2. smart-home
  3. 154705-128813

Trade all my Amazon Alexa Echos for Sonos for whole home audio?

I have about 15 Echo devices right now. I use them in groups (Upstairs, Downstairs, Everywhere, Master Bedroom, etc).  All are connected to my Eero Pro mesh wireless system which is awesome.  However, I'm getting sick and tired of the dropouts!  They work MOST of the time but the failure rate is too high.  Not all of them play....  They all play for 10 mins then say "I'm having trouble playing music right now" and all stop.. There are a number of problems.

So, my question is, would Sonos do better?  I know they'd "sound" better so I'd use less of them.  But is their multiroom platform more stable?

I've also heard the Alexa integration isn't very good in Sonos.. Like, you have to enunciate more for Alexa to understand you etc.

Thoughts?
dtximages
6 responses Add your response
lalitk's avatar
lalitk
5,443 posts
 
First off, 15 Echo devices are quite a lot...before your switch to Sonos or anything else, have you checked your network speed? It may be getting bogged down by so many devices in your household hence causing dropouts.

Check with you service provider and have them analyze your network system. 

I have both Sonos and Echo throughout my home and never experienced any dropouts. For my casual listening, I prefer Sonos over Echo.
dtximages OP
365 posts
 
Ok, I wasn't sure what my ISP could actually do. I have At&T 1GB service so it's very fast.  But perhaps that's a good next step

Also, 15 echos is a lot but it's well within the capability of the Eero wifi mesh.  Also, I have many other devices that work perfectly like light bulbs.  Very very rare to get a drop out on them now after switching to Eero.
tubegb's avatar
tubegb
190 posts
 
Another variable to consider is that although you have "1GB" service, it may not be actually providing anywhere near that speed. Full disclosure, I'm an AT&T customer and not a fan.
dtximages OP
365 posts
 
My ATT has been rock solid, of course I'm in a metro part of Dallas where AT&T is headquartered..  

But I pull anywhere from 300-700mbs through wifi... Depending.. Wired I can get 800ish.

So I'd say that's a success as I never expected to see 1GB.
simao's avatar
simao
1,819 posts
 
I think Sonos are sonically more preferable and more fidelity than Echo when used household. They have more range. However, the Klipsch The One II is also incredible along the same vein.
Post removed 
Log in to respond
More to discover
80x80
RTI T2X