Network Acoustics Eno Streaming System vs SGC Optical Isolation System


Has anyone directly compared between the two? If my conversion isn't off, it looks like the Eno Streaming System is roughly $1,000 compared to the SGC Optical Isolation System at $350 (sale) w/linear power supply. 

Eno:

https://www.networkacoustics.com/product-category/streaming-systems/

SGC Optical System: 

  

128x128Ag insider logo xs@2xtoro3

@sns that is exactly what I did with this affordable LPS that can accommodate providing power to both Optical converters.

Actually, it was really simple. Also having a kick ass DAC and Innuos Zenith helps. 

 

Optimizing FMC isn't as simple as one may believe. There is generic route via switching power supplies, generic with one or two lps. Then there is the Sonore route via upgrading FMC (two OpticalModule) only or FMC and optical streamer, these can be powered via various quality LPS. And then we can upgrade Sonore products with this, https://audiophilestyle.com/forums/topic/62352-finisar-sfp-modules-for-audio-grade-network-switch-group-buy-for-audiophilestylecom/ My next experiments will include Finisar SFP industrial grade and optical cables.

 

 

+1 @audphile1 on the passive filter.  I have a Muon in each of my systems and a nice improvement!  In one of them I also still have the Ether Regen in front of the Muon.  It adds, but not as much as the Muon.  

I like the passive nature of the Eno which also equates to less cables - I would imagine the passive nature bypasses any noise that it may otherwise induce if it were being powered, which is what we’re trying to reduce with an LPS for the last FMC, right?

Exactly. After trying fibre optic FMCs and iFi power supply on the switch, I opted for the Network Acoustics Eno streaming System directly from the EERO mesh access point. No switch. I liked what I heard. To me it sounds fuller and more natural than what I’ve heard with the FMCs.
The Eno also does not introduce any additional noise due to its passive design and cleans up enough of the incoming garbage. I also ended up eliminating all of the clutter associated with the FMCs and switch. It’s a more of a neat installation that brings in enough of an improvement to not need all the extra modules, power supplies and cables.
Few important things to take into consideration…components first and foremost. Clean power. Then filters and cables.

Appreciate the discussion. For a while I've felt like the amount of tweaks that could be done to enhance streaming and reduce noise can be overwhelming to grasp - FMCs, ethernet cables, LPS, servers, modems, switches, passive devices (Eno), routers, hard wired from a mesh system vs WiFi, etc.

For the past two months I've tried to educate myself and played around with some cheap switches, RF/EMI shielding tape around cheap switches, new modem, placement of hard wired mesh system/point, and cheapish ethernet cables to see if I could hear a difference before taking a deeper dive. 

For my wallet I was hoping NOT to hear a difference, but I do. This practice unfortunately reaffirmed my belief that everything matters in this hobby. 

@jjss49 appreciate your experience. @oddiofyl and @jerryg123 and @ddafoe appreciate the links - I have them in my wish list.

I like the passive nature of the Eno which also equates to less cables - I would imagine the passive nature bypasses any noise that it may otherwise induce if it were being powered, which is what we're trying to reduce with an LPS for the last FMC, right? 

I replaced my EtherRegen (fiber into the A side) and LPS1.2 power supply with the following converter and an iFi power supply.   I couldn't hear a difference after the switch.   I purposely picked the StarTech just because it wasn't the cheapest (actually is pretty pricey compared to $20ish ones on Amazon).   I have no idea if it makes a difference over the $20 ones but bang for buck compared to the EtherRegen was a big bonus for me at least.   Just adding 10 feet of fiber between my router and EtherRegen or StarTech was the biggest improvement for me, outside of buying a pretty decent streamer.

 

@kota1 the fiber option is going to eliminate EMI and RFI as noise cannot travel across fiber. It is just blacker, cleaner. Add the LPS to eliminate the 5v switching and noise. The LPS facilitate both fiber converters. 

I hope this helps. 

@jerryg123 , I am about to upgrade my ethernet and was looking at geting the Add-Powr Symphony I/O. It is about $500. Then I look at the fiber solution you posted and think it may work but is it too subtle, and then you have to add more boxes. Opinion?

@arafiq this is what I am using, and you will need to pick up an extra cable. 

 

@jerryg123 Thanks for sharing. I used the same converter when I owned the Sonore opticalRendu bundle.

I'm using Node 2i in the second system. Can you think of any reason why this won't work with the Node? Is there a way to add an LPS?

I run the fiber from my router to my system (45 feet), then a switch, then Network Acoustic’s ENO (earlier model of Muon).

You can use both, it is not an either/or proposition.

The fiber is much, less expensive as posted by @jerryg123 and @oddiofyl. As another example, here are two converters for $42, and a 5V linear power supply for $86, and SC/SC dual fiber cable for $16/10M (dirt cheap). A 10M fiber set-up with LPS for $144.

i have both currently, compared carefully, i feel they work equally well (which is very well indeed) - leaves the music sound calmer, blacker backgrounds, cleaner tighter deeper bass, all that good stuff, so to speak

specifically, i use the optical sfp slot out of my etherregen a-side into an optical rendu with lps feeding both... that may be net net a lower noise solution than using a lowest common denominator fiber modules and switching power supplies

Here's how I optically isolated my system

TP  Link.    TL! SG2210P.   10 port switch with 2 SFP slots

 TP Link      MC220L.  Media convertor ( two)   

(4)  10g SFP  modules

2 LC fiber optic cables 

This switch allowed me to have a separate fiber optic connection to both my Vault 2i  and Aurender N200

Works great,  about $275 for everything.