John Lee Hooker/The Healer, Eric Clapton/No Reason to Cry
Best Sounding Classic Rock Cd's
Hi guys, new audiophile here and first time posting. As I improve my system I like to demo it to my friends. I know it’s hard to beat vinyl but I have found some CD’s that are well mastered and produced.
Hugh Laurie: Didn’t it rain and Let them talk.
Ronnie Earl: Grateful Heart and Steve Winwood: Back in the high life.
I’m looking for some recommendations on some Classic Rock CD’s or Blues, that are well mastered and produced.
I know you guys would be the ones to ask, Thanks Jim
44 responses Add your response
Believe it or not, the CD Stadium Arcadium by The Red Hot Chili Peppers fills the bill and is really good rock music. Individual songs that rock and are great recordings include the Snake bite song about Heroin on a Godsmack album, and "Like a Stone" on the Audioslave CD with Tom Morello, of Rage Against The Machine:on Guitar. This is one of the truly great rock guitar solos of all time, along with Martins Barre's solo on Jethro Tull's newer recording of "Aqualung Live" , If you like Blues, "Buddy Guy Live" is great, and his "Living Proof' is fabulous, especially when he decides to play like, but much better than, some imposters, at least after you hear this, :Only Three D Strings are necessary Slash, and the Van Halen genre of wannabe great guitar players. Buddy blows them away his later recording are as good as rock and blues can be.. A recording that is very interesting for a while, but has some great recording is the original "All Jamaica All Star Jazz Band, with absolutely great recordings of the trumpet and sax solos that jump into the room with you. The vocals on (Yes this is true, honestly.) "My Boy Lollipop" and "Walk On By" are astounding, bringing new life to songs I never even liked. |
Heart Dreamboat Annie, Pink Floyd The Wall, Emerson Lake & Palmer 1971 self-titled Tank/Lucky Man, Eagles Hotel California, Fleetwood Mac Rumors, Supertramp Breakfast in America, Dire Straits Brothers in Arms as well as Love Over Gold...all are excellent albums, both performance, and recording. A real treat on vinyl. :-) |
I’m surprised no one has brought-up one of the most classic of classic Rock - the Led Zeppelin remasters. The first three albums are really great remasters. I particularly like LZ III with all the acoustic guitar stuff. From Zoso on their not quite as good imo than the first 3, but all are major upgrades from the previous releases. btw, I want to make a special shout out to the mastering on Robert Plants, Fate of Nations. It’s probably one of the 3-4 best sounding masters on my system. It’s very classic rock like, even though it’s much later. This album I always play when demoing my system to other people. They are always wowed! Oh, and I almost forgot, the Beatles Love CD is the best you'll ever hear the Beatles sound. I can't understand why Capitol didn't let Giles Martin remaster the entire catalog. He made the music sound like it was recorded in the modern era. To hell with that "Capitol sound". |
Hmmm . . . surprised that two of my classic choices haven't been mentioned! Pink Floyd's Dark Side Of The Moon (I prefer the Sony Mastersound only slightly over the 24 bit new stereo mix) and Welcome to the Machine (I prefer the new stereo remaster slightly over other versions). Magnificently recorded at the time, I have always used DSOTM as my classic rock test album for equipment. Traffic's Low Sparks of High Heeled Boys remaster is also very nicely done and a great albums well! |
Certainly Rumours by the Mac.Big Stars records with the work of John Fry of and at Ardent Memphis. it's not classic rock by any means, but if you'd like something well recorded played produced mixed mastered, with a great sound stage. Buena Vista Social club. Jerry Boys a Brit with tons of time behind the console.If you'd like something closer to classic rock, he did Two Shoes by the Cat Empire. Both records done in a very primitive studio in Havana, but you wouldn't know it to listen. http://www.allmusic.com/artist/jerry-boys-mn0000276697/credits Dire Straights Making Movies by Shelly Yakus. Of equal skills and time.A number of early Petty records and Lennon. http://www.allmusic.com/artist/shelly-yakus-mn0000023547 Jay Messina http://www.allmusic.com/artist/jay-messina-mn0000811933 David Thoener http://www.allmusic.com/artist/david-thoener-mn0000811742 Jim Scott http://www.allmusic.com/artist/jim-scott-mn0000348633 3 of these guys worked at NYs Record Plant and made jaw dropping sound. One thing to be aware of. Many CD reissues before 2000 were made from LP EQ'd masters. That is not the same as the LP master or flat master tape.EQ'd masters are made for LPs to compensate the physical limitations of the vinyl LP, especially as the needle gets closer to the center on a 25 minute side. Here's a bit of a read on EQ masters, if you are unfamiliar.http://www.realhd-audio.com/?p=1612 |
The Moody Blues reissued their first 7 on SACD in 2006. If you like their trippy albums, I'd start with In Search of the Lost Chord or To Our Children's... If you like their more song oriented albums pick A Question of Balance or Every Good Boy Deserves Favor. Good stuff. Every Good Boy... probably has the edge sonically, but A Question... is a beautiful album. |
| Post removed |
I think that once you've admitted you're a vinylholic you're not going to be able to convince yourself any cd is as good to the ear. That said, there are trade offs for convenience. One doesn't always want to be running to flip vinyl while cooking or entertaining, so the cd changer is my trade off in that situation and I agree with the comments on the improvements made in most of the remasters and the phenomenal job Bluenote has done with late 1950s jazz recordings. I'm happy most of my vinyl is still in good shape from the late 1960s on. I'm hoping for a continued rekindling of hybrid sacd issues because to my ear they seem to bridge the gap and only need to be changed half as quickly as lps. But when I really want to hear the old rock or classical music sound its fullest, even the sacd seems to be wanting. What is truly sad is how much money I wasted on just the opposite of what you're looking for. So many of the early CDs sound so flat that I can't bring myself to listen to them unless I just don't have the vinyl. Has anybody had much luck buying second hand vinyl? I've bought a dozen or so but I never can understand how the sellers, although highly rated, could classify them as Mint or Near Mint. Often I find I'm taking about an ounce of dust out of the grooves before I play them and the snap, crackle, and pops drive me crazy. |
I agree with many of the comments posted. Heart for reasons unknown to me(maybe they did know a "Magic Man") produced very good recordings. Not familiar with Heart-Heart(1985 and later recordings), Billy Idol's earlier recordings sound good to my ears. I would also add The Doors-Morrison Hotel. The problem with digital is your not sure which remastering is best or is the original cd pressing best? With vinyl the original is almost always the recording to get. |
Supertramp- Crime of the Century Jethro Tull- Aqualung (40th anniversary ed.) Allman Brothers- Idlewild South (deluxe ed.) Look for classic rock albums remastered by Stephen Wilson. He has a tasteful ear and high standards. In the blues department, try some Duke Robillard or Sugar Ray Norcia era Roomful of Blues. Sugar Ray Norcia and the Bluetones cds are all well recorded as well. There are many. many more.... |