The Most Philosophical Song You Ever Heard


This may be a little too deeply personal for some, so reader discretion is advised. Don't know the reason, stayed here all season. Nothing to show but this brand new tattoo. But it's a real beauty, a Mexican cutie. How it got here I haven't a clue.
Blew out my flip-flop, stepped on a pop top, cut my heel had to cruise on back home. But there's booze in the blender and soon it will render that frozen concoction that helps me hang on.

millercarbon
"YMCA" played at certain political rallies kind of gets the philosophical mojo goin'.
Post removed 
Post removed 
Post removed 
Some great songs and deep stuff here...

My own favourite

Sit down young stranger
I also love imagine.  It is beautiful and simple. To despise it because it is simple is weird. 
That smell Lynyrd Skynard , 
Nights in white satin  and the orb
Landslide ,
the cats and the cradle Let it be 
the sound of silence
profound but all are different reflections of life 
every is open to interpretation.
Post removed 
I think Harry Nilsson said it best.   

"You're breakin' my heart
You're tearing it apart so f**k you"
Good one @jpwarren58  However, I believe it means 'Life Goes On' in Yoruba / West African / Nigerian...
@emrofsemanon,

"CD, that is a superb avid editing job on that one, wasn't it? :)"

It certainly is. That's the great thing about some fan edits, they're often better than the official videos.
Just shows that you don't always need big bucks if you're creative.

@j_husker,
"I wrote a paper my senior year at Creighton (English-Creative Writing specialty) outlining the influence of philosophy on modern rock music. I got an A."


Congrats. I guess if you didn't, you might have penned a treatise illustrating the fallacy of making value judgements on rock music critiques.

Personally I've never been much of a fan of philosophy but when you're in a semi darkened room listening to Joy Division...


[And all God's angels beware
And all you judges beware
Sons of chance take good care
For all the people out there
I'm not afraid anymore]


...you don't really have that much choice.
"I woke up this morning, feeling so blue.                                                                                        I did the Polka, there was nothin' else to do..."
                                      -Rotondi "Blue Polka"






my favorite would have to be Schopenhauer, for whom music functions as a kind of empirical validation of his entire metaphysics.


Keith Jarrett 
The Vienna Concert 
Bob Dylan,
Masters of War. Love Eddie Vedders cover of it also.:
The hour that the ship comes in.

Graham Parker
Blue Horizon
(a very sweet song)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FUjHJwIlFiU

My friends all grew up
And some went out
All around the world
And back again too
Some of them stayed put
In their hometown
Well there's worse things
That you can do
Some of them married
Couple of them died
Some of them just go
Along for the ride
Can't claim to understand
What it all means
Probably nothing
But that's not how it seems

Post removed 
Philosophical (as opposed to sentimental):

Iron Maiden-Rime of the Ancient Mariner 

Putting Cooleridge’s poem to music. Is this cheating?

Nearly anything by Rush- Xanadu, Trees, Farewill to Kings…Peart’s lyrics were heavily influenced by literature and philosophy, notably Ayn Rand. I wrote a paper my senior year at Creighton (English-Creative Writing specialty) outlining the influence of philosophy on modern rock music. I got an A. 


@emrofsemanon,

It's hard to top that one.

It works on just about every level you can think of.

Here's a tribute posted by YouTuber DarthNub,

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Ru9e2rTHeuk
"highly illogical" [charles r. grean, fred hertz]
From far beyond the galaxies I've journeyed to this place
To study the behavior patterns of the human race
And I find them highly illogical
Girl meets boy they fall in love
She says he's everything she's dreamed of
But when they get married before he's aware
She changes his habits the way he combs his hair
She changes him to someone he's never been
And then complains he's not like other men
Now really I find this most illogical
Take the case of your automobiles
Greatest invention since man discovered wheels
Hydra-Matic overdrive four-on-the-floor
Pushbutton windows pushbutton doors
Double barreled carburetors rush you anyplace
But you never can find a parking space
Highly illogical!.
take the case of modern man
He works all his life gives it all he can
Saves all his money works overtime
Pinches every penny banks every dime
All he can think about is money but you know
That he can't take it with him where he's going to go
Now I find that fascinatingly illogical
Now is the time to journey home to tell of what I've learned
My people I believe have every right to be concerned
For in spite of computers and advanced psychology
Behavior patterns are still a mystery
I predict the future of this earthly human race
Is that having made a mess of Earth They'll move to outer space
Well there goes the neighborhood
Totally, completely, absolutely, irrevocably, highly illogical
Post removed 
What is it about grumpy old cynical men? Innkeepers with all the answers. Have no room in their closed minds for Mary or anything that challenges their insular shallow minds. And the irony is the OP's thread ostensibly relates to philosophy. 
Lennon's "Imagine" strikes a chord for hope and a better world. Christianity began as a communal sect. It's growth and success were limited by such a concept so it changed to a more realistic organization. Gained much by doing so but an argument could be made it also lost something important. My interpretation of Lennon's lyrics is they explore the true radicalism of Christ's message.
I have to agree with Miller about Imagine. Even when I was young it made me cringe.
Todd Rundgren had (was in?  Kinda a fluid concept) a band called Utopia.   

On the album Swing to the Right the song "One World" offers a message of unity between all manner of common people. 

There is more (not Thomas More) but that'll do for now.
Leonard…darling of the right who are incapable of actually listening to..wait for it…..lyrics..

” Everybody knows the game is rotten, old Joe still picking cotton “..

Of course, when Ted is your great intellectual and bow hunter, quite a bit gets left on the table….
Post removed 
@millercarbon,

"Imagine is commie pabulum, insipid nihilism, made all the more slimy for its silky delivery. A worse song it is hard to imagine. Okay, We Are The World. But that’s about it. Kharma Chameleon is more intellectually and philosophically grounded."

Good summing up, though I’m sure we can all imagine a lot worse than We are the World.
And yes, Karma Chameleon is leagues better.

However, John Lennon’s Imagine might still have a place in kindergarten.

It might even get some of these very young adults wondering why less than 1% of people own more than half of the world’s wealth.

We can, for now, leave Yoko and John’s personal assets out of this.

Champagne Socialism could be the topic for a future lesson.
Post removed 
Imagine is commie pabulum, insipid nihilism, made all the more slimy for its silky delivery. A worse song it is hard to imagine. Okay, We Are The World. But that’s about it. Kharma Chameleon is more intellectually and philosophically grounded.
Let us pause in life's pleasures
And count its many tears
While we all sup sorrow with the poor.

Guess that one without Google 
"I wonder If you can."

Also +2 for Imagine.
Post removed 
Post removed