Jazz for aficionados


Jazz for aficionados

I'm going to review records in my collection, and you'll be able to decide if they're worthy of your collection. These records are what I consider "must haves" for any jazz aficionado, and would be found in their collections. I wont review any record that's not on CD, nor will I review any record if the CD is markedly inferior. Fortunately, I only found 1 case where the CD was markedly inferior to the record.

Our first album is "Moanin" by Art Blakey and The Jazz Messengers. We have Lee Morgan , trumpet; Benney Golson, tenor sax; Bobby Timmons, piano; Jymie merrit, bass; Art Blakey, drums.

The title tune "Moanin" is by Bobby Timmons, it conveys the emotion of the title like no other tune I've ever heard, even better than any words could ever convey. This music pictures a person whose down to his last nickel, and all he can do is "moan".

"Along Came Betty" is a tune by Benny Golson, it reminds me of a Betty I once knew. She was gorgeous with a jazzy personality, and she moved smooth and easy, just like this tune. Somebody find me a time machine! Maybe you knew a Betty.

While the rest of the music is just fine, those are my favorite tunes. Why don't you share your, "must have" jazz albums with us.

Enjoy the music.
orpheus10
Post removed 

Rok, like you pointed out Chuck Mangione, there is another artist that had his time in the Sun at about that same time, and that's Eumir Deodato. I have a number of his cuts on my "play list".


      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jRPzvgugShI&list=PLG9jLl6Ldd_gJ8vwZKDPOmudIuLp-EMiS


      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=boXD-tsBuOA
Schubert, if this is of any meaning to you, I would be quite sad if you leave. If my memories serves me right, once before you have already taken the pause from the thread and I was glad when you have returned.

Odd as it may seem, since this is quite impersonal way of communication, still is and man somehow becomes 'close' to all caracters here, despite or because of their diversity.

I guess written things might seem 'heavier' than spoken ones and with that notion in mind, it becomes easier to look over some.

As Johnny  Cash would say in StQuentin prison....
'I can understan how do you fell about some things,not of my business how do you think about some other things and I dont give a damn how do you feel abot some other things'.... 

Well, if that does not work, than I can only think of this...

https://youtu.be/2lAY-rRRa4o
schubert, forgetting is easier said than done.  I was only there from the safety of distance in intelligence photos.  So I admit I can't truly imagine what the experience must have been.

Now I would hope you can find peace through the escape in music.  Focus on that as much as your time will allow.  I too hope you don't leave, you are a worthy contributor.  Perhaps when you visit the site your discipline will allow you to skip to the next post as soon as you see anything other than jazz being mentioned and not become tangled in "the other stuff".  

Such analysis is beyond my pay grade but I suspect that continuing on here could be beneficial in being reminded of older music you've forgotten, by hearing new things you enjoy, and by generally stoking your mind with information on a subject you obviously enjoy so much.  Peace brother.
Post removed 
frogman

Awesome Sonny Stitt selections. Here is Miles proving that you can "evolve" while still sounding awesome:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VN0rvZwTwRI

The change of pace around 18:30 is, IMHO, awesomely great.

New York Jazz could have been titled "Stitts Best Bop"; that album featured "Bop" almost as good as the man who brought the "Bop" game to town, Charles "Yardbird" Parker.

My collection is loaded with Stitt contributions, and I enjoyed the one's Frogman contributed.

The best sax solo ever, is the one by "Joe Henderson" on Grant Green's "Idle Moments".

The cut "Idle Moments" was supposed to have been only 7 minutes long, but when Joe Henderson got in his groove, and it was apparent the cut was going to go over, Rudy Van Gelder, the recording engineer, who was also in the groove, decided that there was no way he was going to stop this, so he let Joe blow until Joe stopped.


        https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aq0m0hbCjFQ


       



Sometime when I hear Grant Green, I almost break out in tears. I knew Grant Green, I can't say I was a friend, but his best friend and fellow musician was a close friend of mine.

Some of the reasons I break out in tears are too personal to reveal, but one of the reasons is how tragic his personal life was, and the fact that he should have been rich.

Grant Green was a man of the streets, and as such, that was the way he lived. I knew and heard him even before he made his first record. He was a star in and around St. Louis before "Blue Note" came and got him. Grant's music that I heard isn't even recorded, except in my mind, I heard Grant Green play for Grant Green; it sounded like he was crying on the inside and trying to soothe his tears.
Dexter Gordon's solo on "Tanya" from the album "One Flight Up" is a masterpiece as well. It also happen to be one of my favorite jazz songs. Just a great composition. Along with Gordon is Donald Byrd on trumpet, Niels-Henning Orsted Pedersen on bass, Kenny Drew on piano and Art Taylor on drums.

