Keep noise creators outside your clean power zone


Hi Everyone,

Just a tip for those of you who have invested in power conditioners:

Keep things which generate noise outside of your clean zone.

Power conditioners, unless fully active, are just filters. They are not magic blessing devices. What I mean is that the power that comes in gets filtered, and sent out, but it can be contaminated again! It’s just like your water supply. Makes no sense to use fancy water filters, and storing it in a dirty bucket.

If you can, avoid using wall warts, and network devices like Wifi routers, switches, video streamers etc. on the clean side of your conditioner because they will contaminate the already filtered power. If you have a conditioner with multiple zones, put all your noisy neighbors on the same dirty zone.

I try to solve this by using a less expensive but still very good power strip to create a "de-militarized zone." DMZ for short. The Furman PST-8 is a great way to do this, because it does include really good filtering which goes down to about 3 kHz.

Plug it directly into the wall, not into your conditioner. This will give you the most number of filters between your wall warts and your audio. Of course, other alternatives are to use linear power supplies exclusively, but even then, anything with a network or CPU in it can generate noise that makes it through the power supply.

Lots of other conditioners will work, of course, the Furman with SMP just has great noise handling and ~ $120 is much more affordable than alternatives.

Whatever you do, keep your noisy neighbors outside your clean zone.

Best,

E
erik_squires
Post removed 
@heaudio123

I believe (back from my days working in this) that's there are limits to the amount of capacitance you legally can add across the H and N lines, no? Putting a coil in series helps with that. :)


Here are the specs, from another piece of gear that uses SMP (Series Mode Protection) and LiFT( Linear Filtering):

  • Filtration Rating

  • 10 dB @ 10 kHz
    40 dB @ 100 kHz
    50 dB @ 500 kHz

  • This is not the same device, but the same features. The 10 dB @ 10kHz corresponds, roughly to working down to 3 kHz. Still, either measurement is a lot better than the typical EMI/RFI suppression which usually don't work until 100 kHz
    Post removed 
    Erik, is this a manufacturer claim or has there been some independent testing?   I am not doubting it, just curious where the number comes from.

    @heaudio123

    Good question, and I actually had to think about where I got this number from. it's actually inferred from similar technology. Series mode surge suppression needs a big low pass filter to work. That filter is in place at all times, but during a surge additional components get activated.

    The inference I made, and you are right to ask me about it, was that since surge suppression needs that low pass filter to work, and that other specs are nearly identical to similar series mode surge suppression, then the filter knee should be about the same place.

    From similar devices which have been measured that point is about 3 kHz.

    Sorry to have stated such an assertion without actual hands on data.

    Best,

    E
    Post removed 
    I did actually mean maybe just maybe back to the OP topic?
    Too much to ask for??
    🙄🙄
    @uberwaltz....Do you mean the usual sturm 'n drang, or the uneasy truce? ;) *L*

    Some would argue about the color of daylight....imho.....*sheesh*hand to forehead*
    @tomic601

    My memory here is vague, but I think it went through a few versions, and I remember one being really great and another meh.

    My first exposure was on a Snell A/III, and swapping out the Amber amp for a Tandberg was a real revelation in what a good amp could do with that speaker.

    Later on, in San Francisco, I got one and it just wasn't the same.  Maybe the caps all needed to be replaced?
    Post removed 
    I grew up in a house with 4 vacuum cleaners.

    My crazy uncle Russel would basically use them to vacuum up the bark from around the wood stove he kept moving, then when they clogged he'd buy another.
    I may have left out guns, Porsche’s and home theater.... only one of those brings out the crazies....

    I will remind “
    dear gentle reader” that I grew up in a house with 300 guns, so go ahead - educate me... about crazy
    Post removed 
    Now I remember!
    It was a combination jazz and turnip festival.
    They called it 'Turnip the Jazz'!

    Thank you, I'll be here all week....
    I wish Miller would just go infest another forum.....so pretentious and unpleasant....our hobby is for fun and to enjoy with others.
    Oh cmon now guys
    Being a little hard on Miller arent we, I mean what has he done to deserve this?

    Oh wait, hold on, its coming to me.
    Thats right... everything!

