Great thread from the OP....
I think the same as him...
But there is two aspects of acoustic....
---Passive treatment of the room and precise location of the speakers are the first aspect ONLY...This cannot alone do all the job needed...
---Activation by mechanical adjustable Helmholtz resonators and diffusers to fine tuned the room and bent it for the SPECIFIC speakers needs and ears of the owner is very powerful and UNKNOWN to most people because it ask for a dedicated room... it is what i called Hemlholtz method for small room acoustic...
The only necessary costlier component is a dedicated room anyway, not costlier speakers upgrade especially if you own basic good one. already..
Dont upgrade before controlling the room...
Most of the times after controlling your room you will decide to listen to music instead of upgrading...
Recreation of music in a room is not an electronical engineering solution and question first and last, it is FIRST and LAST an acoustical question and solution....
The gear is there for the acoustic listening experiments...The acoustic is not there for the gear sake...Do you catch? You ears are the main gear anyway...
Remember the dog of RCA listening the acoustic pavilion of the rudimentary turntable ? It created a false impression in our subconscious, we were not dog we dont listen to turntable or amplifier or pavilion , we listen to and through a room... Speakers dont work alone, there is other gear behind them , and a room after them...
Sound is waves within waves... Complex pressure zones levels....Not abstracted lines coming from a wall or from the speakers...acoustic and psycho-acoustic is a bit more complex than this simple drawing to put in place some sold panels...
I know very little but i experimented a bit with my room and this is what i discovered...