Best used integrated under $5k

Lyngdorf 2170 or 3400

Linear Tube Audio Integrateds are awesome. Worth a look for sure 

Love my Hegel h390

Will look at PrimaLuna , Ayre and Moon too. 
BTW I was talking to folks at Wilson. They pointed to Pass, Hegel and Luxman. 

The sound you are describing sounds like you should look seriously into a tube integrated...

PrimaLuna EVO400 integrated is very, very good and describes your needs to a tee. I would consider changing from EL34's to KT150 to give you more power and a slightly tighter and pushier low end. It's at a small cost of air and space (where EL34's excels).

Missing from your list: Ayre AX-5, Sim Moon 600i. Modwright 200 and 225.

Corelli, fair point. Hopefully the following will add some value to the exchange:

Here is the type of sound I like:

1. A tad bit warm while still having a lot of punch (nothing muddled about it)
2. Vocals (Diana Krall, John Mayer etc) have a level of cleanliness to it
3. Guitar (Gipsy kings, Jesse cook) sound airy without being lean
4. Speakers can fill a medium to large room (16’x16’x9’) even at modest volume and sitting on my sofa (9 ft away from speakers), I feel engulfed by the sound. Key is even at moderate volume. 
5. It may be related to my first point above; forgiving of recordings that weren’t mastered at very high quality. 

Best?  Hard to say.
Great bargain? Krell KAV 300i
https://www.stereophile.com/integratedamps/809/index.html

How can any useful info be shared when the OP did not state what SQ factors are important to him.  Likewise, not one responder saying why they value their choices other than features which anyone can look up.  Don't see much value in exchanges like this.

I would seriously listen to PrimaLuna EVO400 integrated. My buddy just had one home for an audition and it was nothing short of spectacular with his Audio Physic Virgo III's.

I have or had owned the Luxman and Pass Lab brands and recommend either one to you. The Hegel brand sounds very interesting however I've not had the privilege of listening to one.

Jjss49 - not sure why you say H360 doesn’t have a DAC. It does. However I will have to get a separate phone stage with it. 
While I am planning to use this with my TT, it’s nice to have the flexibility to stream too. However none of these units are so called Swiss Army knives And won’t have all of the below: 1. Streamer 2.DAC 3. Phono stage 4.Pre+Power

So with Hegel I will have go get phono.
With ML585, i will have to get a streamer and either get 585.5 or get a phono stage too. With ARC I will have to get a streamer/DAC and Phono stage. 
With Luxman will have to get streamer/ DAC. 
With the exception of Hegel H360, all of these will require a streamer, which is fine. 
I left out brands like Plinius. It will be great to hear inputs on what else shall I add or feedback on the list I have. 

From that list I’d pick Luxman or ARC, with ML or Hegel or Naim after that. 

Hegels are outstanding.  If you don't need the internal DAC then a used 360 would be very good.  If the onboard DAC is important, then get the new 390.  I love mine.  Best solid state I have heard in a quite a while.