Best female vocal recording on CD?
so i am asking for what you use as a reference female vocal recording/track. right now i come back tp bonnie raitt "you cant make me love you" from luck of the draw. big, warm, strong voice. not a perfect recording. but hmmmm that voice.
my only requirement is it has to be on CD. and we all know of great vinyl that did not translate into great CDs. so help me out here, what should be my next music purchase
I’m a huge Rickie Lee Jones fan and know every inch of that record... so I was pleasantly surprised when I read your post! I was even at the live show supporting that album; so I think I may know where you’re coming from... I own and have listened to 95% of all the standards mentioned in this thread... Norah, Patricia B, Holly Cole, etc... many excellent choices... and yes, I have a hi-fi system worth two or three brand new SUVs I could have parked in the driveway instead. Given this; My favorite all time female vocal track for CD (non-high res) is: *Barbra Steisand’s Send In The Clowns (track 8) ’Broadway Album’ ... it’s an older recording, but just an astonishing track - both musically, vocally, emotionally and sonically. I even own the vinyl (for the day I go that route!) Important to know; My system is is based on hi res SACD, Pure Blu-Ray Audio and DVD-A spec. The next track is going to surprise a lot of people: *Dolly Parton’s In The Sweet By And By from her ’Little Sparrow’ SACD release (Track 13).The entire album sonically is a masterpiece... conceived, recorded, mixed and mastered from the studio mics to your D/A ENTIRELY in DSD. Few pop albums can claim this. It’s not remastered from low or even hi res digital masters or analog tapes; rather, it is the purest of the pure - like Chesky SACDs/DVD-As releases. IMHO this is an example of how good hi-fi content gets. I’m a musician and recording engineer. I have very little consumer gear in my hi fi setup. The heart is a 6-ch Emm Labs mastering DAC, dedicated DSD transport and 6-ch transparent pre. I challenge anyone to find a finer recording than this on VINYL or otherwise. I have heard 100’s and 100’s of great hi-fi albums on vinyl that simply can’t touch this recording... same with other hi res discs (I have a sizable collection). Although sweet sounding, the physical properties of vinyl are severely limiting. Ie: (S/N and dynamic range). Add to this the required encode-decode RIAA eq curve in your preamp to compensate for all this and it just won’t allow vinyl to do what this hi-res recording does... STUNNING 5.1 clarity and an emotional performance that will blow you away. I have played this as my reference recording for almost a decade. I have left friends and dozens of crazed vinyl-heads audiophiles speechless; jaws on the floor. If you don’t have an SACD (spec) setup w a good DAC this recording alone would be the enough reason to make the plunge. Honorable mentions: CD: Eva Cassidy, Fields of Gold Sarah McLachlan, Angel, (if you have a player with the HDCD chip, get the ’Angel’ album soundtrack version vs the standard ’Surfacing’ album CD version). SACD: *Sarah McLachlan, Answer, album ’Afterglow’ (a relatively new release!) *Alison Krauss, Ghost In This House, album ’Forget About It’ *Rickie Lee Jones, Stewart’s Coat, album Traffic In Paradise Enjoy your journey! ps.. there is track 'Little Sparrow REPRISE' after the Dolly track 13 I mentioned feom the same same album that demonstrates how good dobro and guitars can get on a hi fi system, so let the disc run and get treated to a reference STRING track as well! Note: these are recordings you can really crank up, so highly suggested, do it and you'll be amazed. |
Can't add a lot to a great list of vocalists here, but a minor suggestion, Jane Monheit has a lot of pedestrian stuff out there, but she seemed to find her strength in the "Surrender" album. Gardot, Barber, Peyroux, etc. are all great ... might also look at Nancy Moore for interesting interpretations. |
Some great artists have already been mentioned. Here's a few that haven't been: Sarah Vaughan (USA) - her SACD with Clifford Brown is sublime. (Japanese remaster) Beverly Kennedy (USA) - a jazz singer from the 50's. She only released 4 albums. She killed herself in 1960 at 28 years of age. The Japanese are fanatical about her so there are some very good remasters on CD available now. Her LPs go for +$500 in Japan. Cara Dillon (IRL) - Live at the Opera House - available on 24/96 download Kate Rusby (UK) - Awkward Annie - I could listen to her Yorkshire accent all day long! |
