Thanks for the post. I'm interested. I had heard that judging amps by the "class" was not a sufficient metric and I love the narrative here you've given with your experiences of a variety of amps.
!!!OK OK - I'm Big Enough To Admit I Was DEAD WRONG!!! Class D Doesn't Always Suck!!!
In preparation for a move to the Philippines later this year,I needed a system I could pack in my travel trunk that offered:
small enough size & light enough weight to travel well,multi voltage operation(120/240 volt) so that I can use it anywhere,plenty of digital inputs including USB/Optical,Bluetooth 5.0 along with a decent headphone circuit & lastly,sound at least comparable to the SimAudio Moon 240i/Harbeth M30.2Xd system I was replacing...
I started with a Vincent Audio Class A/B,compact hybrid integrated..While I could easily live with the sound,it just wasn’t small enough,even with it’s half size frame,to be a viable option + NO USB input..Next was an Advance Paris,Class A/B,MyConnect 60..Same result,fine sounding by just too big & again,NO USB input...
I finally accepted the fact that I was going to have to bite the bullet & give a Class D option a try..I demo’d a few amps,a PS Audio Sprout 100,a fosi something,a Topping & an SMSL,even a fairly expensive Primare but I just wasn’t "feeling"the music..Oh they were technically decent,offering great bass & decent enough staging & imaging,but none of them had that organic,natural tone I craved...
Then I discovered Creek Audio had rebooted the venerable 4040 integrated amplifier in a modern,compact,lightweight Class D configuration,offering all the features I required including 120/240 volt operation..I remember the original 4040 from long ago,with it’s wonderful green display & natural,organic sound driving Celestion speakers..
Remembering that original experience with the CAS4040,& having owned an Evolution 50a, I was well versed in the Creek house sound & had a pretty good idea that if anyone could make Class D sound musical,natural & organic,Mike Creek would be the guy..
Well 3 weeks ago,based solely on that gut feeling, I grabbed one of the few remaining,updated 4040a units in Black finish available at the untarrifed price of $1280.00 delivered, & have had it playing a little under 2 weeks now..My beloved Harbeth M30.2Xd’s have been rehomed & replaced with the miniscule yet wonderfully musical ProAc Tablette Anniversaries & I’m STILL wearing a mile wide smile!
Yes,I did give up a bit of deeper bass,mainly at low listening levels,but with just a bit of volume,the bass those tiny titans put out,driven by the Creek amp is full,deep enough to allow a kick drum to sound like it should & leave me wanting for nothing..Cellos have such a beautiful dark,deep voice they will make you cry & the bodies have resonance you can really feel..Everything I listen to just sounds right...
Imaging & staging in pretty amazing..I am spoiled having had a couple of really good tube amps in the past & I will say hands down,the Creek OUTPERFORMS the SimAudio 240i in these areas of performance,being deeper,wider & better defined!
Headphone performance?Driving either HiFiMan Ananda Nano's or iBasso SR-1's,late night listening sessions are magical..Mike Creek really understands how important headphone listening can be!
So yea,I was wrong about Class D..With the right implementation it is highly musical,wonderfully natural & organic,and when it comes to it’s physical characteristics of size & weight just can’t be bettered...
@hilde45 ,thanks much.I posted this hoping that any old dogs,or even youngsters, stuck in the mindset that I was in,will have the courage to try new options... |
I’ve had many Class D’s for years. Some "high end", some not so much at least based on cost and aesthetics. Each different sounding but good overall. None "sucked". I see only Class D in my future as well unless I decide to play with a flea powered tube amp and high efficiency speakers as well just for kicks. Just tossing my 2 cents in the pot. |
“Synergy” is the word. I was using a class D for a long time with my Magnepan MG3.6R’s until the Power Module in one channel decided it had had enough. Yes, it’s me with the wanted ad for Spectron part. A friend uses Jeff Roland mono blocks with his MG3.7’s. and a VTL pre amp which sounds very nice indeed Might be a little tricky taking them abroad but were there’s a will…..
