madrigal Proceed HPA 2) says to leave it on. I can't bring myself to do it. I'm hardly what anyone would call an environmentalist....more like a conservationist....but the bottom line is that even in standby mode that amp makes heat. A fair amount of it too. I have no idea what that translates into in terms of electricity usage but it cannot be negligible. And my music rooms tends to be a tad hot in the summer and a tad cool in the winter compared to the rest of the house. That last thing I want in a Carolina summer is more heat. So maybe I should leave it on in the winter. I believe my AR LS16 tube pre-amp manual says to leave it on as well, in standby mode, but I do not remember and can't recall if it makes heat in standby mode. I would hope not. |
@aeschwartz It appears your A21+ amp is consuming 1-watt on StandBy mode, and its very possible you’ll hear a difference after 2+hrs of warmup-play, sure. I tested a smaller A23+ a few months back and it sounded better after 1-2hrs. Most good ClassA solid state amps I’ve owned sounded pretty bad at 15-30 minutes from cold startup, and once the large transformers became warm and fully saturated, I could always hear notable changes at 1hr and 4+hrs. Some other well known Class-A amps notably improve after 8-24hrs warmup once everything becomes nice and toasty. I’m not sure I’d leave an ultra high-end Class-A SS amp on other than for weekends or long listening days. With my current tube mono amps, 1hr of warmup is all that’s needed and the sound really does not change after 1hr. Varies some by amp type and design of course, type of transformers used, YMMV. |
ricevs I am totally off grid(closest power pole is 2miles away) ,I have solar ,generator backup and lithium4 batteries . I do power my hybrid down and it takes a solid hour min, to get my system to open up. I run class D in my video room that is always in standby mode . |
There are a few other possibilities that were not considered: 1. Side One of the LP may be your favorite and thus it may have gotten more play and is showing its age compared to Side 2 that is more pristine. 2. By the time you had finished your meal, the power grid in your area may have become less busy and therefore better suited to your listening session. 3. That bong hit. |
atmasphere8,812 posts10-27-2020 3:47pmYou can't take any good system seriously for the first 1/2 hour or so! Indeed - also your phonostage and cartridge need warming up. With vinyl things can be very frustrating. Part of that early dissatisfaction will be augmented by the phonostage and cartridge not performing yet. |
@aewarren There are a few other possibilities that were not considered: 1. Side One of the LP may be your favorite and thus it may have gotten more play and is showing its age compared to Side 2 that is more pristine. 4. That ribeye steak in your tummy makes you sleepy 5. Those three glasses of petit syrah makes you loopy 6. That square of tiramisu pushed you over the edge lololololololololol .......... |
Actually, i agree with both the OP and N80. Yes! solid state warms up, and over a 30-60 minute period the majority occurs. Many solid (state) reasons. That said, everything sounds better after a glass of wine, or with stable blood sugar or whatever. So joking or not, N80 is, IMO, absolutely right. Since i design commercially, i have to account for the many things that might fool me into thinking something is better or worse. And how i feel is culprit #1. That's why subjective evaluations are so difficult, and generally viewed as without credibility. Yet i wont argue that we need listening - i cannot measure most differences that i can reliably hear. G |
There’s a reason why most SS amps have the on/off switch hidden inconveniently on the back - they expect you to leave the gear running. As one commenter noted, though, yes, the components do deteriorate over time (I just replaced a Conrad Johnson amp that had run almost continuously for 12 years; over the last year I had noted that the bass response was degrading). Counterpoint is that the majority of electronics failures occur during power up. Pick your poison? |
atmasphere = +1 (and; more = better) |
The phenomenon is not necessarily universal. Just sayin I have an F5 (Class A)that sounds great cold and deteriorates slightly as the temp goes up in my room, say 2 hrs later. Probably has to do with improper bias calibration during the build finish. Just to add another eccentricity to the forum cool aid, I like my speakers ** toed out ** (again in my particular situation). :-) |
@millercarbon There's no such thing as warm-up, and certainly nothing needs to be left on all the time.This is from his lengthy post on the other thread on this subject, just this week Which is it Chucky? Of course it takes time to reach thermal equilibrium. A shorter time for tubes than transistors. |