There is no best female recording, it means you are willing to sacrifice some of other recordings if you look for best female recordings listed here? While I agree some of here listed are indeed "some" of the best, but it just impossible to list them all, I like to go by tracks instead of female artists alone, it’s hard to compare which is the best, each unique in a way that you are not going give up listen to. My first impression of female voice from Whitney Houston, it came out of radios, though that time when I was child, the time back then was start of 90s, I would say that her voice is not as soulful as Aretha Franklin or Nina Simone, but her voice is kinda unique in it’s own, both technically and emotionally, she kinda create more "well known" recording or live ballads than anybody else, these singers are not much considered as "clean" audiophile", as they sing on the go soulful way as opposed to the likes like Norah Jones, Diana Krall, Eva Cassidy, and Katie Melua which I think few tracks like Piece By Piece & Nine Million Bicycles are indeed nice, but some of other Katie’s tracks maybe too young in her presentations, the 3 former white Jazz singers are very well known to audiophiles I assume, here are some of my favourites: Adele - Hometown Glory Alison Krauss - When You Say Nothing At All Aretha Franklin - Ain’t No Way Astrud Gilberto - It’s A Lovely Day Today Barbara Streisand - Evergreen Barbara Cook - My Funny Valentine Barbara Bonney - Ave Maria Basia - Third Time Lucky Cara Dillon - There Were Roses Captain & Tennille - Love Will Keep Us Together Chaka Khan - Lullaby Of Birdland Crystal Gayle - Don’t It Make My Brown Eyes Blue Dana Winner - Moonlight Shadow Des’ree - Laughter Diana Krall - I’ve Got You Under My Skin Dionne Warwick - Alfie (Live from The Mike Douglas Show 1972) Dionne Warwick - One Less Bell To Answer Doris Day - It's Been A Long, Long Time Dusty Springfield - The Look Of Love Ella Fitzgerald - Summertime (Ella in Berlin 1960) Enya - I Dreamt I Dwelt In Marble Halls Erma Franklin - Light My Fire Etta Jones - Don’t Go To Strangers Etta Jones - What A Wonderful World Eva Cassidy - Tall Trees In Georgia Holly Cole - Calling You Inva Mula - Lucia Di Lammermoor + The Diva Dance Jennifer Holliday - And I’m Telling You (I’m Not Going)(Live from Radio City Music Hall 1986) Jennifer Warnes - Famous Blue Raincoat Joni Mitchell - Blue Judy Collins - Send In The Clowns Julie London - I Left My Heart In San Francisco Julie London - The End Of The World Katie Melua - Nine Million Bicycles Katie Melua - Piece By Piece Kelly Sweet - Dream On Kelly Sweet - We Are One KOKIA - ありがとう (泪的告白) Lady GaGa - Applause Lisa Ono (小野リサ) - あたしの赤ちゃん (Drume Negrita)(Cuban Children’s Songs) Lykke Li - Little Bit Mariah Carey - Hero (Live from concert at Proctor Theatre, New York on July 15, 1993) Momoe Yamaguchi (山口百恵) - さよならの向う側 Montserrat Caballé - O mio babbino caro (Oh My Beloved Father)(Live from Munich 1990)(Giacomo Puccini) Nana Mouskouri - Der Lindenbaum (菩提樹) Nancy Wilson - All Night Long Nina Simone - I Loves You Porgy Norah Jones - Come Away With Me Ofra Haza - Im Nin’Alu Patsy Cline - Crazy Peggy Lee - Sans Souci Radka Toneff - My Funny Valentine Radka Toneff - The Moon Is A Harsh Mistress Rebecca Pidgeon - Spanish Harlem Rihanna - Stay (feat. Mikky Ekko) Rimi Natsukawa (夏川りみ) - キセキノハナ (奇蹟之花) Sade - Kiss Of Life Sade - Your Love Is King Sara K. - What’s A Little More Rain Sarah Brightman - O mio babbino caro (Oh My Beloved Father)(Live)(Giacomo Puccini) Sarah Vaughan - Misty Sissel Kyrkjebø - I Dreamt I Dwelt In Marble Halls (Live from Dalhalla Concert) Suzanne Vega - Luka Toni Braxton - Un-Break My Heart Whitney Houston - I Am Changing (Live from San Francisco 1986) Whitney Houston - I Will Always Love You Whitney Houston - Saving All My Love For You Whitney Houston - The Greatest Love Of All (Live from Arista 15th Anniversary 1990) Yael Naïm - New Soul 崔萍 - 今宵多珍重 崔萍 - 南屏晚鍾 張露 - 靜心等 徐佳瑩 - 失落沙洲 (我是歌手 I Am Singer) 徐小鳳 - 不了情 王菲 - 矜持 王菲 - 致青春 蔡琴 - 月光小夜曲 蔡琴 - 機遇 I 蔡琴 - 被遺忘的時光 蘇芮 - 奉獻 鄧麗君 - 又見炊煙 降央卓瑪 - 一剪梅 降央卓瑪 - 紅梅贊 降央卓瑪 - 鴻雁 陳永馨 - 三月 陳芳語 - 我愛你你知道嗎? 順子 - 回家 I am not able to list them all I guess, so conclusion there is no best female recordings for me, hmm if got one I would choose Whitney Houston - I Will Always Love You, I’m still finding a version as opposed to the market album recording, the sound is more lively, not sure is it some Dolby Digital sound effect on it |