|
It’s always nice to hear of an audio enthusiast who’s downsized their system and in the process experienced what it was like when they first got started in this hobby. I experienced something similar when after having several high end systems, purchased a vintage British system from the 1980’s and 1990’s composed of a Naim CDi, Naim NAC 42.5/HICAP/NAP 110 driving a pair of Linn Kan I’s. IME this is a great sounding little system for not much money. As for Creek Audio, I’ve always liked their gear and 35 years on, still have a pair of CLS10 bookshelf speakers from the early 1990’s, that my late Dad used in his study for years. |
It would be helpful to understand more about the recommended speaker impedance to pair up with this particular amplifier, and getting it right. Sounds like the OP found a nice match with the ProAc speakers used here. Nice. Great to read more progress with the new Class D amplifier designs some are achieving past few years. There are a few other reviewers and folks who've mentioned some type of harshness up top or the amp responding in a flat way when paired with speakers with big impedance swings, and compared to their prior AB amps with the same speakers. I did not see data or amplifier measurements to explain what was being reported, or how that was occurring, yet it did bring up the amp < > speaker matching question as being an important factor to understand more about perhaps.
|
@decooney when the Creek first came in I still had a pair of Quad 11L speakers on the stands..These speakers had a 6 ohm nominal dropping to 3.8 ohms in the lower treble & the Creek had no problems driving them to a steady 95db.with no harshness,compression or clipping.. |
@erik_squires true.There are many small Class D integrated amps available nowdays BUT the Creek & Wyred For Sound mINT are the only ones I found that are user convertible from 120 to 240 volt operation with just the flip of a switch! |
OP : I'm not necessarily encouraging you or anyone else to audition the NAD instead, but thought it would be useful to mention them. You are right though, they are not user convertible since they have universal power supplies. If you really must have a switch to change the power supply setting I guess you are out of luck. |
@danager weird comment and don't know why you chose to ping me |
...and the insane in the membrane sort as I would only toss my 'trash' for a pair (Yes, a pair...wishes 'n fishes....) of these.... ;)
|
Perhaps it is far too late to matter, but... Many years ago I purchased a Devailet Primer/250. It is a 'lifestyle' audio system and an early implementation of Class D tech. It sounds great, yet different from my main system (SS & tubes). It is so attractive that it receives praise even when turned-off. Like most manufactures, models change and the 250 is no longer current. Still, it is nice to see if on is available on the 2nd market. Check-it out... Have fun on your next journey... |
Class D has come a long way since the sterile, dryer sounding modules in the beginning or some overly warm designs that lack air and inner detail. There are some difference between designs. My preference is now GaN FET as I find them the best overall. |
Yeah it seems Class D has finally come of age in recent years. I hadn’t encountered a Class D amp that I could live with long term (and I tried many) until recently with the Axxess Forté1 integrated. It finally dethroned my Yamaha integrateds. I also prefer it to the Denon A110 and Luxman 507Z. There was a time not long ago when I believed I would never be a class D convert, but here I am listening to my Forté1 and not yearning for anything. The fact that it’s significantly easier on the power bill is icing on the cake. |
I too was skeptical of class D amplification, however I purchased a Jeff Rowland Capri S and a pair of Rowland 501 mono blocs for my Wilson Audio Watt/Puppy 5.1’s and I was not disappointed. 1000W of power opened up my Wilson’s and I have never looked back. Amazing soundstage, increased headroom and plenty of bass punch. Done correctly, it can definitely rival class A/B IMHO. |
I bought an NAD M10 v3 recently just to try DIRAC, and I'm amazed at how good it sounds. The ease of use is fantastic too. HDMI ARC, Roon, Airplay, Bluetooth, etc. Apparently you can even connect 2 "rear" speakers that are BluOS compatible for a sort of surround for movies. All for under $3k. |
I think judging am amp on class is indeed not wise, as I have a full on service department in this space I tried to build a good sounding Class D amp, Not easy at all. You still need a great front end, you still need a great power supply, you need cooling schemes as the Class D runs hot. I was trying to beat an inexpensive Class AB amp and it cost (build cost) just as much as a full on Class AB amp to get the Class D to sound as good. Comparing N Core that is used in lots of amps as not a good method for evaluating quality. The front end and the power supply make all the difference in the world so many N Core amps can and do sound different based on these surrounding segments of the entire amplifier. Unfortunately, you have to listen to it. Now that does not account for the genius designers among us, Theta was building great sounding Class D a long time ago- but that is one of the best amp designers in the world (Morris Kessler). The are many others who are extremely bright in this field as this is all they do. |
@ltmandella the Creek 4040a IS ALREADY THE PERFECT AMP FOR THE PHILIPPINES!!! |