Agreed!
Jazz for someone who doesn't like jazz.
What I'd like is a recommendation of two or three albums to start with. (I know that's insane)
And since I've given next to nothing to go on I'll point out a few things that I do like that might help narrow it down some maybe.
Jazz-like stuff I do like: Steely Dan. Almost all of their stuff. Van Morrison's jazz influenced stuff like Astral Weeks.
I like blues. Delta and hill country hard core blues.
I like a wide variety of rock from heavy metal, to prog rock to classic R&B.
Does any of that help? I know this is a crazy request but if I could get some recommendations I'll at least have somewhere to start. Not looking for specific recordings yet. Just content. When I find what I like I'll research the best recordings.
Thanks for any possible advice.
George
Post removed |
And then, there is the great P.T. Gazell ... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U5zGvLJwkqM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jijVFnRwKfw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EIWZXPh89dk |
An excellent entry point to jazz is to listen to West Coast jazz. It is more melodic and easier to listen to for the beginner. Here’s some examples: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gsz3mrnIBd0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pcFRDj0z784 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2ncRUjL-1xk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BoUFb5KP4m4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z8eP6WG0aDY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2JlBWqSXXKU |
Wow, amazing number of responses on this thread! I could suggest two paths. Slow transition, say something like Santana to Chick Corea to Weather Report to Miles Davis or straight to JAZZ with Miles Davis Kind of Blue. I think Sonny Rollins is readily accessible also. Ben Webster...many paths to follow. |
nicotico ... Thanks. By your comment, it is clear to me that you not only know how to listen, but you also know what to listen for. That, in my opinion, is what leads to the enjoyment and understanding of jazz. In trying to explain jazz to the uninitiated, I've made the comment several times on these threads that so much of the music exists between the notes. Bill Evans certainly was a master of that. So was Miles. The key is to recognize that and to learn to listen for it. Frank |
Noticed something interesting when I went to the dynamic range database and looked up Kind of Blue. There was not a single recording listed that suffered from any significant dynamic range reduction. Even recent production CDs have excellent DR. If this is true across the genre it might be THE motivating factor that keeps me plugging away at this. It’s kind of amazing since virtually all rock releases since the mid 90s or so are plagued with horrible DR recordings including new bands releasing music right now! Even bands that pride themselves on production quality. |
Another extremely easy album to listen to is by the Massimo FaraòTrio called How My Heart Sings. Beautiful Piano playing by Massimo and very easy going. The song that hooked me on the album is called Easy Living. I would also seek out the Jazz Shepard’s YouTube channel. He gives some fun historical context on all things Jazz and plays samples of the music while he’s talking. Very interesting. He talks about different artists, Jazz forms, labels and all sorts of stuff. That’s where I heard the Philly Joe Jones album Philly Joe’s Beat I’m listening to right now. |
Hey @oregonpapa, l really like your observations about Cannonball’s influence on the whole album. Thanks for sharing. I had to respond to your post, because I have always felt for a long time that someone besides Cannonball (and other than Miles) had that exact same pervasive influence on the outcome of the whole album that you refer to. For me that person is Bill Evans. I like to think of Bill as Miles’ “silent partner” on that album who could deserve equal credit with Miles. I’d have a hard time explaining why I feel that way; I just do. But your view about Cannonball is just as valid, and interesting to me. |
These are the best easy listening jazz compilations I've ever heard! https://www.amazon.com/Best-Blue-Note-Vols/dp/B000005HGV/ref=sr_1_4?dchild=1&keywords=best+of+the+blue+note&qid=1587508736&sr=8-4 Disc: 1 1. Blue Train - John Coltrane 2. Maiden Voyage - Herbie Hancock 3. Cristo Redentor - Donald Byrd 4. Moanin' - Are Blakey & The Jazz Messengers 5. Blues Walk - Lou Donaldson 6. Song For My Father - Horace Silver 7. Back At The Chicken Shack - Jimmy Smith 8. Chitlins Con Carne - Kenny Burrell 9. The Sidewinder - Lee Morgan https://www.amazon.com/Best-Blue-Note-Vol/dp/B0002548BA/ref=sr_1_12?dchild=1&keywords=best+of+the+blue+note&qid=1587508792&sr=8-12 1. Senor Blues - Horace Silver 2. Decision - Sonny Rollins 3. Three O'Clock In The Morning - Dexter Gordon 4. Blues March - Art Blakey 5. Wadin' - Horace Parlan 6. The Rumproller - Lee Morgan 7. Somethin' Else - Cannonball Adderley 8. Blue Bossa - Joe Henderson 9. Watermelon - Herbie Hancock |