My gosh, this is my first entry on this forum and I must recommend Jennifer Warnes "Famous Blue Raincoat" for strong consideration. It was a staple of audiophiles in the 80's and 90's. One could feel her chest vibrate mid-soundstage. Her voice is very engaging and palpable, her enunciation so nearly perfect, even her inspiration of air was part of the magic. And the emotion she conveyed with each word or phrase was felt in one's marrow. It remains a must hear for anyone being introduced to my system ( Apogee Divas or Scintillas, Krell, Mapleknoll....) |
Mary Black, Babes in the Woods album. I used to use this as a reference for modifying CD players in years gone by. Currently using Audio Note OTO Signature with modded AN DAC 1 via Marantz CD 17 Mk II KI Special and modded Audio Note K speakers. Having heard Mary Black live, she translates very similarly to CD as does Lisa Gerrard and Loreena McKennitt. Cowboy Junkies, Trinity Sessions, Sweet, Sweet Jane is another knockout on standard CD format. Holly Cole, album Don't Smoke in Bed, track The Tennessee Waltz and several others on that album are quite special. Regards Craig |
right now i come back tp bonnie raitt "you cant make me love you" from luck of the draw. big, warm, strong voice. not a perfect recording. but hmmmm that voice.That's exactly the song I'd recommend. You can tell how great Bonnie Raitt is when you compare her to Adele's version of that song. Adele absolutely butchers it. Definitely one of my references. I'll tell you right now, I don't get the audiophile fare (Diana Krall, Norah Jones, etc.). I just don't think their voices are that good ... I don't care how good their recordings are. So take that into consideration when viewing my reference material. Dream of the Archer by Heart (remaster). Hard to beat Ann Wilson in her prime. You might be sick of it, but there's no denying that Celine Dion shines on My Heart Will Go On (Titanic theme). I dislike Mariah Carey's breathy singing, but believe it or not, she was actually a hell of a powerful singer on her first album. Check out the song Vision of Love. And you might not like the rest of the album because it's metal with Beauty and the Beast vocals, but the song Sunlight by Oceans of Slumber is just excellent clean female vocals. Also metal (but this song doesn't sound like it), I like the atmospheric breathy detail of Trees of Eternity's singer, Aleah. Try the song Sinking Ships. It sounds like your ear is next to the microphone. And, while not vocal perfection, I do like the smokey vocals of Sade's Cherish The Day. |
Siris Svale - Blackbird (Norwegian jazz singer with a beautifully twisted sense of songs - excellent recording and great music) Mariza - Fado (originally from Mozambique of African & Portuguese ancestry, she's brought the ancient sound of Fado into the 21st century - decent recording, great musicality) |
Hi guys, here's my list, in no particular order: 1. Karen Dalton - In My Own Time 2. Karen Dalton - Its So Hard To Tell Who's Going to Love You the Best 3. Laura Nyro - New York Tendaberry 4. Joan Baez - 5 5. Joan Baez - David's Album 6. Joan Baez - Blessed Are 7. Richard and Mimi Farina (Joan's kid sister) - Memories 8. Joan Armatrading - 1st album 9. Judy Collins - Colors of the Day 10. Tracy Chapman - 1st album 11. Sibylle Baier - Colour Green 12. Joni Mitchell - 1st album 13. Joni Mitchell - Ladies of the Canyon 14. Marissa Nadler - Little Hells 15. Maxine Sullivan - on Period Records, SPL 1207 16. Amy Winehouse - Hidden Treasures 17. Eva Cassidy - the 4 LP set Live at Blues Alley 18. Sade - Any of her first three albums 19. Wanda Jackson - Right or Wrong 20. Black Orpheus - Soundtrack, listed here for that ONE SONG on side two 21. Kiri te Kanawa - Blue Skies 22. Emmylou Harris - Luxury Liner 23. Gram Parsons and Emmylou Harris - Grievous Angel 24. Gram Parsons and Emmylou Harris - GP 25. Tona la Negra - La Sensacion Jarocha 26. Blanca Rosa Gil - La Triunfadora de Cuba 27. La Lupe - La Lupe Es La Reina 28. Billy Holiday - Songs for Distingue Lovers 28. Billy Holiday - Lady in Satin 29. Joy of Cooking - Closer to the Ground 30. Janis Joplin - In Concert That should get you going. I know that you asked for CD, but as I have 5,000+ LPs and a handful of CDs, I'm speaking for the VINYL LP issues of these recordings only and bothered to list them because these disks deserve a listening regardless of how well they were digitized. I suspect that, except for the Latin LPs, they are at least "VG+" to "EX". The Gil is "VG+" on both LP and CD, an outstanding bolero set from Hialea. Regards - |
