Cheap starter system for kids
A friend who is definitely not an audiophile has two kids who have gotten into vinyl using some junky all-in-one turntables that just now broke. He wanted my advice on helping them put together their new systems but definitely isn’t ready to jump into the deep end just yet.
I generally enjoy the game of building theoretical systems from scratch so hoped some of you would too. The system needs to be for beginners in their tweens/early teens, include a turntable, be relatively compact as it goes in a bedroom, does not need deep bass to avoid annoying their mom, and it needs to be as cheap as you can get with still good sound quality (he hasn’t given me a sure budget yet but definitely under $1k and the lower the better). He’s only comfortable with new/refurbished gear rather than used or vintage.
So far I’m leaning towards:
Turntable:
Project debut carbon - $400
or
Rega P1 - $475
Phono:
Schiit Mani - $130
or
Cambridge Alva Solo - $180 (if he’d rather pay $50 to avoid all the Schiit jokes from a tween boy)
Speakers: Audioengine HD3 - $350
Look forward to your ideas & comments.
I generally enjoy the game of building theoretical systems from scratch so hoped some of you would too. The system needs to be for beginners in their tweens/early teens, include a turntable, be relatively compact as it goes in a bedroom, does not need deep bass to avoid annoying their mom, and it needs to be as cheap as you can get with still good sound quality (he hasn’t given me a sure budget yet but definitely under $1k and the lower the better). He’s only comfortable with new/refurbished gear rather than used or vintage.
So far I’m leaning towards:
Turntable:
Project debut carbon - $400
or
Rega P1 - $475
Phono:
Schiit Mani - $130
or
Cambridge Alva Solo - $180 (if he’d rather pay $50 to avoid all the Schiit jokes from a tween boy)
Speakers: Audioengine HD3 - $350
Look forward to your ideas & comments.
17 responses Add your response
This Pioneer PLX-500 comes with a built in phono preamp and cartridge! https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1345767-REG/pioneer_plx_500_k_direct_drive.html/overview |
You can get some great deals on Thorens too. The older ones are really easy to fix if they ever do break. They are belt driven. A lot of the models parts interchange. I have a dozen or so. LOL. Look! 100-1500.00 for the same TT one with a heavy Plinth, one without. Belts 10 dollars.. Carts get scratchers (DJ stuff) 20-150 for 2 or 3. A good receiver, like Sansui, Pioneer Spec, there are a few good ones with Phono on board . Throw in a good Sony SCD for 200.00 if you looking. Speakers, just a ton to chose from. I like the older Infinity for the money. 100-400.00. A lot of parts to keep them in tip top shape.. VMPS if you can find a pair you like... Big boom boom for the kiddies..No subs needed... Fewer the parts better off you are ay? Receiver TT Zip Cord Speakers CD option Music Channel option Regards |
Used nice and clean Technics SL1200 mkII for about $400 Kids are not like audiophiles, buy a DJ turntable for them so they can move record back and forth on a turntable that can survive after first try (belt drive can’t and most likely will be destroyed quickly). For a brand new look for this Denon or Pioneer |
Oh I enjoy a good system build, especially with a budget... it's fun! Are you locked into the powered speakers? That might limit the number of devices you can hook up if they have varied interests. I've been kicking around this same scenario for when my kids are a bit older and wanting their first "real" systems. If I was locked into new I think I'd start with a trip to Parts Express and get a pair of Dayton B652 or B652-Air. I have them as near field monitors at work and they are amazing for around $60 shipped. Parts Express also has some very inexpensive amps in a variety of flavors to suit input needs, power, bluetooth, etc. You can get out of there for around $200 and then add one of the entry level U-Turns or Fluance decks with built in phono stage. That's a pretty inexpensive investment for kids. But you could also spend a bit more go with: The Elac Debut 2.0 B6 for around $250. Pair that with a Denon PMA-600NE or NAD C316BEEv2. That's under $1,000 without tax/shipping. |
msafrick1 posts05-13-2020 9:30amI have the Pro-Ject Debut Carbon. They come with clear spot tape. If you don't install the tape the lid will fall off. They do teach how to handle a manual tonearm though.. I learned when I was just 6 or so.. 59 years ago..LOL. A Garrard 301/Grace tonearm.. RUSSCO TT bullet proof. you can't break it. I forgot about those. I have 6 or 8 QRC, Russco, Sparta.. VERY COOL TT. I gotta post some pictures, of the Broadcast and Transcription TT, collection.. Tons of fun.. I'll bet the kids and the parents would love it... I call them Garrard Killers, Massive... 100-1000.00 usd Motors look like washing machine motors. Tone arm boards too. They come with a little onboard tube preamp sometimes, too, BUT open wiring on the bottom, gotta be on a good plinth, I make mine out of oak stair flats, 40-60 lbs, 28.00 dollars, takes two. I use Queen Ann Legs, very classy looking. You can use multi tonearms too. EASY swap. Plinth or Tonearm mount. 24/7 for 30 years....easy maint too. Regards |
Thanks for all the input. Unfortunately for those who recommended used gear, the buyer here is definitely not comfortable with that even though its probably the best value. I'm definitely not locked in to powered speakers, but my friend has heard AE HD3s on my computer at work so I was just leaning towards whats familiar to both of us. I considered the Elac B6s paired with an amp or receiver, but I haven't heard them in person yet...still trying to gauge how complicated they'd be comfortable with the systems being and powered speakers keep it super simple plus add bluetooth (not that there aren't other options for that) to let them and their friends play stuff they don't have on vinyl. Since dad isn't himself familiar with audiophile gear, the many suggestions for a TT with built-in phono preamp are probably a good idea too for the simplicity mentioned above...or at least a amp/receiver with phono input if we do go for passive speakers I know turntables and kids don't always mix, so the idea of going a bit more robust with a DJ style TT like the Pioneer PLX-500 or Audiotechnica LP-120 might be wise...or perhaps automatic (Denon DP-300F)?? Appreciate all the opinions/suggestions. Thanks |
DJ turntables are mostly rubbish, except for Technics (the leader of the industry for decades) and recently a Pioneer and Denon as alternative, please ignore any others, they are not good! Buy what professionals are using (not amateurs), even if you think they are looks the same they are not the same at all. Every brand tried to clone Technics and make it cheaper (bad idea). Technics is the best you can get and this is actually great Hi-Fi component (the mk7 is what you have to look for) ! Don’t be afraid to pay a bit more for it, you’re paying for the quality and this turntable can be used for 30 years. Pioneer and Denon re not bad, especially for kids. They are easy to re-sell, but those can be used for a very long time and kids will not destroy them. You can have new Technics mk7 (this is the best of them all). Pioneer PLX1000 as alternative or Denon VL12 P.S. Don't even think about belt-drive when you're buyin turntable for kids, it will be destroyed quickly :)) |
If it were me in this scenario and I didn't want one of the newer, cheaper belt drives, I'd go for something from this guy. https://horiatis76.com/ He sells fully refurbished decks, often with new dust covers, interconnects and stylus (if needed). I don't personally have experience buying from him but he's been at this a long time... and the higher end stuff goes quickly. But right now he has a nice selection of lower end DD tables, and I'd think any of them would work well for kids just getting into this stupid hobby. ;) Yea I get that your friend isn't into used but I think this is a pretty safe option. |