Kind of Blue is an interesting recording. I have multiple copies, including an original "six-eye" stereo version that is the best of the lot among the ones I have, including Japanese reissues. I found it in a thrift store back in the ’80s for fifty cents. Those were the days. Listen to it and see if you agree with me on this ... When the first cut starts out, the album sounds like a good studio recording. Good, but not that inspired. Sort of like the musicians were there to collect a paycheck. Miles takes the lead, then Coltrane comes on second. THEN, Cannonball Adderley takes his turn and plays with an inspiration that is totally infectious to everyone else on the album. He played like Bird reincarnated. From that point on, it becomes one of the greatest jazz albums of all time. My take has always been that if it weren’t for Cannonball Adderley touching the souls of the other players, and subsequently the end listener, Kind of Blue would have been just another good jazz album. Your thoughts? Frank PS: If you like Kind of Blue, you’ll want this one too: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u37RF5xKNq8 |
@pryso Thanks. I'm not sure that I like Kind of Blue for the right reasons. I'm sure there is depth there that I have not explored or even recognized is there. But, when you are initially drawn to something it is a lot easier to dig deep than when there isn't that initial appeal. I also like classical music. Not an aficionado by any stretch, but do understand that there is depth and complexity and can sometimes recognize and appreciate it. So that might help some. |
n80, as I suggested earlier there are a multitude of styles/types of jazz. That is what makes suggestions to a "newbie" so difficult, and the subject so baffling to the newbie themselves. Many, many great suggestions have been made here and sampling those can be as good an introduction as any. After my post I considered suggesting the Ken Burns series, but with so much music to listen to I wasn't sure if you'd be willing to watch that much video? If you watch more you'll certainly find more to explore. Contrary to many others here I don't consider KOB a good "introduction" album for someone starting out in jazz. It is one of the best ever recorded but is subtle and complex enough it will not be appreciated by many newbies. To your credit you've stated you like it. That suggests you can skip past many of the more "lightweight" suggestions. So all I'll offer at this point is based on what you've sampled that you do like, continue exploring other recordings by those artists. You are bound to run into some dead ends but that's OK, just try more recordings. With that you'll find side men/women with your preferred artists who are interesting and that will lead you to their recordings. And so on and so on. |
@oregonpapa said: "Like a lot of jazz musicians, Kenny G.went over to the dark side to make money" I think this is true in a lot of genres. Lots of serious rock bands abandoned their core stuff to make ballads. They all made tons of money on cheesy, monotonous ballads and virtually none of them ever recover artistically. Others, like ZZ Top make a killer album like Eliminator and every album after it sounds exactly the same. It would be hard to turn your back on the kind of money that vapid vacuous pop-ified music can offer. I do remember a funny quote from Huey Lewis that after being a cult band on the local scene that they were accused of "selling out" when they got popular. He said they had been trying to sell out for years. Listening to Harry Connick, Jr.'s Lofty's Roach Souflle' and it is not bad. @nicotico We have watched two episodes of Jazz and I'm enjoying it. It really is more about the people than the music, and that's fine. I don't mind that. Its good to know some of the back story. |
In my estimation, Kenny G. at best played elevator music. He had a real niche, but it wasn’t in jazz. He sold tons of recordings and made tons of money but it wasn’t from jazz fans. I have thousands of jazz recordings, and there’s not one Kenny G. among them. There was that one night on the old Arsenio Hall show though ... By the way, are any of you fans of this guy? I am ... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BMD3TE61PBA&list=RDBMD3TE61PBA&start_radio=1 And then, if you like Coltrane with an international flavor, there’s this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8d9cD_Es9k4 Let’s not forget Mingus ... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sxz9eZ1Aons And then for the harmonica fans, there's Toots ... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cLz4jwLN610 Frank |
Some good advice here, but N80 I’ll go contrary to some of it. If you’re new to Jazz skip the Ken Burns series, at least for a while. The only thing you need to know from that whole series is the Wynton Marsalis quip about Jazz “it doesn’t come to you; you have to go to it.” A good radio station that plays a variety of Jazz is indispensable. And lastly, seek out those who pushed the boundaries of their instruments and music. |
Unless I missed seeing the recommendation, nobody mentioned: Pat Metheny, particularly the old Pat Metheny Group. This surprises me. Very approachable music on most albums. I believe that some of his compositions will become jazz standards and it is very interesting to hear his songs covered by other artists. |
