Okay, so I used to think that listener fatigue meant that your ears just kind of got tired from listening to speakers that were overly bright. I don't have a good understanding of the make up of an ear, but I believe there are muscles in an ear that, I guess, expand and contract while we listen to music and I figured that's what it meant to have listener fatigue. Now, I'm thinking that listener fatigue is maybe more than your ears just getting tired but actually, your whole body getting tired and feeling drained. I experienced this time and time again listening to my paradigm studio's. They are somewhat bright and provide quite a bit of detail in my oppinion, so I'm wondering if, since there was such a great amount of detail coming through, that it was physically draining because I'm sitting there analyzing everything that's coming through the speakers. I would wake up and first thing in the morning, grab a cup of coffee and start listening to music (my daily routine) and 20-30 minutes later start nodding off and I couldn't figure out what was going on. I've been sitting here this morning listening to my new vandersteen's for two hours and can't get enough. I feel like I could listen all day and that I'm almost energized from listening vs. drained.
Soooo, what are your oppinions about what listener fatigue is and why it's caused?
IMHO, one of the reasons for the listener fatigue is from a physical energy of sound. The sound has a physical energy and sonic energy. The p energy is what pushing the sound away from the speaker. We hear the S energy pushed from the P energy. What we want to listen is the S energy. Not P energy! For example, the beginner golfers hit a lot of slice balls. This slice ball flies straight at the beginning of the flight of the ball. The golf ball starts go to side way after hitting and pushing energy from the golf club (P energy) dissipated and weakened. P energy is forceful energy from an object and they hurt human ears like a sonic boom. S energy is a natural movement of the sound. The unbalance of P energy from the tweeter and the woofer causes discomfort and fatigue to your ears and brain. The unbalance of S energy will generate just tasteless of music sound. ***A sonic boom is the sound associated with the shock waves created by an object traveling through the air faster than the speed of sound.(from Wikipedia.com)
The bright sounding speakers are OK. I love shimmering, sweet, dazzling, and splendid high frequency as long as P energy between the tweeter and the woofer is balanced. I enjoy the bright S energy, but I dont want the P energy from tweeter. We control the S energy with the volume level. If the P energy of the tweeter on any speaker can be controlled, we can easily make a musical sound system.
Some tweeters equip a plastic or metal cover to control P energy. The side effects are loosing a big portion of S energy and whirling turbulence of sound waves. We cant get musical satisfaction from thin and diffused sounds. These speakers with a cover sound usually not musical. If they are musical, thats from woofer. Not the tweeter. How musical can they be without the high freq? Mediocre at their best. The woofer and tweeter on the speaker should be P energy adjustable without loosing S energy. So, this hobby/passion for hi-end music could be little easier.
The physical energy is very easy to control. P energy dissipates after hit an object while S energy bounces. Simple! We need a sound wave guide that kills/reduces P energy and bounces S energy to a listener.
B, nice. I've got a serious thing for lady singers (I know, not the preferred nomenclature). Trying to think who can hold a candle to Trixie. Tanya Donnelly, pre-Belly, the track Not Too Soon from Throwing Muses, with her her screeching like a cat, is near-orgasmic. Early Heather Nova, especially the live stuff, before she went all silly, is pretty fine. Jess King, her first album, has one track on it that is devine (I Believe in Angles) -- thought I fear you won't be able to find it anywhere. Had a real soft spot for Fiona Apple's first album, before she went right the hell off the wheels. More recently, working on the start of a thing for She Keeps Bees, but it hasn't really taken hold yet. Sandra O and a couple of tracks from Yea, Yea, Yeas are top notch. Don't love all of it, but when she's on, she smoulders something fierce. (Watch the video for Maps off of their first album. I challenge you not to love it.) Margot Timmons, of course. Not every time, but when it's on, it's the very definition of an irresistible slow burn. Oh, and apologies for totally hijacking your thread...;-)
Mezmo, I actually have all of Trixie Whitleys songs that I could get from Spotify too. I love female vocals and wouldn't say that she has the best or most refined voice out there by a long shot, but she is my favorite female vocalist. I absolutely love her music; it's just dripping with emotion.
B -- rock on with the Chris Whitley. Solid. Living With The Law and Dirt Floor are my favorites. Different, but brilliant, each. And do check out his daughter, Trixie Whitley (yes, for real). She did a you-tube video of rather go blind with Brian Blade and Daniel Lanois that is one of the best things ever. No BS, one of the best things, ever. And that band, Black Dub, dropped a studio album last year (or the year before, damnitt if i can keep track anymore), that though radically over-produced, has moments of brilliance. Check it out, you won't regret it.
