My old Tannoy dual concentric Gold had two tone sound controls level behind ...
It could help especially if someone had no acoustic control in his room..
I cannot put an image as you did...
I dont know why...
Do Your Speakers have LEVEL CONTROLS or EQUALIZERS? (Vintage or Modern) ???
Do Your Speakers have LEVEL CONTROLS or EQUALIZERS? (Vintage or Modern)
MANY Vintage Speakers had/have Level Controls, and a few big speaker arrays had external equalizers.
..............................................................................
Many of you know It’s my contention ALL SPEAKERS should have Level Controls, to refine their frequency distribution in your space at your positioning in that space, and re-adjust for any space you move/use them in.
L-Pads retain impedance shown to the crossover; Potentiometers alter what is shown to the crossover a bit.
......................................
Just stumbled about these
2 Altec Lansing speaker crossovers N800-8K |
https://www.ebay.com/itm/313970394857
JBL’s
Bose 901
.................................................
My Uncle’s 1958 Fisher President II (Large 3 way, horns and big woofer) had/have 2 L-Pad level controls
AT-37’s used in many of their consoles and separates.
https://products.electrovoice.com/binary/AT37%20and%20AT38%20EDS.pdf
PRESENCE: for Mid-Range Horn’s Volume Control, relative to he 15" woofer with no control
BRILLIANCE: for Tweeter’s Horn’s Volume Control, relative to the mid-range.
.......................
My AR-2ax (compact 3 way cones) had/have 2 Level Controls
I just restored 2 pairs for my Office and Garage/Shop Systems
https://www.audiogon.com/systems/10092
..................................
MANY Vintage Speakers had/have Level Controls, and a few big speaker arrays had external equalizers.
............................................................
Do Your Speakers have LEVEL CONTROLS or EQUALIZERS? (Vintage or Modern)
After a few times, it get's very easy. 1. Image MUST be on the WEB, not on your computer. 2. Find Image on Web: right click it 3. 'Copy Image Address' (not copy image) 4. Here, in the window, top bar, click 6th ICON from the left: IMAGE 5. Pop-Up Box Appears, 'url address' default top line 6. Paste Image Address you copied (or go get it now) 7. Wait until the Image Size automatically fills the two size boxes 8. OK, image appears in your post.
|
While I agree that speakers benefit from being able to be altered for different placements and rooms I disagree that L-pads or even switched R arrays in a passive speaker are desirable. They are crap for reliability. Professional, active speakers have these features and IMHO are the correct way to implement them. Also, adjusting individual drivers is not really as good of an option for adjusting the output as having an upstream EQ or tone control. In general, the crossover points of a speaker and the human hearing and studio choices may or may not match up. The "loudness" button on my receiver will work correctly regardless of the speaker design. I'd hate to try to achieve the same thing with a set of level controls on a 2 or 3-way speaker. |
@elliottbnewcombjr wrote:
Sure, kind of; with outboard actively configured speakers just about the most elaborate kind of controls with everything from individual gain to each driver section, crossover points, delay, slopestyle and -steepness, etc. This is done via a digital crossover placed prior to amplification, and can be done from the listening position via a laptop/tablet realtime/on the fly. With the aid of measurements, the initial help from a friend well versed in this field, factory specs with recommendations and their measurements, lots of reading up and research plus countless hours of listening, the results have been fine-tuned to my specific acoustic environment and overall preference. |
My Apollo speakers are very adjustable in both the time domain and the amplitude domain via digital crossovers. All crossover parameters are easily adjustable. Adjustments can be made on the fly via tablet and multiple setting can be saved. I can toggle from one setting to another from my listening chair to compare or for different listening needs. Passive room treatment first then DSP is applied.
