Favourite Guitarists


This discussion was inspired by the recent article about our 3 favourite female singers.

Because it was impossible for me to pick just three female vocalists ( I love women singers), I will not put a limit as to how many you wish to vote for. I limited myself to a dozen. However, if you list more that 50 I will seriously question your decision making skills.

In no particular order, except for Rory at number one.

1. Rory Gallagher

2. Peter Green

3. Roy Buchanan

4. Joe Bonamassa

5. David Gimour

6. Slash

7. Johnny Winter

8. Duane Allman

9. Stevie Ray Vaughn

10. Mark Knopfler

11. Glen Campbell

12. Guthrie Govan

 

128x128tony1954

This is a good list for a select few genres…expand your music genres and you’ll expand your list….there are many many “great” guitarists and few, probably less than 50-100 “spectacular” guitarists.  

Two of my favorites that have not received any mention - 

Andrés Segovia

Eric Johnson

Ask any virtuoso guitarist what they think about them...and then be ready for an hour or so of enthusiastic comments on their playing!

 

BTW - I am NOT a guitarist, I am a bassist and drummer/percussionist.  

@bigpopsmusic 

"This is a good list for a select few genres…expand your music genres and you’ll expand your list…"

Good point. There's a heavy Rock bias here. Perhaps it's a generational thing?  

I listen to a lot of Jazz and my favorite Jazz artists are not guitarists. Perhaps 5% of my Jazz listening features guitar. 

Post removed 
Post removed 

@bdp24 Yep, I did... very sorry. Harrison's manhandling of a Gibson, SB is otherworldly

Was just listening to some Camel and thinking Andrew Latimer may be the most functionally expressive “rock” guitarist around. Always plays the right notes just right. Compare him to David Gilmour.

No one person is best in all regards. Each has unique strengths.

I think I remember Clapton (or was it George Harrison?) praising J.J. Cale once upon a time. Naturally, I went straight to the record store and bought the guy's album. The only words I could think of after listening carefully to the record for about a week were "low wattage" and "anonymous." It wasn't long before I brought the LP to the used record store. What can I say?

Another vote for a "highly underrated" uber-shredder:
(only one prior mention)

Mike Oldfield

 

How about Erik Clapton , Jimmy page,Carlos Santana , Robin Trower which btw rock hall of fame is a political joke Robin Trower is night and day better the many in there BTW, Tommy Emmanuel ,John Entwhistle  -Bass Only mentions  of lead guitar .

Unless I missed it, no one has mentioned the criminally underrated Chris Cain.  If you are a fan of great electric blues guitar (not to mention first rate vocals and hip compositions) check him out on Tidal, Spotify, etc… Albert King loved him.

Terry Kath (Chicago) gets my vote. Even Hendrix said he was better than himself.

As an Aussie, I must mention Red Symons who was guitarist for the band Skyhooks which found fame in the 70s for many reasons.

Nobody outside of Australia has probably heard of them - six songs from their first record were banned from radio airplay.

Not unlike Brian May, he has an astonishing intellect.

Jimi Hendrix

Jeff Beck 

Mark Knopfler 

Eddie Van Halen 

Grant Green 

Wes Montgomery

Kenny Burrell 

Slash 

Kirk Hammett 

Brad Whitford

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

My vote goes to Tommy Emmanuel, saw him play in a small venue in one of the Detroit suburbs last year, extremely gift man CGP..

 

Pete

Andres Segovia 

Ricardo (manita de plata) Baliardo 

Jimmy Hendrix

Steve Howe 

David Gilmore

Carlos Santana 

Jango Reinhart

Duane Allman 

Jimmy Page 

Eddy Van Helen 

Ritchie Gilmore 

Tony Iommi 

Joao Gilberto 

Stevie Ray Vaughan 

Steve Hackett

Robin Trower 

Mark Knopfler

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Many have mentioned Jimmy Page. Let’s not forget John Paul Jones who was the quiet man but nevertheless exceptionally talented and penned some remarkable Zep songs (at one point, perhaps an entire album).

Jimmy would have been lost without JPJ.

His subsequent solo releases are tremendous.

Go listen to Billy Cobham’s Spectrum album and listen to Tommy Bolin and see if he is worthy of anybody’s list.

 

Also:

Mike Stern

Nels Cline

+1 Bill Frisell

Steve Vai 

 

 

I remember enjoying the hell out of David Gilmore when I saw Pink Floyd live.

if "taste" is in the running versus "flash" ...

Richard Thompson (if you've seen him LIVE, you'll understand)

Stephane Wrembel (see previous comment)

Bruce Cockburn (OK, but try ...

Grant Green

Bill Frisell

 

I skimmed through all 5 pages.

You folks know your music.

Steve Howe and Tommy Emmanuel are top of the list for me.

Nice to see David Bromberg get some love.

Bruce Cockburn should be on this list but I didn’t see him mentioned often.

 I agree Richard Thompson live is something to behold!

Cheers!

mszmsi --  I have a John Renbourn guitar book. For a time I could play several of his solo tunes on my acoustic guitar. Then again, I probably haven't attempted them since the turn of the century. Have I mentioned that I saw Pentangle at the Troubadour?

Jeff Beck just jumped up to #2 on my list next to Jimi the Great. Rest in Peace "Master of the Vibrato arm".....

Forgot to add these two when I posted my first response:

Brian Setzer

Rick Nielsen

Another rather significant Aussie band from the 70s and early 80s was Cold Chisel.

Lead guitarist Ian Moss. This is an example (not the best recording or rendition).

Ian was not the lead singer.  An example of an original Chisel song, somewhat better recording.

@noske - I'm a big Cold Chisel fan, and just recently got that super-deluxe set of 'Circus Animals', with the framed signed photo and all. Yeah, Mossy is a superb guitarist - he sure lets it rip on songs like 'Letter To Alan' and 'Hound Dog'. They are still going strong and playing gigs down under. And Don Walker is such a good songwriter. 

@larsman And Don Walker is such a good songwriter.

Too right. As is Ian, and Steve, the drummer who penned when the war is over in the link I provided.

However this is a fave guitarist thread, so I won’t dwell on that aspect. Mossy truly gifted as a guitarist. And, oh, he can sing and write songs. Sadly I am not blessed to having witnessed Chisel live, despite many opportunities to being able to do so.