FWIW, I’m running the TP link powerline adapters. Due to location , I was limited to this or Wi-Fi. I was aware of this devise but ignored trying it until I saw it recommended by one of the streamer manufacturers as an alternative. I’m sure the idea will get hammered as this thread progresses, but it worked well for me Vs Wi-FI. If I had wall access I’d run Cat 8 or optical , but I don’t. Buy it on Amazon and utilize their 30 day return policy. We don’t know , if we don’t try. Cheers , Mike B.
Streamers/DACs
Just picked out gear for our new hifi room and I’m starting my search for a good streamer or streamer/DAC combo. We have Paradigm Persona 3F speakers, Persona Sub and Anthem STR amp. I’ve narrowed streamers options down to 3 well-reviewed choices: Aurender, Lumin T3, and Cary Audio DMS-700. Not sure if I’d go with the Aurender A15 which has the option to just do digital out if I feel the urge upgrade to a better DAC or start with the N200 and either use the Anthem’s DAC or buy a separate unit right off the bat. Mostly interested in streaming Quboz, don’t care about Roon. The audio room has no realistic way to add an Ethernet port so I’ll need to work around this with a Wi-Fi to Ethernet bridge (or comparable solution) if I choose Aurender or Lumin, whereas the DMS-700 has a built-in Wi-Fi option (but a seemingly rudimentary app by comparison to the others). Any experience with these products is welcome. Of particular interest would be experiences from other Persona owners and why they chose the streamers/DACs they did but all input is welcome. Thanks much, this forum has helped immensely in the build thus far.
“Mostly interested in streaming Quboz, don’t care about Roon.” Couple of considerations while choosing Streamer / DAC’s. If you choose N200, then I would pick a DAC that offers the best possible USB & SPDIF implementation. So before you open your wallet for N200, do your research on a DAC. |
I recommend using the DAC in the STR and getting an iFi Zen Stream or a Paradigm PW Link. Why go spend $$$ before you see the synergy between the Persona and the Anthem DAC. I have a Paradigm PW W Amp connected with a pair of Paradigm Reference Studio 20’s in another room. They voice these products with their own speakers, see how you like the Anthem DAC/Paradigm speaker synergy before changing it. |
Hey @brewerslaw - Not sure if you saw my post here about the A15 and N200, but you might find it to be useful:
I also responded to your last PM now on how you could use your WAP if you have one in your listening room. I have used Cary DACs in the past and they are "okay". Not the end in resolution. I worry about suggesting the DMS-700 to anyone regardless of whether the sound quality is good because Cary does not specialize in digital source playback ecosystems, which will result in a less mature/satisfactory user experience. |
I am now a very dedicated Aurender fan. I bought my first streamer Aurlic Aries G2 because it had built in wifi and Aurender didn’t. Mistake on my part. My dealer told me to just buy an wall wart wifi extender and plug it in next to the streamer… wow, that was easy. I found my first Aurender way better than the others I owned or auditioned. My Aurender produces vinyl quality sound. You can see my systems. I know of a number of $150K systems running off wall wart Wi-Fi’s with world class sound. I have a EtherRegen. I put it in on my main system. I recently took it out. I could detect no difference. I have swapped it in and out… also upgrading the Ethernet from wifi extender to the EtherRen. This actually caused a slight hardening of the treble. I though maybe the newly installed Ethernet cable needed additional breaking… but it was not going away. I finally decided a Cardas Ethernet cable would probably fix it. Then I realized with the $200 cable already on there, adding a $350 cable… I would be paying as much on cables just to stop the EtherRegen from interfering with the sound. That just seems wrong. So I just took it out of the loop. I don’t want anyone to think that I am suggesting EtherRegen will not help them. I believe the value of fiddling with your network is more valuable the lower the quality of your streamer. I have a flagship Aurender W20SE… and I believe it is very nearly completely isolating it from the network. When I have some time, I’ll put the EtherRegen in my headphone system with my Aurender N100 and hear what it does. |
we are apersona dealer and we sell servers the 432Evos we srll an amazing dac streamer from avik the S180 as per wifi vs ethernet a good wifi to ethernet bridge is your solution knowing the personas you should look at a very warm sounding dac aor adding a tube preamp most dacs with volume control will not sound as good as a dedicated preamp the naim nd5 xs is an excellent dac and streamer the naim app is excellent also the atoll st 200 is really musical dac preamp and streamer th bricasti m3is an amazing dac and has a decent volume control Dave and Troy Audio intellect NJ persona naim atoll bricasti dealers |
@ghdprentice Seems the EtherRegen is hit or miss depending on how the rest of someone's internet is functioning. I too could hear very little difference with it on its own and almost returned it until a friend suggested I try a Farad Super 3 LPS on it. I did so with a good aftermarket cabling, and that smoothed a lot out while bringing out more detail. It was an unconventional route as I paid more for the LPS and cabling than I did for the EtherRegen itself. Unfortunately I did something stupid and fried the LPS, so I took the opportunity to upgrade to the Synergistic Research Ethernet Switch UEF and called it a day. These solutions cost way more than they should but now that they are in place I am happy to have them. In my system, even while using wifi via a Netgear Orbi into the switch, streaming and local file playback are nearly indistinguishable, which was not the case before. |