My JC1’s live in standby, and they start to sound their best about 1 hour into a listening session starting at 5:30 on a Friday evening. A Sunday morning with JS Bach is sublime at about 6am, with about a ½ hour of playing time. I suspect it’s a combination of time of day/power grid activity and transistor temperature stabilization. Most natural phenomena have several factors operating simultaneously. Science is so... complicated. |
I'm a bit skeptical of manufactures who say that their products need hundreds of hours of break in before performing or sounding good. Although some products do benefit from a break in period (several hours, not hundreds of hours) It has been my experience that good products will sound good and perform well out of the box (so too speak) after being allowed to warm up. I do know that some amps, pre amps DACs and CDPs (old or new and some more than others) will improve in sound after being allowed to warm up before giving a serious listen. My, tubed pre amp sounds better after about 20 minuets of warm up, but I can't hear much, if any difference, after that. It just sounds really good. I shut it off when I am through listening, to save on my tubes and power bill, if I'm not going to be using it again for several more hours. My Integrated tube amp sounds best after about 1/2 hour of warm up and I can't hear any difference after that. I also shut it off when I'm not going to be using it for several hours. My old ADCOM SS power amp sounds best after at least 8 or 10 hours of warm up. When I'm using it in my main system, I leave it on continually. For those with these older ADCOMs, if you're not giving them at least 8 or 10 hours or warm up, you are missing out on how truly good they can sound. Many other SS amps, likewise, sound their best after several hours of warm up....Jim |
Once again, for the community's benefit, read my article at Dagogo.com; "Audiophile Law: Thou Shalt Not Overemphasize Burn In", wherein I put both burn/break in and warm up to the test. I am uninterested in semantics arguments, or debate with people lacking experience of actual comparisons of systems side by side. :) |
@douglas_schroeder - I read the article and am not surprised with the results. Since I don't view these things as a contest, I am not concerned that some here believe in significant changes due to burn-in, but I don't. I think you are getting close to what happens with your statement:
I would assert that a significant change happens to the hearer during the honeymoon period as the ears acclimate to the product. Why is there so little discussion of “Acclimatization”?Could this be a reason some manufacturers recommend an extended burn-in period before making a decision about the sound quality of new equipment? Considering some combination of The Endowment Effect, the Sunk Cost Fallacy, or some other psychological phenomenon, some manufacturers (or their marketing departments) probably realized the longer a person owns something, the less likely they are to return it. While I don't believe in extended burn-in, I have heard the difference between an amplifier that is warmed up vs. one turned on from a cold start. The difference was apparent with my former amplifiers - Class A Clayton M300s. They were most of the way there after about 30 minutes and seemed fully on task after an hour. As a follow-up to your burn-in article, I would be interested in hearing about whether you and David could hear differences between brand new cables and cables that have been conditioned on something like the Cable Cooker. |
mitch2, thank you for your comments. I have not used a cable cooker; there are simply too many things to do in audio that I have determined are of more significance to me. You can bet the first thing I would do if I got my hands on a cable cooker is repeat my experiment with sets of new cables to get to the bottom line regarding cable cookers. If any cable cooker manufacturer wants me to assess, I can. But, I will vet the product first, as I will not spend extended time on a product that I deem of marginal value. If anyone wishes to extend that courtesy to me, they should expect that I will conduct a similar comparison as I did in the Audiophile Law article. That would be as fair an assessment as the come. :) One last comment to perhaps head off objections. Someone might say that I'm predisposed to not hearing the benefit, as though my bias would not allow me to accept or acknowledge the putative benefit. Let's be more mature than that. I compare settings, cable sets, my Schroeder Method of IC Placement, etc. on a weekly basis, so if any change is to be deemed significant it has to pass my Law of Efficacy, which states that it must be instantly/immediatley heard, repeatable (i.e. In this case, heard concisely, even if cables are moved around), and subjectively benefit holistically, not just partially). |
