Really enjoyed hearing the Wilson Benesch Discovery 3Z monitors.
($31,000 US)
What is the Best Sounding Stand Mount Speaker in the world?
Price no object.
Brand and Model is adequate.
If you have not listened to it, please restrain yourself.
I raise this question because there is a maker claiming
to be the best. I am curious if it will garner votes.
Conclusion out tomorrow!!
Stay tuned!!!
“I share the same first name” As a suggestion, don’t buy above until you hear TAD CE1. |
Post removed |
Response Recap in no particular order-
1.PMC MB2 $73,800 2.Wilson Benesch Endeavour 3zero $74,000 3.MBL Radialstrahler 120 $24,000 4.Borresen M1 $100,000. Plain 01 a mere $30,000 5.SCM 300 ASL Pro (Active) $44,000 6. Graham LS 5/5 $25,000 7.Sonus Faber Guarneri Tradition $15,100 8.Focal Diablo Utopia 3 $15,000 9.Dutch & Dutch 8C (Active) $12,500 10.Alta Audio Celesta $15,000
No one voted for the self proclaimed "Best Stand Mount in the World"! We are missing a couple brands I expected votes for. I am extending this another day. Euros please chime in.
|
It’s a big stand-mounted speaker, but nonetheless: the ATC SCM150ASL Pro’s certainly sound great, as does their even bigger stand-mounted sibling - grotesquely big in this category, I know - the SCM300ASL Pro. That being said, thinking that the latter with built-in amps, electronic cross-over and top-of-line drivers (incl. dual 15" woofers and what’s arguably one of the best midrange drivers around) can be had in the same price category or cheaper than some more typically sized passively configured mini monitors appears much more grotesque to me. For that reason in particular I’d gladly bend the rules a bit for the ’typically expected size of a stand-mounted speaker’.. |
Wilson Benesch Endeavour 3zero has got to be on this list. I have the Discovery 3zeros and the Audiophile Junkie speculated they might be the best stand-mount speaker in the world when he was in my room at AXPONA. The Endeavours are technically superior in terms of cabinet design and should push the absolute limits in terms of sound quality. |
-ADC L710, L910. for vintage they are remarkable. -Proac Tablets these are what got me started as an audiophile. - BBC monitors, as above with the tablets they were based, as so many, on BBC's work so you really need to consider the BBC monitors as some of the best as they influenced so many other designs. -Omega SAM, inexpensive and one of the best at sound stage I've heard. most full rangers excel in this area though these are just one of the less expensive ones that really shined. - Living voice, auditorium line, they are superb at making music. wish i didn't sell mine... |
@thieliste I think you meant to say Borresen 01 SSE. The 05 is the biggest floorstander. :) I have heard the 01, the 02 SSE, and the 05. All are endgame. I own the Borresen Z3 Cryo myself. |
What qualifies as a stand mounted speaker? I noticed someone mentioning the Harbeth 40.2 XD. It is a box on a stand, but, it is a big box on a stand and is meant to be treated as a big speaker--placed in big room, well away from the walls. My local dealer, Deja Vu Audio in Northern Virginia makes custom speakers, including a stand mounted speaker that looks very much like a 40.2 Harbeth on steroids--similar proportions. The drivers include an 18" woofer and Western Electric horn and compression drivers that now cost well north of $20k just for the drivers, and a Fostex tweeter. The crossover includes some scary expensive Audio Note capacitors. This is one of the better stand mounted speakers I've heard, that is, if it qualifies. |
“Best sounding standmount speaker” is an undefined and highly variable bespoke value judgement, so I will post it in two different ways: (1) Best I’ve auditioned at length AND thus purchased and currently own TOP CHOICE : HARBETH 30.2XD on TonTraeger speaker stands ( because of their thin wall cabinet build that permits this BBC monitor derivative to resonate like a grand piano or violin soundboard ) - derived from the BBC’s LS5/9 design, - my personal experiences mirror the following review excerpt: ” …. Used on 24"-tall stands from TonTräger Audio ($1495/pair), the Harbeths delighted HR with easy-flowing music, vivid colors and textures, "unshakable clarity," and stereo images that were "tangibly there." Herb’s verdict: "the most tuneful, accurate, neutral, fun, and music-loving stand-mounted two-way speaker I’ve I’ve heard."" CONTENDER: HARBETH 40.2 XD . These were key contenders but my room size, and acoustics were primary drivers to consider the 30.2’s. Surprisingly , the latter is the “sweet spot” in their model offerings, so they were the “Best Buy Option’ for me.
(2) Excluded “Best ,,,,” but strictly only a whimsical option. There are several “ fantasy wish-list” options composed of Uber-expensive, interesting and engaging standmount speakers I’ve auditioned at audio expos that I will never be able to afford. They were setup with $500,000+ electronics and graced with ka-Ching NORDOST ODIN cables that sounded fabulous but an impossibility for most of us … thus a pass on this post .
|