External DAC's are pretty expensive imho... BUT I don't know that much on how to choose one. I want mostly cd's in my small two channel system... I am rebuilding after selling my Logans and Mac amp to go back to "drivers"! The Logans wore me out with Maintenance. Should I buy a new cd player or get a new DAC for my old player?
Also, if you like a cold/analytical sounding dac, get a benchmark.
A device can not be cold (emphasizes kids and treble; opposite of warm) and analytical (transparent, no color) at the same time. The Benchmark is indeed the latter.
I am real... at least the IRS and my mortgage company think so. lol
The question was "are" they overpriced.
I am a lifelong musician and almost all of my tube amps are custom built and I play PRS guitars with mostly boutique effects pedals so I understand what goes into making high end equipment.
I am looking to run a simple simple cd-preamp-amp-speakers-gin n tonic- comfy chair system.
Now... lots of folks want me to run a DAC with my current cd player which played well but is an older model. Looking into this I have found the price of a standalone DAC to be ALL over the map. I understand this and how it works BUT DAC's seem to be very trendy at the moment ( no disrespect meant) and I can't see paying 3-20 thousand dollars for one, nor can I, and want to discuss "if" they are the trending component at the moment. I don't know much about DAC's as a component and came here to learn a few things... do I need one with such a simple setup? :)
My advice would be to get yourself a DAC with also preamp possibility (volume control) and built-in streamer (Tidal). Bluesound Node 2i and Teac NT-505 would be fine with Teac more expensive. The Node 2i has a usable active crossover.
Will you hear a difference? Depends on your golden ears. Takes a lot of experience. When some are talking of huge differences, in my opinion, these are subtle for most of us.
There seems to be a trend here that for pennies on the dollar you can get a great sounding DAC and it's all based on measurements.
Good luck with that. Measurements don't mean dick unless it's properly implemented. That, and you're following folk who admit they can't hear all that well.
Watch out for the people that are trying to sell you something. Also, if you like a cold/analytical sounding dac, get a benchmark. Some dacs are overpriced and there are good dacs priced fairly cheap. I wouldn’t buy a non-fpga type dac, you are too locked in with current technology with little to no way to upgrade to future technologies without paying a premium for the upgrade.
without more data anyone who answered is ignorant. On what basis do you find DACs overpriced? what have you listened to? Do you even know what t takes to build a truly good, o great sounding DAC?The D--A process is fraught with complexity, some of which i m just realizing - albeit it's obvious hen an engineer "gets " it. what's hour real goal? Great sound? The best digital sound available today? Digital and analog today have complementary strengths. I wish one had both. My goal is to build something with both, but toady that's either impossible or costly. Get real and ask a question that cna be honestly answered. G
You are getting a lot of varied opinions, bogus results and misinformation here. Be careful what advice you take seriously.
Al it takes is a jittery source and all DAC's will sound similar.
Al it takes is a cheap active preamp to make everything sound homogenous and 2-D.
Systems are complex and every single part of the system from the power to the cables to the components, signal processing and software apps must be optimized in order to get stellar results. Any one of these that is sub-standard can ruin the whole pie.
Not that you need to spend a fortune to achieve this. On the contrary, if you are smart and selective and take advice from the RIGHT people, you can get there on a budget. I think for an entire system, the threshold is probably $20K-$30K. Anything below that will tend to be mid-fi with 2-D presentation between the speakers IME.
It all depends on what you want your system to sound like. If you can use a soldering iron then change a few parts in your CD and pre and see what happens. Most of the DACs I have heard in the $2K to $5K range really don't float my boat. They very similar characteristics some do on one thing better than the other but not much to my ears in sound differences. The Berkeley Alpha DAC mention was nothing exceptional when I owned it. Same with the Benchmark. The Schitt again to my ears nothing special. To me you are better off modifying one of your components that to buy a cheaper priced DAC. You do not need a very expensive transport either as mentioned above to mate with a higher priced ( better DAC price does not dictate the sound). These DACs if you look under the cover are not using any special parts like V-Caps, Duelands, Caddock resistors so to me they are nothing special. You can but these better parts in your current components and to me achieve a much better sound in your system.
