2. analog
  3. 156870-132496

Considering a new Phono Pre-Amp

Hey Everyone,

Going to try and keep this short and simple.

I am considering a new Phono Pre-Amp. Currently have the Sim Audio 110lp V2 and it has been serving me well but wondering if a better Pre-Amp could further improve the system.

Here is what I am considering after much research and reviews:

- Herron VTPH-2A
I have read many great reviews of this particular device.

- Manley Chinook
Once Again read good reviews of this device also

- SimAudio 310lp
A step up from what I have now and has had good reviews. Also, everyone who reviews it states it’s extremely quiet, so I suppose that is a plus.

-Goldnote Ph10
I like the ability of this device to change settings on the fly. Have read good reviews but also possible noise issues?


The Herron and Manley of course are tube based so that’s one of the biggest differences between these 2 and the SimAudio and Goldnote.

I don't think I could go wrong with any of these because they are all quality products.

Well I wanted to get the communities opinion.

My only fear is, with my system, would I experience an improvement or not? Not Sure

Thanks
128x128jay73
rsf507
2,233 posts
 
Never any noise with PH10 NEVER.
varyat's avatar
varyat
145 posts
 
Whest PS 40RDT - read some reviews....Direct ship from manufacturer- he's a very easy chap to deal with...
varyat's avatar
varyat
145 posts
 
I use both SS and tubed phono stages. Both types can be great however I don't get the best from my tubed unit until at least an hour of warm up/play. If you are someone who listens to an album or two at a time then I would choose a SS model that can stay on 24/7 and be ready to go whenever you want. Just something else to think about...:)
jay73's avatar
jay73 OP
219 posts
 
Millercarbon, thanks for your insight on the Herron.

@slaw , never heard of that company before but I will check it out, thanks.

Thanks to everyone for their suggestion, much to think about.

Too bad I can't demo some of these units easily, that would make the decision a little easier but such is the case with Audio.
williewonka
3,072 posts
 
I have the Simaudio MOON LP 5.3 RS - which was the 310 predecessor and looks to be the same from the internal photos I have seen

I can confirm it is very silent, has amazing dynamics, clarity & detailing, with a huge detailed image.
- I did not elect to buy the optional power supply, but instead, treated it to the very best power and interconnect cables, which I believe accounts for the stunning performance I now enjoy.

The only down side: you have to take the cover off to get at the dip switches to setup the gain/capacitance/resistance settings.

No matter which phono stage you select, you will need good cables to allow the unit to perform to its maximum ability, so budget accordingly.

Cables are a tough thing to rationalize, because "it’s just wire" and to get cables that allow components to perform their very best you can end up spending more on the cables than you spent on the component.

My preferred choice of Cable Companies that have products that perform really well, include...
- Inakustic, Nordost, KLE Innovations

DIY cables is another option, if you are handy, but most people prefer established brands.

Regards - Steve


More to discover