"...or my 1970's Pioneer receiver..."
Yup.
Yup.
Klipsch Forte ii too bright, or is it my room ?
Wow! You are all over the map on this one. It may be one item, or a combination of several, that is causing the brightness. First, your speakers. Some Klipsch models, for some people, are bright sounding. I personally, would not do anything to modify the speaker, they were designed, and built a certain way. Try toeing them in, a little, at a time. Next, is a room issue, and this may be a biggie.It would be less troublesome, and cheaper, to relocate your speakers to another room. If you can not, or do not want to do this, then, it may be best, to look into "room treatments’, to deal with reflections from the glass and tile. If you don`t want to go the room acoustics route, try near-field listening. In my humble opinion, I don`t think changing your electronics will rectify the problem, unless, you have a better sounding room. If the room was better for sound, then the next step, would be, some tubed components in your system, or new speakers. |
Post removed |
I have Forte I speakers in stock form and they need careful amp/ room matching to not sound bright. They sound best when I can sit at least 9' away. At around 6' the horns don't seem to develop and sound bright. A lively room w/ lots of reflections seem to magnify the already lively Klipsch sound. These speakers seem to like warm and soft sounding amps. Works very well with my current Rega Mira3 amp and a vintage NAD 7225 receiver. I'll bet Marantz amps would be a great match as well as vintage McIntosh. I was surprised that they sound bright w/ my Mystere IA-11 tube amp because of the superb air and spaciousness that it supplies. I think this amp would be a perfect match in a larger well dampened room where you could move the speakers into the room. Finally toe in plays a big part and these speakers wonderfully large soundstage allows for great sound with no toe in. |
If a speaker sounds fundamentally wrong to you, I urge you to not reconfigure all your associated equipment and room to accommodate a speaker that does not appeal to you from the get go. Been down that road and the best solution is to start fresh. For some the Klipsch sound might be the ticket and that's great. For others, don't force a round peg in a square hole. |
+1 @russ69 +3 @ holmz Even when new I never cared for Pioneer in the 70's. At 50 yrs old its wore out with dried up capacitors, etc. room full of glass and tileGuaranteed to brighten any sound would a mid-priced tube amp work, +/- $500We no longer live in the 1970's. $500 was a good budget in the 70's but not at all today. However for $1500 you can get a VTA Bob Latino ST-70 which will put you way ahead in sound. But you will need a preamp also. They also have them. And you need to tone down the glass & tile. Curtains and rugs are needed. tubes4hifi home page |
I agree, try vacuum tube amplification, even low power vacuum tube amplification, before you give up on the Klipsch. How about a little 15w/Ch amp based on EL84’s. There are some decent integrated amps of this types from China or power amps made in USA by tubes4hifi. Years ago, Dynaco made wonderful sounding EL84 amps, the SCA35 and ST35. Tho not as powerful, many listeners prefer these to the ST70. |
Post removed |
+ Henry53!I worked in a Klipsch dealership for years and never could stand them. I understand the current product is better but I have no direct experience. Consider a Black Ice F11 at $1595. An affordable EL34 based integrated. If you are handy you can build a Dyna ST35 kit. Also try stuffing a tennis ball in the MR horn to “mellow it down easy”. Nerf might work too! Easily reversed tweak to tame the harshness. |
If a speaker sounds fundamentally wrong to you, I urge you to not reconfigure all your associated equipment and room to accommodate a speaker that does not appeal to you from the get go.. Wrong. I can't think of many speakers that will perform well in a room full of tile and glass. Add in a Pioneer receiver and you have a recipe for disaster, no matter the speaker. Oz |
Glass and tile room? That, to me, seems to be your problem. I've also noticed a few comments over the years about some speakers being best at lower volumes and not so great at higher volumes. That's probably the room too. Sound telegraphs the materiality of the surface it comes in contact with. Glass and tile are going to bright surfaces. No need to turn your living room into a sound studio. You can make simple and clever choices that pay big dividends. Stage 1: Lay down a large, thick rug. When you buy a proper Persian/Turkish etc rug from a good retailer, they will include a heavy felt underlay. This is better sonically than just putting the rug on the ground or using some cheap grip netting. If you can, get a large enough rug that extends to the front wall/under the speakers. Or, as in my case, get a separate rug just for your speakers and equipment to sit on. Please don't think this is overkill...it makes a difference to you will hear. People will easily spend 5 figures on an amp...but balk at spending 4 figures on a good rug. I've learned to value and appreciate rugs because of my audiophile hobby. Install some good drapes that you can close up for listening sessions. Stage 2: Avoid artwork or picture frames with glass. Those music posters in large glass frames look cool but don't help. Choose paintings on canvas and natural hardwood frames. Tapestries, wood carvings and almost anything with uneven, rough or fabric surfaces will help. Try to use symmetry between left and right walls. We have a 60" monitor on the side wall. I place a wool throw blanket over it when I listen. My last home had a great listening room. I could turn the volume up really loud and it never felt loud or out of control. The room had an amazing grip on the system. Your system should sound just as good at high volumes if the room is well treated. |
Wow thanks everyone!! Out of 20 comments it looks like the large amount of glass needs curtains, that is inexpensive & easy, I'll do that & the dynamat first, if It's still too bright a tube amp / new pair of speakers will be in the distant future as I have other expensive hobbies like having a mortgage in California, thanks again everyone! |
Post removed |
