The OP can probably see there are many ways to approach his desired outcome.
"I’ve pretty much eliminated the P6 but am also looking at a MOFI"
Even the highest level Rega, it still is a polarizing brand.
Having demoed the Mofi Ultradeck in my setup 6 years ago, I heard it as a "okay" piece for the price.
Now that it’s at $1500 retail, with a $500-1K whatever cart it can be nice setup for less than $2500. With a used $2-3K phonostage it will be a decent rig until a more substantial cash outlay for a used $5K table is desired. $3-5K used can get a noticeably "better" performing unit-IMO.