Mac fanboy, have all their products. However, for music, I do not use any Mac gear, except my iPhone to control my streamer.
Going to suggest, removing the Mini, replacing it with a quality streamer. Don't change anything else yet. Just get used to the streamer, then go down the upgrade path.
I had my old ipod (yup, still got one) plugged into my system for a while. It sounded flat, hollow, and compressed.