Sad songs- We love them- We need them


Hello everyone,

I was listening the other day to a sad song on my playlist and realized their ability to invoke a powerful emotional reaction. Usually about someone in your life. Your children, your special lady or man or maybe someone who is no longer living. I realized we need these songs to remind us life is short and to remember what is most important to us. I thought I would ask everyone to list a song or two that is special to them. It doesn’t necessarily need to be a sad song. I have children so I will start with a few songs that remind me to tell them I love them more often or give them an extra hug or two. 
 

Cats in the cradle- Harry Chapin

Jacobs Dream - Allison Krause 

Hell Is for Children- Pat Benetar

Ron

ronboco

Old Bones, Hangman, and Trigger on the album Blood of the Land by The Burned.

Darkest of My Days on album A Rebel’s Story by Big Wolf Band

Roy Orbison--Only the Lonely, Cryin

Everly Brothers Cryin’ in the Rain, Cathy’s Clown, When Will I Be Loved?, So Sad, Love Hurts

The Happenings Will I See You in September?

Elvis, OF COURSE, Heartbreak Hotel

Lots more, but these for a start...

 

Son Volts "Methamphetamine" is the saddest song ever written for my money. A close second is John Prine's "Souvenirs"

 

Puff the Magic Dragon - Peter, Paul, and Mary

A dragon lives forever, but not so little boys
Painted wings and giant's rings make way for other toys
One gray night it happened, Jackie Paper came no more
And Puff, that mighty dragon, he ceased his fearless roar

His head was bent in sorrow, green scales fell like rain
Puff no longer went to play along the cherry lane
Without his lifelong friend, Puff could not be brave
So Puff, that mighty dragon, sadly slipped into his cave

@fastfreight , good call on Lloyd Cole.

Everything But the Girl - Riverbed Dry

Prefab Sprout - We Let The Stars Go

The Smiths - Back To The Old House

@mitchagain  yes I think it is the unique combo of cynicism and depression! 
seeing him live in DC in a few weeks;  sure hope he’s not in love!

"Gloom, Despair, And Agony On Me"  Hee Haw

"The Ballad Of Dwight Fry"  Alice Cooper

@spenav, Thank you so much for the thought, what a sweet special gesture. It was my beautiful 36 year old daughter I lost in a car wreck 8 month ago. Enjoy the music

@tooblue 

I can imagine no greater pain than losing a child. I have two daughters and a son. I’m so sorry. 
 

Ron 

  • Empty Garden - Elton John
  • Touch me in the morning - Diana Ross
  • Times of your life - Paul Anka
  • How you gonna see me now - Alice Cooper
  • Send in the clowns - Judy Collins

 

"I Can't Make You Love Me" Bonnie Raitt

"Hey Mister, That's Me Up On The Jukebox" Linda Ronstadt

"Hurt" Johnny Cash

"He Stopped Loving Her Today" George Jones

"Someone Like You" Adele

"The Living Years" Mike & The Mechanics

"Good Riddance (The Time of Your Life) Green Day

"Lazarus" David Bowie

"Blue" Joni Mitchell

"By the Time I Get to Phoenix" Glen Campbell

"How Can You Mend A Broken Heart?" Bee Gees

 

 

"Hurt" by Nine Inch Nails as opposed to the cover of it that Johnny Cash did.

From Lucinda William's "Sweet Old World" CD, the song "Sweet Old World" and also from that DC, "Pineola."

I really liked the covers that Emmy Lou did of "Sweet Old World," and also her cover of Steve Earle's "Goodbye." 

From back in my days of high school angst, Nazareth's version of "Love Hurts."  (Although I don't think it would have an effect on me any longer.)

"The Ghost Of Phil Sinclair" by Chip Taylor still evokes an emotional response (of sorts) from me.

Post removed 

I Can't Make You Love Me as performed by Bonnie Raitt

 

Saddest song I know.

@cns1946 +1

"The wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald" Gordon Lightfoot.

I can't listen to this song without getting choaked up a little.  My wife and I spent some time in Michigan's Upper Peninsula last year.  Being there made the song even more real to me.  

@tooblue My sincere condolences.

I lost my son in 1994.  Our song was Mona, by Quicksilver Messenger Service.  I'd drive him to school every day, and start this song when we pulled out of the driveway.  Mona has a very long instrumental lead in and we made a game of noting where we were when the vocal started.  We could also tell if we were making good time, or bad time on the commute.

Every year on his birthday, I reenact the drive -- noting, of course, where the vocal started.