    Carry on old chaps!
    Actually, I heard Azerbaijan was a hotbed of jazz!
    They recently held the annual Baku Jazz Jamboree.


    That completely assuages my guilt!
    I thought it was one of those red baseball hats.
    You know, that way the curtains match the carpet.
    @three_easy_payments,
    I'm certain he at least has a strip of red carpet.
    Leading to a wicker 'throne' and a Burger King hat...
    Actually, I heard Azerbaijan was a hotbed of jazz!
    They recently held the annual Baku Jazz Jamboree. They even had a Miles Davis lookalike contest.....
    Or was it a turnip festival.......
    I get those two confused.
    @tomic601

    Might have been. Honestly the amp though did not hold up. The 2 Parasound A21s I had were a lot better.

    That's the other thing, as much as I got rid of, I still had an Oppo BD player, 2 Parasound A21s and a plethora of Class D amps, Focal profiles, and was making my own, and a pair of Monitor Audio profile speakers.
    Which Tandberg? The 3K series hyper neutral and quiet....

    I would put those in my garage or vintage system in a heartbeat 
    Man, when I lived in San Francisco I sold all my gear in bulk.

    Sumo pre/amp, Tandberg pre/amp, Theta Casanova.

    In a 1 bedroom, that was waaaay too much stuff.  Not to mention the speakers I was accumulating.

    There are children in Azerbaijan whose souls are dying due to lack of Jazz music and here I was hoarding.
    Apparently my wife thinks feng shui is Chinese for
    "Stuff all your husband’s crap in the garage..."
    Nothing wrong with Feng Shui, but really, you guys have to check out Marie Kondo, the hoarder whisperer.
    Before I knew Feng Shui Bagua mirrors were supposed to face outdoors I was only warding off myself.
    Look what you all doing to miller...it’s only noon and he’s not even reached his average daily quota of 20 posts 😃

    https://www.memeatlas.com/images/wojaks/wojak-soy-soi-boi.gif

    Geoff - suggest you cut a dragon hole... no F-S listening room is complete without one...

    remember the Dragon must be able to fly downslope unimpeded to water...

    put $$$$ where mouth is as the developers in the know do in Hong Kong

    While nobody has a monopoly on truth , the petty attack on Erik is really uncalled for.
    E and helomech are quite correct in appending SMPS to Wall wart. Get them on a different leg of your panel IF possible. You can try this w long extension cord and as E says an inexpensive PC

    the Point about mostly analog devices being self polluted is quite accurate- ARC and Aesthetix both recognized this and make the display defeatable - quite audible.

    finally to help answer Miller’s question about where the clean/ dirty line is - anybody who puts a resonant tonearm in a corner on purpose has no clean line...
    @thecarpathian  

    I’m guessing you built a one man shelter......

    I wonder if it also has bright red carpet?
    But he knows better than everyone about everything!
    Just ask him or that tiny personal PM fan club he uses as vindication of his beliefs.
    A wall wart is nothing but a very simple power supply. Its a transformer, couple diodes, maybe a cap or two. That’s it.
    That makes as much sense as saying "all amplifiers sound the same"

    For $75 to $100 or so, one can get a PC based scope and have a bloody look!!! No guessing. No noise? No problem.

    BTW, the concept of following is anathema to me. If I could, I'd block millercarbon permanently. Nothing he writes is worth the bits to transmit.

    You should have seen what he wrote before the mods deleted it....
    Totally abrasive and clueless.
    Miller
    You should have stayed in your ’end of the world’ bunker, counting your cans of beans and bottles of Purell with all your friends instead of once again displaying that sparkling personality.
    I’m guessing you built a one man shelter......

    Had to drop by for a moment just to say.... First some special snowflake gets triggered and of course mini-Mao removes the post. But too late, another one triggered, copied and pasted the whole thing. So its still up there for you all to read the truth about yourselves. Which includes such a lack of self-awareness you leave that post up. Hilarious. 

    If one of you would now be kind enough to copy and paste this one, so its up even after it gets removed (which, Kafkaesque, look it up) that would be ROTFLMFAO hilarious! 