I owned a wyred4sound DAC1LE femtoclock, well over $1k, sold it to play around with analog for a while, ultimately replaced it with an iFi DSD Black Label which far surpassed the W4S in SQ and flexibility. DACs are still changing rapidly and the quality one can get for under $300 is astounding, IMO.
Aside from the preamp choice, (the Parasound P6 is an excellent one), you could add the Oppo UDP-205 as your CD/DVD/Blue-ray source because it has the famed ESS Sabre ES9038Pro DAC. In addition to any type of disc, this unit has a ton of ways to add a digital source - HDMI, ethernet, wireless, coax, Toslink, and USB DAC inputs. The accepted formats of the digital source start with simple mp3 and go up to DSD and MQA files. Hook this up to your preamp using the HDMI (analog only), unbalanced (RCA), or balanced (XLR). Enjoy!
The Oppo costs ~$1500 if you can find one - Oppo recently stopped making them. They will only get more valuable as they become scarce IMHO.
Steve- would you say the transport is then irrelevant in terms of sound quality if using Synchro-Mesh or Benchmark DAC3 ? Thanks
Pretty much. Low jitter on the input side of the SM helps a little, but not much. The output side always sounds great.
You should listen to the Benchmark before you buy.
Most modern DACs have reclockers or similar circuitry inside so that they can claim jitter is a non-issue. It still is an issue with the vast majority of them because low-jitter input lowers the jitter of the internal PLL circuitry. They additionally have the disadvantage that they don't deliver the SQ possible when driven by extremely low-jitter sources like the Synchro-Mesh. The SM helps, but not as much as a DAC without reclocker on the input.
Like all digital circuitry, the devil is in the details. It's not just the chips used or the digital techniques. The big differences in sound quality come from optimal circuit implementation, circuit design, power supply design and decoupling cap implementation. There are literally millions of choices that the designer makes that can degrade the sound quality and still end-up with a functioning design.
DAC technology has improved by leaps and bounds in the past couple of years. Which is why I won't spend more that $2K on a DAC, and from a company that will provide upgrades. My choices would be Schiit, Ayre, Mytek, in no particular order. Bob
You can get better performance from a Transport and DAC compared to the CD player, providing you minimize the jitter from the Transport. There are essentially three ways to do this:
1) Buy a really expensive transport, say $15K 2) Add a Synchro-Mesh reclocker and a good BNC cable to your existing transport and add a DAC with good SQ 3) Buy a DAC that is immune to jitter like the Benchmark DAC3
My recommendation is to get a Metrum or Border Patrol DAC and add the Synchro-Mesh and my Reference BNC cable. These combinations will enable the extremely low-jitter of the SM to benefit the DAC sound quality because these DACs have no internal reclocking. When you use separate transport and DAC, the only consideration is the jitter and minimizing it.
I am sure the Mac pre is better than the Parasound P6. Doesn’t sound like a good move to me. I owned Parasound, a Halo Integrated. While it was ok for the price, it didn’t move me the way the Mac integrated did. The Parasound had less body to the music than the Mac.
I think you could rather say, is all HiFi overpriced? My answer would be yes. Having said that, DACs may be one area where there are bargains or relative bargains. Companies like Mytek,, Metrum, Rega. Chord, and others, make some great kit at reasonable prices.
Looking at HiFi from a business perspective, the problem seems to be about scale. The golden age for Hifi, the 60's to 80's say, then every home aspired to a good HiFi system, now only a small %. If you are spending money on R&D, tooling production facilities and you only sell a few 100 or 1000 units, it is going to be expensive.
The CD player is a Denon DVD 2900... she has served me well... I'm thinking about selling my Mac pre and buying a Parasound P6... has all the features and (I think) a great DAC built in. It's confusing for me...
You must have a verified phone number and physical address in order to post in the Audiogon Forums. Please return to Audiogon.com and complete this step. If you have any questions please contact Support.