Klipsch for starters are severely bright. Then an older receiver the tile will bounce highs all over tape some cheese cloth or cut a tshirt the size of the tweeter, tape it over the tweeter, or try a 2nd layer of tshirt over the tweeter, let us know the results, it will soak up the searing highs. An inexpensive fix! This worked for me on my BIC towers. |
Post removed |
I read many folks recommending tube amps w/ the OPs Fortes. I've used a modern tube amp w/ my Forte I speakers and it's not a magic bullet for Klipsch Heritage loudspeakers. It can still sound bright because of the extra air and spaciousness from my tube amp which multiplies an already lively speaker. I find room placement and a less lively large room than I have plays a very important part. The tube amp is beautiful w/ Klipsch but won't necessarily tame the highs if there is other factors. I also find the my Linn K20 low capacitance speaker cable is a perfect match w/ my Klipsch. |
Really good thoughts, all of them. Refreshing not to hear any “mid-Fi” comments as well. Certainly with any system it’s a challenge to select the right speakers with the proper amplification. You didn’t mention which pioneer you had. Some late sixties early seventies Pioneers were very good sounding. I have always admired horn loaded speakers, but have never owned a pair. I’ve always noticed them being demonstrated with strings, piano trio, or solo instruments in which they almost always excel for their life like qualities. They do sound ‘live’, ‘dynamic’ and have incredible impact. But when I feel like listening to Presence by Led Zeppelin, their appeal goes away and the headaches begin. That’s why I have always used EPI, AR, Definitive Technologies, B&W, and recently Focal. You can insert almost any sealed enclosure speaker with a soft dome tweeter here. They are listenable over a broad range of music without much effort. A carpet would certainly help. If you love the speaker and your electronics you can make it work with your system. Don’t give up! Fire up that graphic equalizer and tame the harshness, or dial back the highs with your tone controls. You don’t have to go tubes. I recently heard the latest Hersey being driven by an ancient Sansui 4000 receiver, playing some Miles Davis and female vocal Lps. Wow! I’m still thinking about how good the Klipschs sounded. They were sweet, powerful, laidback, dynamic and really life like. Makes me want a pair...for now anyway. Best! Norman |
Wow thanks everyone!! Out of 20 comments it looks like the large amount of glass needs curtains, that is inexpensive & easy, I'll do that & the dynamat first, if It's still too bright a tube amp / new pair of speakers will be in the distant future as I have other expensive hobbies like having a mortgage in California, thanks again everyone! It is not solely the glass, and unlikely to the be the amp. I would go to a pawn shop, and try any speaker that they have, or borrow a friend’s… Then report back with findings. |
First things first. Fix the room before doing anything else. It's like building a house and making the foundation later on. It may mean more than just adding curtains. Place a rug on the tile floor. Wood and tile floors look great with a nicely matching rug (rug shops let you try several rugs for free for a few days before buying). Why do I say this? Because you will learn so much about how to deal with room acoustics. It’s also fascinating how some changes seem to make a huge difference and how some are very subtle. Also, how would you quantify which fix worked? First fix room, then speaker/rack location, then electronics. |
I'd agree room would be first thing. Second could be wrap horn rather than change amp. I can only tell you the horn on my Klipschorn went from ringing like a bell to sounding like a damp rag. I tried everything from tiny to large amounts of various damping materials, no sense of natural timbre for me. Still, the damping could work for him if not as sensitive to timbre and tonal anomalies as myself. I still prefer tube amp vs ss amp on Klipsch Heritage, although I did have a little Musical Fidelity M2SI integrated ss in for a time that really wasn't too bad. |
Also, how would you quantify which fix worked? First fix room, then speaker/rack location, then electronics. If the room needs to be done anyhow then doing it 1st makes sense. But if the speakers are new, then I would return them quickly. While speaker placement is important, the speakers are also important. And your list above does not even mention that the speakers might be a contributor.. The good part is that that list is also a long ways towards having a decent start at an Ishikawa diagram. And they are all valid causal mechanisms that can result in the observed problem. |
He needs to change only one variable at a time, changing room first may allow him to live with rest of system. If he intends on keeping Klipsch (which do have some admirable qualities even in stock form), damping the horns could be a next possible solution, assuming he still has issues with brightness after only room treatments. Still has issues, go to tube amp, I, and many others who own Klipsch prefer tubes as we have the similar tonality/timbre issues with most ss amps. He could explore the first two options with practically no cash outlay. If resources of no concern, I'd suggest the room fixes with professional treatments together with tube amp as initial moves. Purchasing new speakers first upsets the entire balance of what he presently has, like starting all over again from scratch. Keep the Klipsch and proceed in incremental steps. |
I owned Forte II's years ago. The biggest issue I had with them was amp. I used them with B&K and before that NAD. I was young and poor and didn't know any better. They were too bright. Yet, I would love to have them back now. I'm putting together a small cabin system and have a Jolida JD-1000a integrated amp and Spica TC-50 speakers which are not cutting it. The 1000a is a EL-34 tube based amp and I feel, it would be a perfect match for the Forte's. I currently looking for Heresy's or Forte's. Advise: Try out an EL-34 tube based amp. |
I have to say that I'd never want to have to switch between speakers to enjoy all the music I like. I also think you're putting too much analysis into this. It seems to me that the speakers don't work for you. Sell them and get something else. Don't waste time and money trying to fix something that for you is fundamentally broken. |