Timber decreased also
Class A, A/B vs Class D amp Soundstage
Good evening.
i just upgraded my Cambridge 850R Class A/B to Cambridge EVO 150 Class D with integrated streamer. I use B&W Diamond II with good cables and interconnects. So, there isn’t really a weak link in my system to be uncovered or exposed when going to a. Class D amp.
There actually is nothing I changed other than the amps
I lost all front to back soundstage. I lost 50% of my right to left soundstage (speaker position has not changed at all and is 6 ft from the back wall.
I stream hi-res from Qobuz. The mid-range sounds a tad bit muffled. The base drivers distort and lower top power than my other amp which remained tight in the base even at ear hurting volume.
The only and I mean only thing I did was change amps. So, I am wondering, does going from a class a/b to a class d amp cause a significant decrease in soundstage? So far, whatever it is, I don’t like it at all, not one kilo-bit
Sorry for the additional update. I can also describe it as the Class A/B sounded like I was sitting in front of the stage in a small venue. Yes, still an amplified system in that small venue and not the real guitar - unamplified sound. Now it sounds like I am listening to a hifi stereo. Hey, second question: does Anyone ever listen and like a center speaker for audiophile audio (not tv). Though, I would not know how to wire it in the system. |
I like CA streamers but haven’t heard their amps. I suspect that this is more of an implementation issue. Many megabuck audio companies such as Mark Levinson are using Class D in amps costing 5 figures and I haven’t seen a pattern of complaints such as yours. Having said that, I would trade your amp for non Class D |
I'm glad the OP was at least specific in his Classe D amp. Often we have something like "I switched to Class D and it was not as good..." with no mention of the actual amps used. Even so, this is not a good test. You should test against say, another integrated with built in streamer. Also, check out the NAD hybrid Class D amps and let me know what you think. |
@geworthomd , Welcome, welcome to the class D sht miracle (promised/touted by the advertising branches).....Now that you've learned your lesson, throw that class D garbage in the garbage can and go back to your AB..or even better yet, try some class A (could get a lil expensive), if you get a chance. |
Of course, nowhere in this discussion is the general thoughts about the speaker impedance, and that this is a tiny integrated amplifier that might just be mismatched to the speakers, or that this is otherwise an entirely new device vs. the original. We’ve simply thrown out all Class D because one very small integrated amp didn’t cut it. Never mind that in all classes of amps, different amps have different output impedance curves so amp X may perform well with a pair of amps but amp y may not. Before you throw out an entire class of amplifier altogether you need better control of the testing, and to use multiple examples of Class D. Otherwise, if it was me, I’d say all Class A was crap because I heard one brand of Class A amps and it hurt my ears. |
I’ve owned PS Audio class D. It was a must to leave amp on 24/7. If amp was put back in the system it could take 3 to 5 days before things sounded correct again. A/B amps would take maybe 24 and at most 48 hours and class A tube a few hours. Why class D took so long was a shocker the first time I discovered this. |
I agree with Erik Squires suggestion of checking out NAD Class D amps, but Zlone also nailed it on three separate items being changed by going to the CA all-in-one. Did you consider the all-in-one offerings by Naim? My Seattle Dealer carries both the EVO models and the full line of Naim all-in-ones and steered me clear of the Cambridge offerings if I could somehow go with Naim [even if used over new for the Cambridge]. |
I’m not that familiar with the Cambridge models you speak of but be careful lumping all Class D amps together. I own the Atma-Sphere Class D amps which I have directly compared to my Conrad Johnson Class AB amp in exactly the same system (like you did). The CJ amp although older is no slouch, but the A-S amps are still better in soundstage and all other respects as well. |
Thank you gentlemen. The reasoning is good behind your questions 1. B&W 802, 8 ohm, measured 6.7. Not changed. 3. Cambridge CNX into the Cambr 851a before. Similar streamer build in to Cambr EVO 150 second 4. The DAC’s are the ones inside each Cambr unit 5. Excellent idea on burn in. Bugger though, 4 days of 24 hours per day and no change 6. Double checked speaker wiring polarity 7. Highs on class d are fine. Mid is muffled like 1980’s technology. It isn’t distorted. Can crank it up but sounds like listening to an old K-mart as soon as plugged in. This is the mid section. Not noticed in the highs at all. They are crisp. 9. Lots of people saying the switch to class d in their other set ups are flat i reached out to a manufacturer of high end tube class d with built in dac if I get the chance I will review for now I’ll keep that card close to my chest anxious to hear if it does work out Not too many class d, tube and modern dac inside So, similar streamers by sane company. Burn in complete. Banana plugs on speaker wires. Qobuz hi res same songs. I have ideas but will wait for more replies first. |