Indian Music?
For a little crossover Indian (not just with the West, but with Asian too), try "Global Fusion" with Subramaniam on Kanartic violin. Top class players and quite good sound. Nice long tracks that create a compelling vision. http://www.amazon.com/Global-Fusion-L-Subramaniam/dp/B00000JG3E Regards, |
HERE ARE % EXCELLENT SUGGESTIONS: 1. Anything by the great Nikhil Banerjee (there isn't much, he died young) 2. All of the 'signature series' recordings of Ali Akbar Khan on his own label 3. On Nimbus records, anything by Asad Ali Khan 4. Anything by Z.M. Dagar, the great Rudra Vina player 5. "Midnight" by Pandit Pran Nath |
I can't claim to know anything about classical Indian, but I have listened to it many hours and have a small collection. Imrat Khan, Raga Marwa, Nimbus Records Dhruba Ghosh, Sarangi, Bowing Sounds from Dawn to Moonlight,Fonti Musical The Sounds of India (details unknown, cannot locate just now) Ravi Shankar lives about 15 miles from me and typically plays a local venue each year. I've seen him about 6x now and look forward to seeing him again. I think he is 89 now and struggling with health. Jackson Brown (another local) has been on the front row of many of these concerts. |
I'll recommend these artists. First among many who I love is the master of the sarod, Buddhadev Das Gupta. His improvisational ability is unparalleled. He builds his ragas with emotionally charged energy that is amazing. His Nimbus recordings are great, but I've never heard a bad one. I've got every one of his cd's that are listed with pictures on the first page of the Amazon.com listing for him and they all are great. I really like the Sarod. Tejendra Naranyan Majumdar is also a great ambassador for the instrument. His Raga Hem Behag on the India Archive Label is a good one. In fact, every disc I've bought on that label is great. Another fine artist is Shiv Kumar Sharma, a virtuoso player of the Indian hammered dulcimer (Santoor.) His evening raga Janasammohini on the Realworld label is a great place to start. For something a bit less common, the Vina player Chiiti Babu's "The Art of the Vina" on the Seven Seas label is excellent. This one always amazes me with it's bluesy feeling. This one is out of print, but Amazon has more. I had the pleasure of seeing Budhaditya Mukherjee live on my birthday ten years ago and that was the most incendiary live concert I've ever seen in any musical genre. His performance was if you combined Stevie Ray Vaughn's power with Jascha Heifitz's precision and technical prowess. Again, Nimbus records is a good label for him, see Amazon.com. The bottom line is that you are not likely to find ANY recordings by an Indian classical artist that a subpar musically. The master/student system functions so rigorously that I don't think it's possible for any one to make to the recording studio that doesn't measure up to the high standards generations of prior musicians laid down. At least that's the way master musicians visiting our university's music department have presented their system of artist development. |
Great recommendations. Here's a few more: My favorite Indian performance is probably a collaboration with Ravi Shankar and Yehudi Menuhin called West Meets East -- riveting. His raga collection "From Dusk to Dawn" is also nice. For fans of 'A Meeting...' VM Bhatt has another fine recording on Water Lily called 'Saradamani.' He also has another with Taj Mahal called 'Mumtaz Mahal' theat serves as my reference for soundstaging. Shiv Kumar Sharma (playing santoor): 'The Valley Recalls' with Hariprasad Chaurasia (flute). Both have many fine recordings. Kalhor and Khan: 'Ghazal'; also 'Moon rise....' Ali Akbar Khan -- my favorite (musically) is 'Journey,' but there was a 'signature series' remastered by Bob Ludwig and Mark Levinson that has wonderful sonics. |
I like all the suggestions listed, although most of them are not "traditional", they are all worth listening to. I was surprised to see the criticism of Ry Cooder as "tired". I think that is one of the best world/hybrid discs and one of the best moments in Cooder's career. It is also one of the rare moments where great music has been recorded to audiophile standards. The separation of the instruments and the mic technique is extraordinary. I also join the others in suggesting that you can't go wrong with: Ali Akbar Khan I also suggest looking for recordings by any of these artists: Dr. L. Subramaniam on Karnatic Violin, Amjad Ali Khan on sarod and Ustad Vilayat Khan on sitar I am a big fan of the "India Archives Series". CD's are $12-$15 on average. I have picked up many of these and have not been let down once. For younger artists I suggest: Deobrat Mishra (son of Pandit Shivnath), Purbayan Chatterjee and Ranajit Sengupta (although he is now 40 and I guess could be considered not so young) Hope that helps a bit |
There are some names which are always good bets: Ali Akhbar Khan, Nikhil Banerjee, Ram Narayan, Zakir Hussein, Mahapurush Misra. The last two are tabla players, the first three play sarod, sitar and sarangi respectively. They are the best-known and always good but that doesn't mean lesser-known artists can't turn in some great performances. My own favourite musician is Zia Mohuiddin Dagar on rubra vina. This is an antique instrument that very few know how to play, and Z. M. does the slower movements exclusively: alap and jor. To me it is very profound and meditative music. Perhaps I should mention that the only living persons I name are Ram Narayan, who is over 80, and Zakir Hussein, who will soon be 60. I would love to know more about the younger generation. |
The vocalists Parween Sultana and Dilshad Khan seem to defy what is humanly possible with their voices. Their music is virtuosic, emotionally compelling, and absolutely life-affirming. The master of the sarod, Ali Akbar Khan, is another artist very much worth exploring. For a more interesting east/west collaboration than "Meeting By The River"---Cooder was very tired at that session and it shows---"Good People In Times Of Evil" by Jonas Hellborg, Shawn Lane, and V. Selvaganesh is a remarkably vital document. |
I second "Meeting by the River" on Water Lily Acoustics Label ....a collaboration between Ry Cooder and VM Bhatt. It is a facinating cross cultural dialogue between two diverse vituosos. Ry plays his steel guitar like a Sitar and Bhatt blues up his Sitar playing. Lots of soul on that recording Also Nikhil Banerjee is amazing. One of the all time great Sitar players. |