No wonder its such a great tune and album as well. A must have for jazz aficionado's
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yaxb70VaEZs

Idle Moments:

Outstanding title track.   This should be up there in 'KOB' and 'Somethin' Else' Territory.  It just 'sounds' like playing a sax softly is a difficult thing to do.

The time length situation reminded me of the Emperor telling Mozart his Opera was great, just too many notes.   But given the time constraints of the LP, it's understandable. 

I am listening to the CD version.  It has enough room for the alternate takes  of both 'Django' and 'Jean De Fleur'.

Cheers

How did I get so many Grant Green CDs?  The OP's influence at work?

Pjw, thanks for alerting me to that LP, which is how I'll get it; the soul of the horn and the musician is best on vinyl, but CD is good too.

Those artists have jelled so well together that each one of them is a star, although Dexter Gordon and Donald Byrd's solos stands out; that makes them a star among stars. 

Every aficionado I talked to who knew Dexter, told me he was playing himself in the movie "Round Midnight"; there was no acting involved, we were watching Dexter being Dexter.

I will get that ASAP, probably CD, and shop for the LP.

Rok, there are more jazz LP's better than KOB than you can shake a stick at; you let them pick theirs and you pick yours.
Abstract Truth:

***** Not the best albums ever,*****

I agree with "the  best" of anything being almost impossible to determine, but this album is as good as any.

Cheers

When I was in the Air Force, in 1960, my room mate brought KOB for us to share for the first time. I liked it, and he thought it was spectacular; he was the first of the KOB breed.

It's been a long time since 1960, and so many boss LP's have gone past these ears since that time; it would stand to mathematical reason that one of them would be better than KOB.

Rok, when you hear people talking about how many special LP's they have of KOB, you know what conclusion to come to when it comes to jazz.

I rest my case.

“I never even thought about whether or not they understand what I'm doing . . . the emotional reaction is all that matters as long as there's some feeling of communication, it isn't necessary that it be understood.” John Coltrane

That's what John Coltrane said, and now some one posted this thread;


      Help me understand John Coltrane .... seriously.


That thread has 113 posts. Can you guess why I have not posted on that thread?


Yes I Can.   It's that academic crowd.   I think they are finally even getting to Wynton.   He no longer sounds like he is from New Orleans.   Sad.

Cheers

In high school, I took physics, chemistry and Algebra III. In algebra III you had to solve several different complex problems before you could even begin to answer the question. That meant you had to set up the equation at each step of the game.

In each one of those subjects there was only "one" answer to the question.


This is not physics, chemistry, or algebra III; this is jazz, the answer to the question has to be provided by "you", not me but "you".

Nothing is more comical to me, than the fact that others look to a resident "Guru", who has musical knowledge comparable to those who have graduated from "Julee- Yard", for answers.

If this was chemistry, physics, or algebra III, that would make all the sense in the world, but this is not an absolute science; jazz is abstract music created by musicians who may not even know where or what "Julee - Yard" is; they create music from the soul.

Our resident "Guru" and myself are on opposite ends of the musical spectrum, that's well known. There are a multitude of questions he can answer in regard to the mechanics of music, but he can not answer questions that fall into the "metaphysical" realm of music.

This post might seem to indicate an element of envy regarding our resident "Guru", but I consider it to be a statement of fact.

You draw your conclusions from that, and whatever conclusions you draw are correct.
Best of the blue note vol 1 and 2
Best of Chet Baker Sings
Best of Big Joe Turner
Kind of Blue
Somethin' Else
Lady Day Love Songs

Too many to list lol
@orpheus10   Couldn't agree more with this:

there are more jazz LP's better than KOB than you can shake a stick at; you let them pick theirs and you pick yours.

KOB is sort of like a gateway drug.  It was easy for the masses to get their head around start to experience jazz.  I realize some never wanted to go any further to challenge their senses.  I continue to dive down the jazz rabbit hole.  I need to go back and read postings in this thread to get fresh ideas.

Three_easy_payments, there have been many who have come and gone, but left something significant in this thread while passing through; that would not be a waste of time.

