Need some help with Brandenburgs

@dodgealum: Yes! I too have the Fuller boxset, and share your opinion. I like the composition enough to have multiple recordings of it, others (in addition to the Pinnock) being Nikolaus Harnoncourt on Telefunken, Gustav Leonhardt on Phillips, and Karl Richter on Archiv. Fortunately, all feature excellent recorded sound quality.

You may want to decide first whether you want a recording featuring modern or original instruments. Since you mention Pinnock perhaps the latter is preferred. In that case I’d recommend the Smithsonian Institution’s box set featuring Albert Fuller leading Aston Magna. Beautiful analogue recording and widely available at your local used record shop for $5-6. 

@notify: If you like Pinnock’s Brandenburgs, look for his recordings of Handel, Rameau, and Scarlatti on the UK label CRD. Great performances, excellent recorded sound quality (the harpsichord is in your room!) and LP pressings.

Ok, great, I was thinking I should go with Pinnock, so you (mostly) have confirmed that for me.

Thank you

Oh, I just realized the OP wanted vinyl.  The Leonhardt set and Karl Ristenpart on Nonesuch were my recordings until I didn’t have to extract music from slabs of fossil fuel.  The Ristenpart was sadly never (?) digitalized, but the Leonhardt was resides on my phone

The Decca London recordings FFrr (Full Frequency range recordings) should not break the bank and sound very good indeed. CSA.2225 "BRITTEN CONDUCTS BACH'S BRANDENBURG CONCERTOS ENGLISH CHAMBER ORCHESTRA"

Matt M

I don’t think Jordi Savall’s recording is on LP, but just CD/SACD.  I don’t really like Richter’s interpretations, or rather the recordings of his performances, probably due to the poor recording capability when he was recording.  I think Pinnock may be my favorite, although the one by Swartz is good also, but not quite the same quality of interpretation as Pinnock.

There are dozens of good recordings out thee.  I second the Savall recommendation, Pinnock, Reinharde Gobble, Marriner, Gustav Leonhardt et al on Sony...

Pinnock, Akademie für Alte Musik Berlin, and Savall all worth exploring.  Among the older recordings, Richter is highly regarded.

Inexpensive, and good SQ-1965 pressing