My experience with EtherREGEN was a mix bag as well. It did more harm than good in my system and I end up moving away from it. When it first came out, there weren’t many options to tweak Ethernet so many reported positive feedback. IME, the impact of FILTERS and Switches greatly varies depending on what’s ahead of these devices. If you were using a high quality streamer, their impact may not be profound as opposed to someone using a Nucleus or iFI Zen. I keep an open mind when it comes to Ethernet tweaks and believe their is no substitute for trying them in your system to truly understand their impact. Like you, I got done tweaking my Ethernet chain when I switched to Telegartner M12 Gold Switch w/JCAT LPS. Further, my switch and router are grounded with a pair of Entreq Macro Ground Boxes, the additions of grounding boxes was like cherry on top :-) |
@lalitk Thanks for sharing your journey. I hadn't heard about the Telegartner until you mentioned it, but that looks like both a serious AND seriously overpriced piece of kit! :) JCAT makes incredible stuff across the board from what I've seen and heard. My only experience with them were their XE cards. |
Having tried a variety of streamers and DAC's I have decided to separate the functions. I use a Lindemann Limetree Bridge and Denafrips Ares 2. Firstly there is no use nor need for a display on a streamer, had several and never looked at them, tablet or phone is much better. Displays in CD players can be turned off, to reduce 'noise', so why have one at all. The screen failed in my Naim streamer making it impossible to re programme. Advice, ditch the screen. The DAC is far more important in sound quality than the streamer, by separates also means separate power supplies. The Denafrips have a good linear power supply. If you wish to upgrade DAC you can easily. I compared the Lindemann / Denafrips to Aurendar and Aurelic streamers at up 3 times the price. Could hear no sound improvement even in $100,000 systems, nor could anyone else. |
There's nothing inherently wrong with using WIFI for your streamer as long as the WIFI is consistent and can sustain bandwidth suitable for streaming audio (which really isn't that demanding). You can get a wifi extender with a hard-wire port on it (to connect to your streamer) for $50, probably cheaper. I stream hi-res audio, and 4k video over mine in a detached garage, with nary a hick-up. |
Lots of talk on how to improve Ethernet to the streamer. I am a big fan of Sonore and its use of optical to decouple your system from the noise on the line. USB to you Anthem and off and running. I am roon user so not much help with which software to use but they support many options to control the streamer all via software and a web page. It’s a nice simple and not to expensive way to get that job done |
I agree with @jerryg123 Don’t depend on anything but an independent DAC. Even in a great amp or streamer. DACS get radically better every year. I run a NUC server with an Innuos streamer and I have never heard anyone’s system at any price sound better than mine. |
The Lightning DS software from Auralic products is light years better than the aurender app and I prefer the Auralic products over aurender products. As good as lightning ds is, Roon is much better. As far as sound quality, I would take Roon or Audirvana over the others, followed by Auralic, then lumin. |
@jeffseight Listening Room gear is being set up now. The router and network switch are in a utility closet down one floor and on the opposite corner of the house with no unfinished or drop ceiling in between. Probably about two hundred of feet of physical space apart. Not literally impossible but real difficult to hardwire. |
Mytek Brooklyn Bridge II another great streamer too. But…… As for the LUMIN is has Leedh Processing Volume control. Meaning the streamer works as a pre amp (exceptionally well). Mytek does this too ( no pre needed) but not with Leedh. Worth a read on Leedh! There’s gobs of info on these forums about cleaning up your Ethernet connection. Some have reported great or little success with an EtherREGEN. I’m in the plus column big time and I can’t stress enough that upgraded linear power, and cables play a big roll. Could you run optical/fiber (cheap too) to your new setup?
|
Total unexpected 180 on my part: Did the free Roon trial, got hooked, and set up a new Mac Mini M1 Roon Core. I’ll be looking for a separate DAC that pairs well with the Persona 3Fs/Sub Strongly considering the following: Bricasti M1, Terminator Plus 12th, Chord Dave, and T+A DAC 200. Any thoughts, particularly from the Persona-knowledgeable? thanks much! |
Nice list of DAC options, so far. Please let me add this one. I’m having very good success pairing an Ayre QB-9 TWENTY with my Persona 3F’s. The Persona’s holistic imaging and full range, broad off-axis response is well supported. The TWENTY upgrade is essentially a new board with most of Ayre’s latest DAC technology. I’m running Cardas Clear and Cerious loom in fully balanced mode, but frankly with its built-in power filters and FPGA schemes, the DAC seems less dependent upon higher end connections.
|
Well I figured it out, the Auris audifi is limited to 44.1 from the coax digital output. I believe that it is something to do with the ability to hook up multiple devices and stream music at the same time. It sounds a little bit better when it comes out of the analog outputs . It looks like it is going to be a backup instead of something that I will use as a quality front end. I am just going to dig out my raspberry pi and save my $ for a unit to feed my new Dac. |