I’m not familiar with your country’s electrical distribution system. But if your nominal voltage is 230 and you’re measuring 260V, that’s about a 13 percent deviation. That’s a huge discrepancy. In the US, for example, power is generally regulated to within 5 percent. So if it is at all possible for you, I’d suggest exploring whether your utility can improve its voltage regulation. Sometimes, a utility doesn’t know it has a problem until someone alerts them.
Jay's Audio CDT2 MK3 hum
Hi all! Greetings from Poland. My first post here after years of reading the forum!
Recently I have purchased Jay’s Audio CDT2 MK3 (230V European version), actually following the comments and recommendations read at Audiogon. All is great with it except the hum it emits from its casing. I should say “hums”. The one that was occasionally audible from the left side (where transformers sit) I eliminated by using a DC-blocker. However, there is audible hum peaking at 300 Hz coming from the right side. Its level is dependent from line voltage which at my place sometimes reaches and exceeds 260 V (230 V is nominal voltage) for short periods during sunny days (lots of PV installations around and old power lines). I tried on-line UPS with selectable voltage output and there was no hum at 220 V, neglectable at 230V and audible from my listening position at 240V. At 250V and above it is really bad. Of course I can’t hear it while music plays but it is annoying when in standby. It is kind of fake standby as in fact the unit seems fully powered except for the display. It takes 12W playing and 9W in standby or turned on (not spinning) with display off.
Obviously, I tried it disconnected from my DAC, different lines in the house, turning off all the lines except the one feeding my audio. The hum from the right side of the unit is ONLY dependent on the voltage. My old Copland CSA14 and new CSA100 and old Roksan Kandy amps don’t hum. My Copland CDA266 and Roksan Kandy CDPs don’t hum. Does not matter how low or high the voltage is.
I contacted Beatechnik and they said it should not happen and advised to check it in their service in Slovenia. Paid, as I purchased it from a private importer, so it is not covered by their warranty. In the meantime I bought a voltage controller with servo motor which keeps the voltage right. Not really a correct hi fi approach I guess.
So, my question to Jay’s Audio CDT2 MK3 owners, preferably from the EU, can you hear any hum from your units, coming from the right side of the casing? Does it fluctuate depending on mains voltage?
Thanks for reading and looking forward to read about your experience!
Sorry my comment is not helpful to Tomasz, but I'm interested that you mentioned PV and old power lines as the cause of the high voltage. I recently installed solar PV, and occasionally one or two of the panels stop producing power because of high voltage. My solar company reported: "Based on our checking, the system encounters high voltages ranging from 250-262V from time to time." So perhaps this will become more of a problem with more solar installation in the future?
Tomasz - is the problem only during the daytime, or do you also get the hum at night? |
Bummer. Can't help you since I run USA power, no clue what EU power units may sound like. My Jay's cdt2-mk3 has been nothing but pure joy. If I understand you correctly, on your next purchase, make sure you buy directly from Beatechnik. They specifically say that any of their equipment bought from the various Chinese outfits that discount their items is not covered by their warranty. Obviously the $300 savings is insignificant now. |
@cleeds : Here in Poland +/- 10% is allowed, so up to 253V is "OK". Technicians were called, checked the voltage and confirmed the problem is with excessive local production by PV installations. Power lines will need to be replaced which will not happen any time soon. In case of any damages excessive voltage can make, they pay for repair. I'm monitoring my installation with Supla system and Zamel monitors and all the anomalies are recorded. @tonnesen My installation consists of two strings, 6 + 4 kWp, oriented east-west. Fronius inverter I have, stops working in case of 254V+ measured in any phase constantly for a few minutes, then checks back and if voltage dropped, starts again. The inverter stops working and not individual panels or strings of panels. Your installation must be different. Sure there will be more problems if more installations will be connected, here and where you live, if no new lines and perhaps auto transformers will be installed in the local network. No hum at night when voltage drops to 230V or below. @baylinor I have a written warranty from a local-private importer so it is not that I am not covered. Starting this discussion I just wanted to be better prepared with my claim. If I get any responses from the members (especially from EU) that the transport is DEAD quiet (in the casing) at any excessive voltages, it will be strong indication that my unit needs repair. Another possibility is that all units slightly hum but their users are not bothered... Funny is that the Berkeley Audio Design HDCD DAC of the importer hums like hell (by my standards at least), but he likes it so much so ignores the noise. "Unfortunately" at his place voltage is dead stable so my problem could not be replicated. You said "no clue what EU power units may sound like" but I don't hear the power unit which is on the left side but something buzzing at the right side. Is there anything that could vibrate there resulting in 300Hz noise?
|
Depending on the price you paid, you still might have got a better deal If Beatechnic’s warranty is anything like Denifrips. I bought a Denifrips DAC that started acting wonky. After seven weeks of back and forth, I sent it in and they popped in a new DSP board and sent it back. I paid shipping both ways. All the best. |
How about adding a power conditioner/regenerator? My Jays CDT2 MK3 is dead silent but I"m in the US AND I power it via a PS Audio Stellar PowerPlant3. I'm not a big believer in "power cords" but I had an extra super thick power cord that came with some other product a while ago that was not being used - So, I have that in play also. None of this may help or apply to your situation - but just wanted to add some options. PS. I wasn't a believer in power conditioners/regenerators either... until I decided to "test" the PowerPlant3. But to my great surprise it made a noticeable improvement to everything. |
Thanks all for the comments. @knock1 Thanks for confirming yours Jay's is totally silent. Are you from Europe? Have you measured your voltage? "I would think that such a high voltage might cause the hum": If this is normal situation with CDT2 MK3 EU version, it is quite disappointing. None of my other old and new EU made pieces seem sensitive to the voltage anomalies. ZERO hum even at 260V. The simplest test to see whether it is some design flaw or a problem specific to my unit, would be to borrow another Jay's and compare them side by side at my place. Not impossible. @creativepart Thanks for confirming your Jay's is silent. I have my $80 power "regenerator" keeping my voltage at 228-232 V and it fixes the problem. Not the most elegant way, though. @baylinor I don't want to break the seal on it to eventually lost warranty. Whatever it is worth... Would like to leave it to my importer but the problem is his voltage is stable and nothing buzzes at his place.
|
@knock1 Hi Tomasz! So you must have Polish roots :) Been traveling a bit but finally got the transport to the seller. He's borrowed an autotransformer to play with higher voltages than nominal and confirmed my observations. He's found that once the top lid is off there is no hum audible. He experimented a bit with the transformers, which don't produce any audible sound when the lid is off. With the lid on the screws needed loosening to silence the hum. So, the whole thing that bothered me whole summer is the transport housing resonance amplifying otherwise inaudible vibrations of the transformers. Hell knows why it is the strongest on the right side. I am relieved that it is only a mechanical "issue" and nothing wrong in the electronics. Although I fixed it by using a cheap voltage stabilizer, I might try to put some anti-vibration insulators under the trafos, So there would be no rigid connection between the transformers and the transport housing. Again, thanks for all the comments. |