Guess How Big My Speakers Are


If you read any of my threads on here or looked at my virtual system you probably already know the answer to this question, but for those who have not, try this as a thought exercise. Given this plot alone how big a speaker do you think this is?

Frequency response plot showint extension to 20 Hz

 

Hints:

  • 2’ from sides, 1.5’ from rear
  • Ported
  • Not horns
  • No EQ applied. This is the natural in room response using short sine sweeps.
  • For a living room this is a well treated room with GIK soffit traps, bass traps and diffusion panels strategically placed.

I’ll reveal my answer if we get 5 guesses or more. :)

erik_squires

Not that it matters that much, but my distances for the speakers and listening location were off. 

 

8' apart, center to center, and 8' from the plane of the speaker's to the microphone  location.

I believe you have some Monitor Audio or Wharfdale floor standing speakers?

Nope, nothing fancy like Nelson Pass published in his paper about high impedance amps and speaker matching. 

 

Speakers are being driven by a quite normal Luxman 507ux.  I mean, I like the Luxman, but there's nothing unique about their specs.  Just a decent solid state amp with reasonably low output impedance.

If the amp has a high output impedance the speaker might have a much higher output in the bass resonance area than one would expect. Nelson Pass demonstrated this at a RMAF about 10 years ago using a current source amp and open baffle speakers.

The distances from the wall also influence the speakers; if inside the room boundary effect a +3dB per octave gain will be seen from about 100 Hz down.

I'm thinking this could easily be a 2 way ported box with 8" high excursion woofer.

 

your listening situation tells me that you have medium sized floor standers similar to Paradigm Studio 100 or Sonus Faber Grand Piano.

Speakers are about 11' apart, with a listening/mic location about 12' from the plane of the speakers.

This is most definitely an in-room response sort of scenario as opposed to quasi-anechoic (i.e. not close microphone).

This could be the curve of any loudspeaker because Erik has not told us where the mic is. You can get that kind of bass out of an LS3 5A if you put the mic one foot away from it. The mic is obviously farther away as you can clearly see room nodes in the bass. There is a strong one at 30 Hz which is boosting the bass but 20 Hz is 8 dB down and is down even lower at other parts of the room. I would guess without the node the speaker starts rolling off at 40 Hz. Volume also makes a difference. This is probably a smaller tower or medium sized bookshelf speaker. Something with two 8" woofers or one 10" 

 

Since that bass response would make everyone thing of large floorstanders, I'd guess bookshelf monitor size...or the post would pose far less intrigue 😉 

Cheers,

Spencer