@khloebo , from reading your posts I have no doubt that you are way more tech savvy than I am (and in case that sounds like it might be snark, I am totally sincere) and I didn’t put as much science and knowledge into the comparisons that formed my perceptions as you have.
I acquired mine in ’21 from Cary’s preowned page, and from my memories of the emails I exchanged before I pulled the trigger, it was 8 years old at the time (it is one of the ones with the indentations on the power supply for the preamp feet to sit on, although I don’t have mine set up that way). When I called Cary on the phone (they will talk to you on the phone if you want to buy something) to close the deal, I decided that I may as well do The Ultimate Upgrade at the same time, and an added "bonus" would be free shipping (no free shipping on preowned, but if one was to send a preamp to cary for the upgrade, Cary would send it back after the work for "free") even though that meant that once the upgrade was done I owned it even if I didn’t like it.
But to understand where I am coming from with my perceptions of the SQ, up until that point I had been listening to a SLP-90 which I had owned since ’99. And the SLP-90 replaced a B&K digital HT preamp, so as you can see, my experience playing with high quality preamps is, to say the least, limited).
The SLP-90 was a huge upgrade in SQ from the HT preamp, but it was starting to sound as if it was getting tired. So the fact that I was listening to a 30 year old preamp probably has a lot to with why I like the SLP-05 as much as I do, although I will say that the SLP-05 sounds a bit (or maybe more than a bit) cool and clinical in comparison with my SLP-90.
As far as my balanced input tubes, that’s something else I am doing different that makes RCA vs XLR not a fair comparison. A friend from another site turned me on to a literal plethora of PAIRS of vintage 6SN7s (note that I emphasized ’pairs’) so after playing around with those in the balanced slots, I did note that some of them really really shined. At the moment I have a pair of National Union 6F8Gs (obviously with adapters) in those slots, and they really do it for me some nights. And prior to putting those in, I was giving a pair of Sylvania ’52 Bad Boys an extended spin, and they were making me happy, but for different reasons. I also found two different pairs of VT231s in that plethora that I thought were audibly better than the rest, with my favorite being a pair of black glass RCAs which made detail and separation stand out much more clearly and cleanly. (There were also pairs out of that fore mentioned plethora that I was not sure if I heard any discernible difference or not, and there are actually pairs of both 6sn7s and 6F8Gs that I have yet to even try.)
So with that all typed, I realize that you were making your observations re XLR vs RCA with all tubes being equal.
Back to the pots: what you typed about using the input level pots in conjunction with the main Alps pot was quite interesting, because in my near field environment I am usually at 9 o-clock + or - a bit, and that, of course, is with the input level pots turned all the way up.
My vision is not very good anymore and also I am a bit dense when it comes to understanding this stuff, but it sounds as if what you have been saying is that to get the best SQ given some of my other limitations also means lowering the gain and if I am stubborn about XLRs the next best would be to upgrade the two input level pots and use them for volume control with the main pot turned all the way up? Or at least set the upgraded inputs low enough so I can run the main Alps at 12 o-c-clock or close to it?
Forgive me if that is not what you have been saying.
(Okay, so now I note that you said that basically the Alps is not at its best at the bottom OR TOP quarter . . . meaning that I would not want to run it all the way up if I was combining it with the input level pots for volume adjustment.)
Regardless, unless I am totally misreading, upgrading the input level pots is definitely recommended. Even though I make no claims to be a tech, I do have experience soldering and de-soldering . . . how tricky a job is replacing the pots on this unit?
Having said all that, nothing needs to be done when you love the sound, XLR or RCA.
Well, there are nights that I am in love. But who doesn’t want more and more love?
Hey, thanks for your contribution to this thread!