|
Sort of. In addition to the 2 stereo outputs, which run ESL's, I have two blended outputs with their own volume controls. These volume controls are downstream of the master volume control, and drive Magnepan DWM's. Basically it's an active crossover built into the preamp, so the effect is much the same - except for distortion. |
Yes, my FinkTeam KIM have two controls. They are very useful, and the first speakers that I have owned with such controls. This is how they are described in StereoNet:
|
Post removed |
Sound Lab speakers have three level controls, bass, midrange (really mid/bass) and brilliance. These level controls are not just for room acoustics. The frequency response of the speaker can change with the type of amplifier used. The changes are particularly severe for ESLs. This is a very important reason that some amps seem to sound better than others. An amp that sounds dull on one speaker can sound bright on another. Big solid state amps with extremely low output impedances will sound great on everything. This is not due to the power. It is due to the very low output impedance. |
@elliottbnewcombjr Wrote:
Yes! Mike |
I am focused on OEM Provided Level Controls and OEM Equalizers. My contention is OEM controls ought to be provided. OEM could offer optional equalizers for specific models Certainly decent and sophisticated non-oem equalizers can do a terrific job, however that is not for most people. A few who have controls do not use them. I certainly would get an inexpensive SPL, adjust them before room treatments. Amazon, 5 stars, $28.
Even if no level controls, these are great assists for refining speaker positioning and toe-in. After you get 'best', then it's up to your specific taste, and hearing which changes as you age
|
The IRS Beta has exceptional level controls, both on the midrange panels and the xover/servo unit. They are a double-edge sword, however, because while they allow the system to be set up properly balanced, it’s also easy to get it very, very wrong. But of course it’s worth it if you take the time to get it right. |
@elliottbnewcombjr The reason vintage loudspeakers have level controls is because the output impedance of the amplifier was an unknown. So the controls allowed the end user to adjust the speaker to get flat frequency response. They were not there to adjust the speaker to the room! Speakers that have controls like this are on the Power Paradigm. Speakers that are on the Voltage Paradigm (considered 'voltage driven') will not have any controls on the rear. For more on this see: |
Ralph, Electro-voice provided one AT-37 Level Control for their 2 way's (8 or 16 ohm versions) and two AT-37 Level Controls for their 3 way's (8 or 16 ohms). Their literature is clear: to adjust for 'live/hard' rooms, or 'soft/dead' rooms (of various degrees of soft or hard of course); for various locations in a space; for an individual's preference. ....................................... Lewm's opinion: best, for 'easily' matching left to right, is a resistor based level control. Certainly easier to match l/r frequency response than continuously variable L-Pads. Either type can be adjusted differently l/r for a particular condition in a space, like my AR-2ax's in my office: left speaker against a wall, right speaker not near walls Electrovoice's 4 way Model 6 (18" woofer)
has a 5 step resistor based Level Control, with published graphs of the frequency response of each of the 5 settings https://products.electrovoice.com/binary/E-V%20Six%20EDS.pdf Page 2, adjustment of balance control, is all about different spaces different tastes. ....................................... Their monster Patrician 800 (30" woofers) had level controls https://skyfiaudio.com/products/electro-voice-patrician-800-vintage-speakers-4-way-with-30-woofers
........................................... A speaker's impedance, then and now was and is nominal, and typical crossovers are designed for the nominal impedance, and transformer taps also anticipate a speaker's stated nominal impedance. . |
Level Controls: especially continuously variable type are: Easy to Screw Up, Hard to get ’right’, then: to taste, or to your specific hearing ability. Set in the middle, leave them alone, or use them as needed/desired. For many years, I would get a friend over, in a specific space, and simply mess with the balance controls until I, with my friends help, got what I thought ’best’, in that space, in that location, with ’that’ toe-in. All by younger ears. Adjusting base for tilt, to aim tweeters at seated ears came later. Infinite Slope Model 2’s with Slanted face also alters the angle of reflection from floors and ceilings, as does toe-in from side walls.