Actually the main and only significant cause of listening fatigue, assuming your equipment is of a reasonable quality, is that your speakers are not properly set up in the room. The only thing the ears do is measure time and volume.AKA phase and amplitude. Since the singer is coming from both speakers it is imperative that the singer pressurizes both ear drums at exactly the same time. Since this a matter of pressure change and NOT distance it is a difficult thing to accomplish. One way to check this out is to dis-connect one speaker and listen to your music and see if you still get fatigue. By eliminating one speaker you have taken away the inner-modulation distortion caused by the two speakers banging into each other My guess is that you will not get any fatigue at all. This is where a set up of your speakers using the "Master Set" technique is absolutely essential for any quality system. There is a great article on "Master Set" on Audio Circle in the acoustic circle. Or get hold of me and I can go over things for you.
where one can listen for hours of uninterrupted music, the other can only listen for a shorter period of time (does not get the same musical satisfaction).
The above can be from overly bright speakers and/or gear!
Lol, Sonic. You know, my musical tastes have vastly widened over the past 9 months. I'm listening to a little classical, some country (Chris Whitley), some jazz, alot of music I never had an interest in before but I can honestly say, Kenny G. has not once been played, nor Michael Bolton.
"Michael Bolton? Are you serious? Your name is Michael Bolton? We love Michael Bolton. What's your favorite song??" "I don't know, I mean, I guess I like all of them". ---Quote from Office Space
I experienced some sort of fatigue today but I don't think it was listener fatigue.
Ive been building my system up incrementally. Today I finally got my new DAC and the change was enormous. It think I was so emotionally connected to the music and probably had some sort of adrenalin rush that after a few hours I needed to take a nap.
my take is this. Go to a live acoustic jazz concert in a great sounding hall... and after an hour and 45 minutes you will be fatigued. If the emotional content, the degree of engagement in the music is high, then after a time (typically 1.5 hours or so) you will be fatigued.
In a stereo system, brightness, harshness, etc. can lead to fatigue. That is an entirely different thing. On the other end of the continuum, those who have systems that are "non-fatiguing" are systems that are not bright, not grainy sounding, etc. --- but if such systems are non-fatiguing even after 3-4 hours of dedicated listening... then the emotional content/degree of engagement in the music is minimal. That is, 1.5 hours of excellent music well recorded is fatiguing --- and 1.5 hours of grainy, harsh, bright music is also fatiguing. Bottom line... any session of dedicated listening is fatiguing after 1.5 hours or so... either for good reasons or bad (or a combo, in varying degrees, of both).
Schubert had stated the answer succinctly. No more need be said. If not understood, the original question can be abbreviated to... "why does my brain hurt shortly after turning on the switch"?
when i "upgraded" my speakers to B&W-801's i now had transducers designed for recording engineers to discern flaws and minute problems in playing back studio takes. I knew that going into the acquisition, but all of the subsequent upgrades and adjustments to the rest of the system and my room to dial in the best possible sound became an open-ended journey. HIgh-end audio can become a like it a lot/worry over it a lot proposition. you can get a ton of information off the source you never knew was there, but it "can" complicate the simple desire to just sit back and listen to some tunes. the best cure i know is to find the best engineered recordings you can and mentally IGNORE any and all shortcomings of recordings that are obviously not so wonderful. maybe someday they will invent a "remastering" digital device that can correct over 90% of the flaws of a piece of music you love in real time. not just a room corrector, but something that will literally generate a REALISTIC 3-D soundstage, the whole enchilada. with a "MAGIC" control where you can add as little or as much realism as you desire. that WOULD be cool....
Whoa! How about analyzing lack of fatigue. What's going on when there isn't any? Or any tweaks, conditioners, regenerators, Mu-Metal, wires and cables costing as much or more than the gear itself? Must be deafness.
Ooh, this is fun lets continue adding to the list of possible sources of distortion.
10. Ceiling vibrations. (Weve got walls, floors and windows dialed in, but lets not forget the ceiling. And furniture. And glassware. And clothing. And hair gosh how could we forget hair. Wee little hairs is how we hear anyway, and just imagine using the wrong shampoo. Totally f-ed.)
11. Ectoplasm. Gostbusters, anyone? Nuff said.
12. Matter. Dark matter is particularly insidious (it can really sneak up on you, you rarely see it coming), but all of it can be problematic / fatiguing. More so with the stuff we know exists.
13. Electrons. Yes, they may be everywhere, but they can really tire you out. And if you run them through conductive materials just so across energy differentials, they can also be quite useful when mixed appropriately with electronic devices.
15. Weather. High pressure, low pressure, changing pressure, static pressure, too dry, too humid, too cold, too warm. Again, f-ed, f-ed and f-ed.
