Chances are at two feet out it might work well. Most speakers that need a little space work in the 2 to 3 feet range. Planers might need more space but that is not your issue.
Wilson Alexia - speaker placement question
I'm looking at this speaker and am trying to figure out if I'll have poor bass/midrange as I can only keep the speakers 20-23 inches from the front wall. My room is 16 w by 21 l with 9 ft ceilings. This is a full range speaker and I'm concerned its bass capabilities may interact poorly with any room-related sound modes. Appreciate any comments/guidance.
Going by the room dimension the width looks good and the ratios are not bad - 2.3 : 1.8 : 1 (2 : 1.5 : 1 evenly spaced room modes). You have some distance from the side wall to work with. Pick up 4 - 6 freestanding absorber panels to start - this should give you a good place to start. Is the 20-30 inch limit going to the front of the speaker? Also Wilson allows for some adjustment of the ports ...
|
"I can only keep the speakers 20-23 inches from the front wall." $50K speakers and you can't put them in an optimized position. You probably will get them to sound good in any location, but a speaker especially like that deserves to at least be influenced by the "rule of 1/3rds" -7ft or Cardas type distances from the front wall. http://www.cardas.com/room_setup_calculators.php From TAS review "They worked beautifully when placed well away from the sidewalls and near the rear walls in my listening room. They have a surprisingly flat response down to around 34–37Hz, going much deeper with a slow roll-off, with audible and measured power to below 30Hz."
|
I have Alexia 2s in a NYC apartment which has your exact dimensions 16x21x9. My speakers are 19" from the front wall at the rear inside corner of the toed in cabinet. The speakers fire down the long walls to my seat. The walls are dense plaster. I could move the speakers to within 18" for more bass reinforcement and that would work too, but once I move to 20", I lose too much bass reinforcement and gain nothing. That does not mean this positioning will work for you but it worked within an inch for my previous Sashas and WP 7s in my room. Good luck. |
Your choices are pretty simple. Room treatment and EQ. I use a combination of the two. I use the EQ built into Roon for the EQ and GIK acoustics panels and traps for the room treatment. You might also want to look at the room mode calculator, it will help you see where you may have issues and what room locations to avoid.
https://amcoustics.com/tools/amroc Based on the first 4 or so room modes, I'd encourage you to start with floor to ceiling soffit traps from GIK. First the wall behind the speakers, then behind the listener. |
I have a pair of Wilson Alexia’s. My room is larger at 16’w 30’d vaulted ceilings. They are currently 3’6 from front wall and 2’ from side walls. My room is also open in the back wall. I have had them as close as 2’ from front wall and they imaged well with better bass. I think you will be fine and or correct with EQ. I’m planning on adding subs to help bring back the low end. |
Everyone - thank you so much for your comments. I've re-measured my space and the distance from the front wall and the back of the speakers would be 18 inches. I really don't want to use any room treatment panels, etc. nor DSP. JJss49 - thank you for the WASP link --- very informative. Gpgr4blu - Is there any way I could speak with you about your setup? You have the experience of using the Wilson's in a Manhattan apartment. Many thanks - Newton
|