Thanks for the all the responses so far.
The Kora looks very nice, but I don't think I could get it for 1,500.
The AI 3A was high on my list, but it lacks headphone output or two tape loops. Same problem with the BAT.
So that leaves the Rogue 99 w/ phono. Can anyone comment on the performance of the 99's phonostage? LP is my primary source.
Asonicyouth's suggestion of linestage + phonostage has been something I've considered and his specific combo is one that I've already looked into. I'm just trying to cut down on the number of boxes. Though if the choice comes down to excellent vinyl playback v. clutter, I think playback would win.
Thanks again, and let me know if there's another candidate I should consider.