16. Residue(s). Of all manner, really. Psychic can be particularly bad. Psycho-acoustic residue can accrete and be notably fatiguing. High-viscosity petrochemical residues are best avoided definitely do not treat your listening environment with these types of sprays, particularly the flammable kind (i.e., napalm may look like fun in the movies, but its really not safe for home use, or anything else). Emotional residue. Be nice.
17. Sound waves. The root of all evil. And the vibrations that cause them (see also, vibrations, bad compare good vibrations). Enervating.
18. Atmosphere(ics). See also, weather and sound waves. The ineffable majesty of fluid dynamics aside, no atmosphere, no exhausting noise. At all. Problem licked. (And the tree-falling-in-forest conundrum is pure bonus points, as no one around to hear in any event.)
19. Perceptual lense(s). Subjective-based, epistemological reality is really the pits. And soooo exhausting.
20. Parallel universes. And no, not higher order dimensions, those sound divine. Parallel four-space, alternate space-time continuums. You do not want these rubbing up against your listening environment, the possibility they may be infinite and effectively omnipresent notwithstanding. Im sure theres a spray for that (but see, residues).
21. Magnets. And magnetic fields. Even the ones that make your speakers go. And the ones created by No. 13, above. But mostly the earths magnetic field, totally fatiguing. And: magnets, how do they work, anyway?
22. Plants. If you have to ask, youll never get understand. But trust me. Plants.
23. Water. Things sound crap under water, yet were mostly made out of water. Think about it.
You're tired of listening to something to a point where you have to stop. To your boss, your wife, your kids, other audiophiles, and yes, even your audio system. I'm going to use a computer analogy. Sorry about that.
Hardware: I agree with many of the other comments here. Listening too loud, a piece of gear or a cable that's too harsh will kill you. Years ago I had a pair of Hales Design Group speakers. Good speakers but power hungry. I bought a Musical Fidelity amp without listening to it because I new it had the juice and the reviews were good, and I got a great deal. (BTW: good specs + good reviews + good deal - actually listening = stupid. learned my lesson) Within 2 minutes, I knew I was in trouble because the missus says: HMM, SOUNDS REALLY BRASSY. While it had the juice to drive the speakers, dynamics, and resolve - it was a brilliant Migraine Maker and it didn't last long. Even in the background I had to turn it off. And if you're wanting to turn off background music you're in deep sh*t.
Software: Some recordings are just harsh. I love the band Big Star and I downloaded a supposedly "Redbook quality digital file" from Rhino. Their recordings are edgy to begin with, but however Rhino encoded the digital files is just so shrill that I can't listen very long, even though I love the music. Also, the type of music you listen to can have an effect. I can handle about an hour of bebop. I love Scott Walker's experimental work, but I can only take one record at a time. Try listening to Gorecki Symphony 3 twice in a row at high volume without huddling up in a corner. Which brings me to...
User error: If you're actively listening to music, you don't leave YOU behind when you sit down in your fake Eames chair. YOU are the most important component in your system. Your mood, physical well-being, stress level, etc, all come along for the ride. If you have a great system without the hardware and software issues mentioned above, the music will transport you away from yourself, but you start there. And 90% of the time I get there. But sometimes I don't want to be hyper immersed. So I'll put on simpler music, or I walk away. Other times, and I'm embarrassed to admit this, I'm so transported that my monkey mind is shut down completely and I finally relax. Then fall asleep. But that is all me fatigue.
Here's a test. Drink a beer. Turn on your system. Drink another beer. Start listening. After a hour, are you bored, analyzing your set up? Drink another beer. Put on a favorite record. Still not happy? You probably have a hardware issue because your user issues should be greased.
"Possible sources could start with the quality of input materials (e.g. CDs or LPs)"
I used to think this was more of a factor in the past than I do these days. I really think system related issues are a much bigger factor, though I know a lot of people find modern "louder" recordings to be a source of fatigue. That is a likely category of recordings to cause listening fatigue, but I find many modern "louder" recordings to actually be quite good, only a small % blatantly fatiguing. I wonder if some are actually designed to grate on your nerves rather than happen to come out that way.
I'm not going to read the prior responses because I think the issue of so-called listener fatigue is too complicated to answer with a simple post. Possible sources could start with the quality of input materials (e.g. CDs or LPs), could be tonearm and carty imcompatibility, and work its way to the speakers. Even simple downstream component incompatibility could be the culpret. Of course the easy answer may be the speakers.
As regards the issue of compatibility, there are a number of threads currently running about so called tube friendly and SS friendly speakers. The consensus seems to be that a mismatch between speakers and amps could cause an ear-ache.