    Wow, I guess you could say that my whole life is cluttered (I blame my mother, who always told me, “Save everything.  You never know when it will come in handy!” . . . . “Yes, Mother”.   It was my father who showed me that saving too much, such that nothing can be located and put back, can be as bad as never saving anything.

    Fortunately, I am not as bad as Mother was (after she passed and we went through her belongings, we found a utility bill from 1949!), but I am indeed bitten.  I even save old buttons, in hopes that one day I will find the missing shirts or compatible ones.   I have tried to fight back against my thoughts that, “Just when I throw this away, I will find out what it goes to and will kick myself.”  And, every once in a while, I do find out what the thing belonged to and restore it to its rightful location, and for that moment everything feels right with the world.
    Geoff, I see you've stopped dying your hair. Or did you start dying your hair?
    Either way, much like your posts, tres avant garde......

    bob540
    This makes me think of the guy who commented here, after seeing my set-up, that I had too much cluttered together. I took that as meaning the clutter was visually unsettling, but having read Erik’s comment, I’m thinking now that he might have been referring to noise being generated by the proximity of several pieces of electronic equipment (though I guess he might also have been referring to reflections?).

    >>>>>There is a third and more mysterious reason, gentle readers, why clutter is bad for the sound. I don’t wish to appear messianic or overly mysterious but think of it like Feng Shui. Having an organized and uncluttered space is good for everything, you can also think of it as minimizing entropy. Especially bad for sound - and I’d don’t mean to be ironic here - are CDs, magazines, books, newspapers, LPs, videos, and extra unused electronics and cables you might have lying around. Even musical instruments. How’s that for irony?
    This makes me think of the guy who commented here, after seeing my set-up, that I had too much cluttered together.  I took that as meaning the clutter was visually unsettling, but having read Erik’s comment, I’m thinking now that he might have been referring to noise being generated by the proximity of several pieces of electronic equipment (though I guess he might also have been referring to reflections?).  

    I have two Furman’s below on that same table, each plugged into the same wall outlet.  One has all 8 outlets (4 are filtered and 4 unfiltered) with all 8 having something plugged into it; the other has 2 devices plugged into its 6 outlets (so far).  I hadn’t even thought if this whole arrangement I have might be introducing noise — but I’m not sure what I do about it if it is (that being the only nearby outlet).  Interesting topic.
    Yeah, no, it doesn’t work like that. Not even close.

    First, because there is no "zone". Look at my system for example. https://systems.audiogon.com/systems/8367 Where is the "clean power zone"? Can you show me? Is it after the power conditioner? Or is it after the step down transformer? Maybe its after the breaker panel? No? Maybe its the electric meter? Because I have tracked the thing back to the point of using tweaks on the meter box and it works just as well there as everywhere else along the entire power path from that point on. Which is to say all of it. So where exactly is this imaginary zone then?

    Second way its nothing like you say, I can disconnect or turn off breakers going to other rooms and hear an improvement. I can put contact enhancers and outlet plugs on stuff in another room clear across the house and still hear the same improvement as when they are used right in the room or even on unused outlets right on my conditioner. So that ones bunk too.

    And finally, no wall warts after the conditioner? Have you looked at my system? Have you looked at ANY SYSTEM?! We're gonna get real basic now. Because what is a wall wart, anyway? Did you ever stop to ask yourself that question? A wall wart is nothing but a very simple power supply. Its a transformer, couple diodes, maybe a cap or two. That’s it.

    Now please do not take my word for it. Open one up and have a look for yourself. Then do the same with ANY component in your system. Because if you look at ANY COMPONENT in ANY SYSTEM you will find EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THEM has a transformer, diodes, and caps.

    Still, in fairness, don’t only knock, also be positive. Point out the stuff the guy got right. DMZ is indeed short for de-militarized zone. Well done.
    Yeah, actually it can work like that.

    Not long ago I had the exact problem Eric was referencing, with a streaming device's wall-wart smps causing noise that bled into my phono preamp. Some wall warts (the heavy ones) are indeed just a linear PS in a plastic case, others are SMPS and usually the culprit of circuit pollution.