I've experienced this dilemma a number of times in regard to audio equipment. Latest was being indecisive about which boutique 300B tubes to purchase for 300B amps. I researched and read every review from all over the interweb, easy to find both positive and negative experiences with every single 300B out there. My problem was the negative comments held greater salience than positive. This inability to choose lasted nearly a year before finally throwing dart at dart board and coming up with Psvane Acme. It could just as well been any of the other 300B's available, I still can't come up with any concrete reason why the Psvane won over others. The shame of this all is I lived with inferior 300B sound quality for nearly a year.
We live in the age of data, the problem is information has become cheap. Prior to interwebs we had relatively little information, what little we could gather was far more valuable. This relatively high regard for the information we gathered made it easier to make choices, we were far more trusting in sources. And the likelihood of having access to only positive or negative information was far greater than today.
Today, because information so readily available, we often get conflicting narratives. So, it comes down to who do we trust with so much information at our finger tips. Today, we not only have to make choices of what products, services to purchase, but also which information to trust, whose information do we trust? Decisions, decisions, decisions!
I'm not sure humans built for this much information, lots of cognitive dissonance today. And if it isn't cognitive dissonance, we build walls around the information and/or deliverer of information we decide to believe, we don't like to feel cognitive dissonance. I've long observed humans prefer blacks and whites to greys, this is world they can make sense of.
Seems funny to me that with so much information available we have far more chance of discovering truths about all sorts of things than we ever did prior. The problem with searching for truth is that we're likely to have come to wrongheaded beliefs and conclusions that are threatened by alternate explanations, facts.
Man, I just know I held to many truths years ago, not so much today. This is conundrum of the more you know the less you know.