Bottom lione: I wish there was a simple answer. I don't believe there is, but if one quickly trips on the solution, the problem could be easily resolved. Unfortunately, the solution may require switching out components, even though as a stand alone, the offending component may be an excellent piece of gear.
Listener Fatigue is just your brain trying to translate something it knows is not real into something that sounds real. The hareder this is for gray matter the harder this on you. When you get to 3-4 hrs of listening still feeling good, stop spending money.
But upgrade implies better or more expensive accordingly. Maybe practically its simply just time to fix things. It may cost more or less in the end than what you started with. Practically, spending more is probably part of what makes us feel better in the end, but I would not assume that.
Agree with Csontos, it's the distortion. The problem is, even when you get rid of as much distortion as you can, there's still a great deal of distortion in the sound. We tend to assume that's what it's supposed to sound like, that any remaining distortion must be the fault of the recording. Pop Quiz: Where on Earth does all that remaining distortion come from?
"An ordinary man has no means of deliverance." - Old audiophile axiom
So this leads me to another question: can you have all the "juicy" detail, and yet have a warm sound too?
Yes, if you have two systems.
Just as your analogy with vehicles, they are designed for a certain perfomance. There are pick-up trucks and sports cars, there are detailed systems and there are musical systems. They cannot be one in the same.
Over drive your amp even just a little bit and those low distortion figures will increase exponentially in some cases. In any case it's going to be distortion that causes fatigue. Usually when it's turned up loud. Odd order harmonics and IMD typically.
It's funny that I think I might be a detail freak. I love detail, but I'm not so sure that I prefer "dry" and "clinical" and I think that's actually slightly what I have. I think Jmcgrogan hit the nail on the head when he said that it's stimulation overload that sometimes leads to listener fatigue.
So this leads me to another question: can you have all the "juicy" detail, and yet have a warm sound too? I really enjoy pinpoint imaging and detail but I'm wondering now if a "musical" sound backs off the detail and pinpoint imaging that I've grown to love. I see how people can collect enough gear for two or three nice systems and end up keeping it all. It's like having the truck for camping, the sports car for track days and canyon carving, and then the luxury seden for cruising.
Soooo, what are your oppinions about what listener fatigue is and why it's caused?
I feel listening fatigue is a mental and/or emotional sense of being, not so much a physical issue with the ears. I find it most commonly occurs with me when my system has taken a turn towards a more resolving, clinical, analytical type of sound. Detail, detail everywhere, mental stimulation overload leads me towards shorter and shorter listening sessions. Sometimes leading me to not firing up the rig at all. The mind is burning up trying to take in all of this information and detail.
The cure is to remove the gear, cables, etc. that led to this hyper-detail sound in the first place and replace them with more musical pieces.
I would second Brauser's suggestion that you may simply have the volume up too high. A great many audiophiles love to listen at a very high volume level, which will definitely lead to listening fatigue much quicker than listening at reasonable levels. I posted a thread several months back about volume levels and hearing loss, you might want to search for that under my moniker and check it out.
Listener fatigue can be brought on in a number of ways. Here's a couple of common ones. 1) Overdrive your system by turning the volume up just a little bit too high. Most systems have a threshold volume level that is comfortable from which even a modest increase will introduce an annoying effect that reduces the pleasure of the experience to some degree. 2) Incorporating system elements that move the system to the bright side of neutral. I recall some years ago trying out a new pure silver interconnect. Nothing against silver, but this particular one was great in capturing detail but also added a hardness to the sound that I just couldn't handle.
Being involved in this hobby for over 40 years now I've seen a lot of system elements come and go. The one thing that I will not tolerate is Listener Fatigue.
You have the right idea and are on the correct path.
The most common denominator for me is that the system does not sound natural, involving and lacks emotion/feeling. There are many adjectives used to describe a system that can lead to fatigue, Among them: bright, harsh, lean, clinical, analytical, forward, cool/cold, sterile, un-emotional, tipped up, Hi-Fi.
When you find yourself listening for a system to do all the "Audiophile Gymnastics" it is already too late. Emotion and musicality to me should be first and foremost. Either you are listening to MUSIC or your EQUIPMENT. The equipment needs to be a window that is transparent and allows the musics to flow through it without being artificial.
" Now, I'm thinking that listener fatigue is maybe more than your ears just getting tired but actually, your whole body getting tired and feeling drained."
You're not on a treadmill by any chance when you listen, are you? I find it better to go to the gym first, before listening. This allows me to prepare for the difficult trials that await me in my listening room. You may also want to have some energy drinks before listening, just to be on the safe side.
You must have a verified phone number and physical address in order to post in the Audiogon Forums. Please return to Audiogon.com and complete this step. If you have any questions please contact Support.