Here's my current top 10 not in order: Beth Orton- Pass in Time KT Tunstall- Invisible Empire Laura Marling- A Creature I don't know MaMuse- Integration of the Awkward Natalie Merchant- Paradise is there Rachel Sage- Blue Rose Shelby Lynn- Suit yourself & I can't imagine Sophie Barker- A Rare Collection of songs Vienna Teng- Warm Strangers Ayleen O'Hanlon- Blend and spill |
+1 Holy Cole, Eva Cassidy, Melody Gardot, Cassandra Wilson, Paula Cole, Patricia Barber, and most others mentioned. My rotation this past week has included Lydia Gray, Anne Bisson, Vanessa Fernandez, Erin Bode, Tori Amos, Gretchen Perlato, Lhasa, Rachel Z, Karrin Allyson, Eden Brent, Patty Carpenter, Amanda Carr, Emilie-Claire Barlow, Karen Lovely, Ruthie Foster, Valerie Joyce, Stacey Kent, Ana Caram, Beth Hart, Janis Ian, Rickie Lee Jones, Josi Davis, Connie Evingson, Astrud Gilberto, Billy Lee Hart, Barbara Jungr, Katia Labeque, k.d. Lang, Allyson Krauss, Claire MArlo, Sophie Milman, Jane Monheit, The Nields (sisters), Madeleine Peyroux, Ambar Rubart, Mary Stallings, Susan Tedeschi, DAr Williams, Lucinda Williams. All CDs. Fine voices, arrangements, performances and recording production (not heavy handed post production). Probably a few more that I can't recall. I am retired, music plays 12-16 hours every day when I am home. I have a 4K plus CD collection (and vinyl which I rarely bother with) which is a drop in the bucket of talent. I felt guilty mentioning these folks because there are so many others. |
THE SOPRANO Arleen Auger possessed a pure-toned voice of great flexibility and absolute accuracy of intonation. She excelled in the music of Monteverdi, Bach, Gluck, Haydn, Handel and in particular of Mozart, but also sang works by 20th-century composers such as Carl Orff with great success. Also consider the amazing Dutch soprano Elly Ameling and the very fine American Barbara Bonney. Don't let the idea that these are "Classical" artists keep you from your investigation. Like a fine Scotch or Beer, although new and distinctive at first they will soon become favorites. |
Ok, I’ve come back with new discoveries, I think you need a female voice, a piano playing, and your ears to listen to these 2 songs to complete a story and journey on your own, note that the recording is not available on YouTube, you can try download somewhere else: Akiko Yano (矢野顕子) - 中央線 Akiko Yano (矢野顕子) - Prayer |
What surprises Jennifer Warnes, "The Hunter" Sara K, "Waterfalls" (Just wonderful recording, on Stockfisch) Shawn Colvin,, "Fat City", "All Fall Down", but any really Kate Rusby "Underneath the Stars", "Hourglass", but again anything, a great English Folk singer. Jonatha Brooke "10c Wings" |
Two observations on this thread. Firstly, aren't we fortunate that there are so many great female vocalists around. All the way through this thread, I have been thinking, "Oh yes, I forgot her". There are just so many around, most of them never get played or listened to, in our world of compressed Pop and manufactured artists, boy bands, TV competition winners. Secondly, how separate most countries are, in terms of music availability. Many of the US artists mentioned I have not heard of and when I look on Amazon, are largely unavailable, or cost £50 a CD. Yes I know with Tidal, Spotify etc, so much more is available to us, but what if you want the physical discs? |
So many great suggestions here, many that I already enjoy and many more I've not heard. I just ordered 10 new cd's based on the suggestions here. I don't want to repeat many of my favs already mentioned but here are some I don't think I've seen mentioned here: Lydia Loveless, Real Connie Evingson, Gypsy in my Soul Jeannie Bryson, Tonight I Need You So Jen Chapman, Open Wide Haley Westerns, Pure Diane Birch, Speak A Little Louder enjoy! |
Calvin - yes Cecile Mclorin Salvant Womanchild Fantastic! Tooblue - you are right, Patricia Barber, Diana Krall and Nora Jones are also Fantastic. Boring? Really? To who? Eva Cassidy - breathtakingly beautiful as some pointed out Anything by Joni Mitchell "Blue" is out of this world Aretha Franklin - Has there ever been a woman with a more soulful voice? Lisa Gerrard - Tremendous I am going to add Alison Krauss. Has anybody heard " Ghost in this house". https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=dWRGZaHb8xE |