............................................ Covid Times, home all the time, unspent money, I upgraded my entire system Including a much more careful adjustment/matching of my 3 way speakers 1. Mess with toe-in, two alternates for best imaging a. one listener dead center b. two listeners, small drink table centered 2. Buy Inexpensive SPL with bottom fitting for Tripod Mount (ear height/listening position 3. Find my Amazing Bytes CD with Test Tones: tracks 9-38 of this CD
https://www.discogs.com/release/7290000-Various-Amazing-Bytes 4. Make enlarged copies of that page to write adjusted results on Back and forth, back and forth, sleep on it, back and forth 5. McIntosh Preamp’s Mode Control, Stereo Reverse, L to both; R to both ... page 8 6. VOICE Tests, Voice (and Instruments) cannot wander from their positions as frequency varies a. Cassandra Wilson, Blue Light Till Dawn b. Barbra Streisand/Donna Summer Duet, Enough is Enough c. Richard Burton, War of the Worlds d. Annie Lennox, Eurythmics, Sweet Dreams 7. Hearing Ability: even though the microphone hears the highs ’equally’, I am 74, I don’t hear highs as well as the mic does, So, raise the tweeters a speck at a time, get the wife to listen (women hear highs more than men), get my neighbor recording engineer over: raise, but not too much. Eurythmics is helpful for this. Get my younger audiophile friend over here (very familiar with my system). Not only best frequency for me in my space, the refinement of Imaging is revealed. The better you get your imaging, the more sensitive you are to great or not so great imaging, dumb decisions like having Max Roach right side, but moving Max to the center during solos. Now you love remote balance to make slight changes that make a bog difference. All imaging id Phantom, based on balance of L/R to create/locate ... here or there. Slight adjustment of balance improves Imaging of whole album or individual tracks (recorded different times/spaces/engineers). Gotta get it right, it ain’t easy, but wonderful results after careful work. Move to a different space: here we go again!
|
Of course, the big item I haven’t touched on, besides reliability is power. All resistive elements waste power, and as those contacts get dirtier the switches and knobs will waste even more power and heat them up. Modern, passive, multi-way speakers simply can’t avoid using resistors, that’s a matter of fact, but the more of this we can move to the active realm (i.e. low voltage/low current) the better we are. IMHO, the least audible, most reliable methods of doing this is how Wilson and other high end makers have done it, by using either replaceable resistors or plug in networks that allow you to select the right resistive value through a jumper wire. |
So, the answer would be "yes" to many (especially vintage) speakers. We do custom performance upgrades to modern and vintage speakers. My standard practice (if the customer is interested in performance) is to bypass the level adjustments and replace with high quality resistors. Measure resistance, verify with RTA, than listen. It may a little trial and error, taking the values up, or down a notch, but Invariably the speaker will sound better in my experience. But, admittedly, the ability to "tweak" the speaker a bit is forfeited in the process. I also find it worth noting that the factory attenuators and knobs remain in place, the speaker still looks "OEM" and it can be reverted to "stock" at any point in the future. I also make it a general practice to bypass protective fuses. These are serious sound de-generators. My rule of thumb is to bypass the fuse(s) IF: a) the driver, diaphragm etc IS replaceable by an OEM (or, better) device, b) the cost is not prohibitive, and c) the customer has had no instances of blowing fuses (maybe some exceptions, but too involved to detail here). If the owner has played the speaker with a high degree of enthusiasm for decades and not blown a fuse, the chances are low (to zero) that damage to a driver will occur in the coming decades. Please keep in mind that it’s not just a fuse. It’s a fuse holder with connections on both ends and a friction contact fit with the fuse. Not the most "audiophilish" approach to best sound quality. But, as mentioned, if the driver/diaphram is irreplaceable or extraordinarily expense, by all means keep those protective devices in place!! |
When I designed my DIY triamplified horn speakers a DEQX DSP was an integral part of the design. I wanted bass folded corner horns back in the corners and midrange and super tweeter horns well out in the room where they could image better. The DEQX corrected the large time difference between the woofers and the mids. The room correction facility, a ten band parametric equalizer, of the DEQX proved to be very useful and beneficial. |
@elliottbnewcombjr Yes, I'm sure the document said that; it would have been a bit of a task to get the user to understand that the correct setting is an interaction with the output impedance of the amplifier. You'll notice that by the mid 1970s these controls had all but vanished. Electro Voice and MacIntosh led the way pushing for the speaker to be 'voltage driven'. That eliminated the need for the controls. The Patrician was an amazing speaker. Thanks for the photos.
|
There is a pair of JBL L250’s for sale on US Audio Mart.
bluury, you get the idea, manual explains as ’their most sophisticated ... to date
https://www.audioheritage.org/html/profiles/jbl/l250.htm
They have a sophisticated set of optional level controls, shown in the manual here
|
Hopping about looking at Equalizers for a different thread, found this info about Vintage McIntosh MQ101 Environmental Equalizer Also Part 2: Room Resonances and Room Construction http://www.roger-russell.com/ml1cpg.htm#themq101
|