n80, You have to remember that Miles was a big time Herion and Cocaine addict. I think that shows on Big Fun , Bitches Brew and Live Evil. Actually , I would say that it influenced a lot of his albums. I think that was a lot of the reason for his abstract stuff, let alone that there is only so much you can do with a Trumpet as the Lead. I recently watched a special on Miles Davis "Birth Of The Cool" It is a Stunning film or Documentary IMO. I actually teared a little at the end ... so sad .Highly Recommended ! |
@tvad Kenny still made bank, though. And to your point, Metheny went on to say:
|
Post removed |
@oregonpapa I thought Pat Metheny's assessment of Kenny G was classic: He had major rhythmic problems and his harmonic and melodic vocabulary was extremely limited, mostly to pentatonic based and blues- lick derived patterns, and he basically exhibited only a rudimentary understanding of how to function as a professional soloist in an ensemble. |
So, Miles Davis. I like Kind of Blue and like Porgy and Bess. Most definitely do not like Big Fun or Bitches Brew. Those two seem very abstract to me, discordant, uncomfortable. I know that’s heresy but that is not the direction for me. Not yet anyway. Watched the first episode of Burn’s Jazz. I liked it. My wife was not all that interested but episode two is about Louis Armstrong and that generation which is what she likes so she is looking forward to it. Liked David Sanborn’s Another Hand. Listening to Coltrane’s Beautiful Star In Town and liking it so far. |
I got into jazz not long ago when I turned some on doing chores around the house. Now I’m head over heels for it, and am learning about new and great artists everyday. I love a good ballad/slower tempo jazz and created a nice sized Spotify playlist of selections. Here are a few excellent albums I have listened to lately. Paul Chambers - Bass On Top - the first song Yesterdays is incredible Ike Quebec - Blue And Sentimental and also Heavy Soul - very beautiful and accessible Jazz Duke Pearson - Tender Feelin’s - beautiful jazz pianist Yusef Lateef - Eastern Sounds - Interesting album and I play the song Love Theme From Spartacus almost everyday. Something about his playing... Joe Pass and Oscar Peterson - Porgy and Bess - if you love guitar you will love Joe Bill Evans and Jim Hall - Undercurrent - beautiful album from start to finish. Excellent piano via Evans and guitar via Hall. Dexter Gordon - Biting The Apple - Dexter has a magical way with Ballads. His rendition of Georgia On My Mind is stunning Gene Ammons - Boss Tenor - Gene’s plating is beautiful and touching. He can give me chills and My Romance is a great song off this album. Ben Webster & Associates - this album, specifically the song Time After Time really got me into Jazz. The subtlety and beauty of his playing made me feel jazz, and his playing was like beautiful lyrics. Coleman Hawkins Quartet - Today and Now - A great song is Love Song From “Apache”. I could go on but there’s a few ideas. https://open.spotify.com/playlist/70s6FreBdsDocjdjJWcxgf?si=6eCfCkXtT_-DHSQmmOMoEQ |
For timeless classic jazz: Miles Davis, Kind of Blue & Sketches of Spain For chill saxophone: John Klemmer, Touch For jazz-inflected pop: Michael Franks For piano: Ellis Marsalis, Thelonius Monk, Marcus Roberts Brazilian Jazz: Bebel Gilberto, Nando Lauria, Gabriela Anders Classic vocal jazz: Billie Holiday, Ella Fitzgerald, Dinah Washington |
Absolutely guarantee you will love this album if you favor Steely Dan type music--Michael Franks Time Together It is a double winner--great music and great sound in your style. Fourplay Elixir great music, OK sound. After you hear the MF album, I have many more in that style I could tell you about. Bob |
@onhwy61 said: "If you don't like what you've heard, then why bother?" Well, a couple of things come to mind: At first I didn't like beer, bourbon, Scotch, asparagus, caviar, oysters, foie gras, etc etc. Over a lifetime I've come to value and appreciate those things. Second, it would be distinctly possible for someone who had never listened to the blues or never listened to rock to be presented with any number of songs that they didn't like that were not representative of the entire genre and then assume, possibly wrongly, that they didn't like rock or the blues. So the answer is, that my experience with jazz might be insufficient to know whether there are types and songs I would like more than others and that keeping an open mind I might find that jazz is an acquired taste that is worth acquiring. Like single malt Scotch. @onhwy61 said: "Life is short, you should listen to music you like." Agreed. But I also think life is too short to limit one's enjoyment. That can get repetitive. @onhwy61 said: "By your own admission your question is insane. That said, there's easy access to any number of streaming services or even FM that will give you a taste." Well, as insane as the question was I've got two pages of excellent recommendations for which I am thankful. George |
+1 Weather Report +1 Swiss Movement McCann/Harris sound great! The Speakers Corner pressing is lovely. Very Fun. And Heavy Weather is another very enjoyable piece to put on. Ben Webster has a great tone and soulful style of playing. Lou Donaldson is another that has a super cool tone. "Blues Walk" would be a good one to start with. |