Rja, I'd say the same for string quartettes or quintets, but would doubt about chamber music that often needs a professional orchestration.
73 responses Add your response
The test of time can be misleading. Historical happenstance, political/economics and cultural nationalism have as much an influence over what art survives hundreds of years as the quality of the art. Classical music - the highest achievement in western history? Very debatable, at best. My short list of higher ranking achievements: collected works of Wm. Shakespeare theory of natural selection men landing on the moon/Voyager 1 & 2 "Moby Dick" KAJ's skyhook the Allied victory over the Axis Albert Einstein |
Silly,classical music is the highest acheivement of the wetern world,there are a hundred great composers with a high level of popularity among those with the taste and refinement to listen to same.Even allmighty Bach has no real populsr popularity. I suspect(strongely) there were be NO current acts even known a hundred much less three hundred years from now. Popular music is utter garbage plain and simple. |
Schubert must be somewhat popular in that his music is still reknowned years later, as is the case with many famous classical composers. So are you saying that Schubert should be topping the charts and not the BEPs or Katy Perry? Will today's pop acts still be popular 100 years from now? Time is the true test no doubt. It will be a different world then for sure..... BAch, Teleman and Handel are pretty much the only original modern music makers of note to western civilization (can't speak for eastern or other non western civilizations or cultures which might have a different perspective) that have achieved or retained a high relative level of popularity hundreds of years later. I suspect only a select few acts from teh last 100 years will achieve a similar legacy 300 years from now. |
Once Tchaikovski was asked to compose something popular and simple so the general public with basic piano skills (and certainly with no possibilities to get stereo system) would play and enjoy. So he started releasing sheet music published in the monthly magazine for the length of one year. Anybody has an idea what's the name of this piece? If not, ask for the answer! I believe that mentioned public realy knew how to appreciate what it takes to make music. |
And you expected.....? So what. Pop music is what it is. Take it or leave it. Lots of other choices out there. Katy Perry is a lot hotter than MJ though. Barbra Streisand (even in her prime) and Bob Marley too! I bet even The Partridge Family outsold most of the more "Serious" pop acts in their day. I like TIc TOk. Fun song! ANd a lot of BEPs as we all know as well, especially Fergie. I bet Marley would really like the song "Union" by BEPs. It is very good and a good recording to boot (for that kind of music): "[Chorus] (One for all, one for all) (It's all it's all for one) Let's start a union, calling every human It's one for all and all for one Let's live in unison, calling every citizen It's one for all and all for one We don't want war- can't take no more It's drastic time for sure We need a antidote and a cure Coz do you really think Mohammed got a problem with Jehovah We don't want war imagine if any prophet was alive In current days amongst you and I You think they would view life like you and I do Or would they sit and contemplate on why Do we live this way, act and behave this way We still livin' primitive today 'Cause the peace in the destination of war can't be the way There's no way, so people just be a woman, be a man Realise that you can change the world by changing yourself And understand that we're all just the same So when I count to three let's change [Chorus] Got no time for grand philosophy I barely keep my head above the tide I got this mortgage, got three kids at school What you're saying is the truth that really troubles me inside I'd change the world if I could change my mind If I could live beyond my fears Exchanging unity for all my insecurity Exchanging laughter for my tears [Chorus] I don't know, y'all, we in a real deposition In the midst of all this negative condition Divided by beliefs, differences and religion Why do we keep missing the point on our mission? Why are we killin' each other, what's the reason? God made us all equal in his vision I wish that I could make music as a religion Then we could harmonise together in this mission Listen, I know it's really hard to make changes But two of us could help rearrange this curse Utilising all the power in our voices Together we will unite and make the right choice And fight for education, save the next generation Come together as one I don't understand why it's never been done So let's change on the count of one It takes one, just one And then one follows the other one And then the other follows another one Next thing you know you got a billion People doing some wonderful things People doing some powerful things Let's change and do some powerful things Unity could be a wonderful thing [Chorus]" |
I have to say to this article, so? So what? Most people only listen to radio and unless you listen to college and 99% dont then you are spoon fed the same 500 songs most your entire life in any genre, country, pop, soft adult, rock so what do guys who make dumb lists expect? Its not the publics fault they dont know better and most really like their musical crap lives just fine so you cant save people that dont want saved. Live and let live, dont bother openly talking about this at the holiday party, you will just look like a snob. |
I think it says AT LEAST as much about the world population explosion as it does about popular culture. When most of the artists being compared to were at their most active (60's and 70's) the world pop was around 4B. Now it's more than twice that, and so is the music buying public. So before making such comparisons, the numbers need to be adjusted. |
Funny. It puts into context all the audiophile complaints about people not paying attention to sound quality. Re Barbra Streisand, objectively, I view her as a superior musician to acts like Pearl Jam (every song sounds the same) and Tom Petty, so I'm not sure what is so outrageous about her outselling those acts. I'm not sure why Katy Perry is inferior to Michael jackson, either. And is Keisha even good-looking? |
made it easier : http://www.buzzfeed.com/daves4/12-extremely-disappointing-facts-about-popular-mus Makes you wonder about a lot of them.... |