Losing a child certainly re-calibrates your definition of what a problem is.  From that day forward, everything else seems pretty trivial by comparison.

@waytoomuchstuff ​​​​​, thank you from the bottom of my heart for sharing that with me. @ronboco, thank you.

Warren Zevon's "Keep Me In Your Heart".  The final song on Zevon's 2003 album, "The Wind".  Zevon began recording the album shortly after he was diagnosed with inoperable pleural mesothelioma (a cancer of the lining of the lung), and it was released just two weeks before his death on September 7, 2003.  I've heard it played an several Memorial Services and it brings the waterworks everytime.

 

 

@waytoomuchstuff  and @tooblue,

 

My heart is heavy for both of you after reading this thread.  I have two boys (actually adults of 31 and 28 years old, both teachers in High School and Middle School, but they will always be "my boys"), and I can't bear to envision a World without them.  My sympathies to you both and I hope time, memories, and music have helped soothe the scar.

 

Allen

 

 

"Accidentally Like A Martyr" Warren Zevon (The hurt gets worse and the heart gets harder)

"I Feel Like A Bullet (In The Gun Of Robert Ford)" Elton John/Bernie Taupin

Although "Daniel" from "Don't Shoot Me, I'm Only The Piano Player" is the saddest-for-me Elton John Song (possibly due to personal family events we were experiencing back then), "Blues For Baby And Me" off the same album always stuck me as melancholy.  As did "Rocket Man," also by John/Taupin. 

David Gray has loads - he's rather known - or them but certainly one of the saddest songs ever is "The One I Love." 

A ghost in the house by Alison Krauss – grieving

If Tomorrow never comes by Ronan Keating and also by Brenda Kinnear - The subject is in the title.

Sweet old world by Emmylou Harris – grieving.

Yesterday when I was young by Roy Clark, Dusty Springfield and others – regret.

Try to remember by Jerry Orbach - nostalgia.

If I Loved You by Shirley Jones and Gordon MacRae from the show Carousel (and we know how that turned out).

 

 

Randall Knife, Guy Clark.

First heard several years prior to my father's death. Couldn't listen to it for a long time after. Fair warning.

 

 

Sorry if it has already been mentioned, Kristofferson's Sunday Morning Coming down and  Merle Haggard's How Did You Find Me here, off of his second to last album, I am What I Am. Enjoy the music

@switzer145 another vote for "Sweet Old World"! Yes!

However, as much as I like Emmy Lou’s cover of it, I am prejudiced and I love the original by Lucinda Williams.

 

Hello in There. John Prine

Lilac Wine Nina Simone

**Lorraine Lori McKenna

When I Was a Boy Dar Williams

True Companion Mark Cohen

Atheist Chrismas Vienna Teng

Start to Stop - Martha and the Muffins

Everybody Knows - Leonard Cohen (but I prefer cover by Concrete Blonde)

Lady Grinning Sole - David Bowie

Don’t Get it Back - Veruca Salt

Just about half of the Aimee Mann catalog.

No one said it Would be Easy - Sheryl Crow

Safe and Sound - Sheryl Crow 

 

 

 

I'll have to contemplate before I can respond on my own behalf; but I know my daughter's choice. When she was about three I was singing lullabies to get her to sleep. For some reason I went into "You are My Sunshine". She started crying inconsolably when I got to

The other night dear, as I lay sleeping
I dreamed I held you in my arms
But when I awoke, dear, I was mistaken
So I hung my head and I cried.

Now after 30 years it has the same effect on her. 

Choose any version you like. Even the songwriter(s) is a subject of contention. I always thought it was corny and was very surprised when she started crying.

+1 for Bonnie Raitt's "I Can't Make You Love Me" and Warren Zevon's "Accidentally Like  A Martyr". They were at the top of my list. 

Here are a couple more including a few covers I prefer to the originals:

Nils Lofgren- "Little On Up", "I Don't Want to Know", "Moon Tears"

Ricki Lee Jones- "Walk Away Renee"

Jennifer Warnes (and Leonard Cohen)-  "Joan of Arc"

Vanilla Fudge- "You Keep Me Hangin' On"

Neil Young- "The Needle and the Damage Done", "Old Man", "Down By the River"

Bloodrock- "D.O.A."

The English Beat- "Can't Get Used to Losing You", "Tears of a Clown" (I love Smokey, but this a great cover of his song).

Smokey Robinson- "Tracks of My Tears"

The Weavers- "Ramblin' Boy"

Joe Cocker- "With a Little Help from My Friends"