Keegiam, I remember your 98 Olds very well, it was a land yacht of distinction that floated over the highway. Did it have a button on the floor that you could press to move the radio dial without taking your hands off the steering wheel?

They had the best radios available at that time.
How sad that the level of insecurity and emotional reliance on being “top dog” (to use his term) is so high that it can cause an individual to stoop to such a level of negativity and condescension. Instead of, at least, simple respect for a different point of view; or, at most, use it as an opportunity to learn something new, the approach is, instead, to demean in an effort to pump oneself up. Once again, it becomes obvious that for some it is not really about love for the music; but, instead, love for how much they want to feel that they “love” the music; a calling card.

I could say a lot more, but it would be pointless. However, the reason to point this out is that this narrow and close minded attitude is antithetical to one of the very core values of the music itself; open mindedness and respect for the unknown which is what leads to creativity itself. However, better to make a point by way of example:

There is probably not a single prominent Jazz musician, past (post 1959, of course) or present, that doesn’t recognize KOB as one of the greatest Jazz recordings ever made. Many, if forced to choose, might choose it as “the greatest”. How listeners feel about the recording is well known. But, wait! Our OP, who needlessly has to turn discussions negative, contentious, and into a competition asserts that “there are more jazz LP’s better than KOB than you can shake a stick at;”..............right.

O-10, I am not competing with you and you shouldn’t be so concerned with competing with me. I have less than zero interest in being top dog or any kind of guru. You want to lay claim to superior, even exclusive. appreciation of some abstract “metaphysical” component in Jazz? That’s fine; good for you. So.....explain yourself. Show what you got! Stating that KOB is “not that good” is meaningless. Tell us, in relevant detail, why recording X, Y, or Z is better; and, in detail, why KOB is inferior. Anything other than that is simply agenda driven opinion: not, as you claim, “fact”.

Eeny Meeny Miny Moe
Catch an OP by the toe
If he hollers let him go
Eeny Meeny Miny Moe

Herbie Hancock Orpheus ten
Who to trust just like Burns Ken
If he hollers let him go
Herbie Hancock Orpheus ten

https://youtu.be/Pwc1d4qxz4M

Modern jazz, while being music, is also a form of communication above and beyond all spoken languages; that's why Bobby Timmons "Moanin" can communicate with people everywhere around the world, no need to speak English, this tune is communicated in the language of music, it's universally understood around the world.


          https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cNjRQo-zpKA


This "music" is communicating "down and out".


          https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cv9NSR-2DwM



Modern jazz communicates a range of thoughts and emotions that can not be communicated by the best linguist in whatever language; all you gotta do is listen.
Music is the universal language, in that everyone hears music and likes / dislikes it, and understands what's being said,  the problem is, are we all understanding the same thing.   We don't have to, for it to be universal.   The emotional response is what makes it universal.

Cheers

Frogman, why do you always, 100% of the time, misinterpret my words? If you wish to engage in a conversation, let us do so.

I was comparing two different points of view. While I comically referred to "Juilliard", one of the most prestigious schools in the nation, I meant no harm.


How sad that the level of insecurity and emotional reliance on being “top dog” (to use his term) is so high that it can cause an individual to stoop to such a level of negativity and condescension. Instead of, at least, simple respect for a different point of view; or, at most, use it as an opportunity to learn something new, the approach is, instead, to demean in an effort to pump oneself up. Once again, it becomes obvious that for some it is not really about love for the music; but, instead, love for how much they want to feel that they “love” the music; a calling card.



Forgive me Frogman, I had no idea I was doing all of that, it was certainly not my intention.

I didn’t know that I was emotionally insecure; I’ll have to check the budget and see if I can afford a psychiatrist, they are very expensive you know.

In regard to KOB, you are proving everything I stated; you are taking the stance that it’s objective and one should automatically regard KOB, as the best jazz ever; while I’m saying each listener should reserve that decision for him or herself.

All of those people who spoke, spoke for themselves, and when I speak, it’s for me; I don’t allow other people to speak for me.


Frogman, on this entire Agon forum, audiophiles can talk for days about this speaker or that speaker, but as you know, mine are custom made. If my rig is designed for me, why shouldn’t my collection be the same?
 The emotional response is what makes it universal.

Rok, maybe you said what I was trying to say?

Frogman, there have been albums on the last two pages that are contenders for being better than KOB. But as I stated, it's not for me to decide for others, they decide for themselves; I'm not a "Guru".
We would have to be clones and have had exactly the same life experiences to get the same thing from every piece of music.

How depressing is that.

Cheers

Rok, I don't mean to belittle others taste in music, but there ain't no gravel roads in St. Louis. I think this is where you're coming from.


          https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YgnnrZfoZS0

Rok, I have asked myself major questions about Grant Green that I believe are related. The first question is why don't I have Grant Green records as opposed to CD's. I have Kenny Burrell records. Those records came out when there was no such thing as CD.

Once I was told there could be a wide difference between the recording date and the release date.  I just don't know why I don't have Grant Green records?

I thought Grant Green was at least well to do, as opposed to being so poor that he had to go to New York when his doctor told him it would kill him?

Ray Charles had a drug problem, and he wasn't poor.  Many musicians have had drug problems and made enough money to pay for drugs and not be poor.  I forgot, we're only supposed to talk about music.

Rok, I don't know anyone who doesn't have that album; I was riding with some people who liked Kenny G, and  they had him on.  They also had that CD which I politely requested they play.
Alex, by 1961 "Moanin" was a jazz standard and could be heard in most lounges; I remember the time well.
Today's Listen:

Dee Dee Bridgewater  --  ELEANORA FAGAN TO BILLIE WITH LOVE FROM DEE DEE BRIDGEWATER

2 Disc set.  CD with DVD.   DVD from a performance in Spain.  Stunning cover art photo.   Can be added to her tributes Ella, Silver and Kurt Weill.  All excellent.   Great booklet with photos.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FD7D0Ba6ITU   

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4DoG61GzIvc   

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BnnIkqxj8n0  

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4a0VDjEUEmY   

I know you Aficionados know this, but anyway,  Eleanora Fagan is Billie Holiday's birth name.

Cheers



Although I like the authenticity of Billie’s voice, the music and recording quality of this recording is off the chart.

This album won the 2011 Grammy Award for Best Jazz Vocal Album, Bridgewater’s third Grammy win in her career.


"Lady Sings the Blues" (Billie Holiday, Herbie Nichols) – 3:31
"All of Me" (Gerald Marks, Seymour Simons) – 2:58
"Good Morning Heartache" (Ervin Drake, Dan Fisher, Irene Higginbotham) – 5:10
"Lover Man (Oh, Where Can You Be?)" (Jimmy Davis, Roger ("Ram") Ramirez, and James Sherman) – 4:43
"You’ve Changed" (Bill Carey, Carl Fischer) – 5:11
"Miss Brown to You" (Leo Robin, Richard A. Whiting, Ralph Rainger) – 2:12
"Don’t Explain" (Holiday, Arthur Herzog, Jr.) – 6:15
"Fine and Mellow" (Holiday) – 4:55
"Mother’s Son-In-Law" (Alberta Nichols, Mann Holiner) – 2:46
"God Bless the Child" (Holiday, Herzog) – 5:13
"A Foggy Day" (George Gershwin, Ira Gershwin) – 4:33
"Strange Fruit" (Abel Meeropol) – 4:16



Personnel
Dee Dee Bridgewater - vocals, producer, artistic director
Christian McBride - double bass
Lewis Nash - drums
Edsel Gomez - Piano 

James Carter - who plays bass clarinet, alto flute, soprano saxophone, tenor saxophone, is quite impressive on this album, it will be added to my collection.

"God Blessed The Child", written by Billie Holliday is the song on this album that touched me most, while I liked the music on the cut "Lady Sings The Blues" best.



Gil Scot Heron must be turning over in his grave; 1974 was 56 years ago and everything he tried to change is much worse; the "Ghetto" was a paradise compared to what it is today.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=drTjTE8MCBU&list=PLRzdMCYnDofrWAMGWuJb2EfQomHeDkDK3&index=6


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m2zKdIcOV5s&list=PLRzdMCYnDofrWAMGWuJb2EfQomHeDkDK3&index=5


Calling Gil Scott Heron a "Rapper" is an insult.
I remember having the LP "The Revolution will not be Televised" in my hands at a Sound Warehouse store in Austin, weighing whether to buy it or not.   I don't have it, so I guess I bought something else instead.   He didn't look like my idea of a Jazz player.

But, the clips you posted I like, proving, you can't, and shouldn't try, to judge a book by it's cover.

Cheers
Geoffkait, I was thinking about Billie Holliday when I did the math and how tragic her life was; especially in regard to narcotics.  But I keep forgetting, we are supposed to separate the music from the musician because that's another subject and it might cause conflict.