So Many DACs - So Little Time


Looking for Good Dac at a Great Price- Here's my order of Preference:

1. PS Audio PerfectWave Dac
2. Bryston BDA-1
3. Bel Canto e.One Dac3
4. Benchmark Dac1 pre
5. Cary Xciter Dac
6. PS Audio DL III
7. Cambridge DacMagic
8. Music Hall Dac25.2

Thanks,
alpha3
What's in your system? It's hard to recommend without knowing what else is in the chain. Also, what ideally do you want to keep the price under?

I've owned or auditioned every DAC on the list except the PS Audio Perfect Wave and the Bryston. I've heard good things about the perfect wave, but I've also experienced and heard of quality control issues with PS Audio gear now that their gear is made in China (not sure if the perfect wave is, and not trying to slag off China, but I went through 2 Power Plant Premiers before giving up on PS Audio, and a friend went through two of their phono stages).

I thought the Bel Canto was definitely better than the Cary and Benchmark. The Cary flattened the soundstage compared to the Bel Canto, and while it was a very nice sound (not harsh at all) I didn't feel it projected as accurate or large a soundstage as the Bel Canto. The Benchmark did a good job with soundstaging and was phenomenal with detail, but totally unforgiving in my system and made everything sound too analytical. The Bel Canto has the detail of the Benchmark, but is more natural sounding to me.

The Cambridge is a great DAC, especially for the money, but I felt bass was a little duller and the soundstage was more diffused than with the Bel Canto or Benchmark (instruments blurred together a little more).

I would second the recommendation of trying an MHDT. I have an MHDT Havana and the Bel Canto right now and the Havana, while not as precise as the Bel Canto (not in terms of detail, but in instruments placed in space) and somewhat rolled off on the lower end, is really fantastic for the money. I'm curious to try the Bryston myself, so may order one when I move to my new place and see how it does against the Bel Canto and the Havana.
just to confuse things...if you can stretch just a little i would highly recommend the berkeley alpha dac. solved all my digital wants.
The Wyred4sound looks interesting. How would the Older
Theta Gen Va dac stack up against these New Dac??
Have heard all the DACs except the Cary. I would strongly suggest the Wyred4sound DAC.
As good as the Perfectwave or better with superior parts quality.
The biggest bang for you buck in my opinion is the Dac Magic. But then that is the only one that I've heard from your list. I agree though with you on the so many DACs so little time. I want to hear them all too. You might want to consider adding the MHDT Paradisea or Havana to your list. They are pretty nice sounding for the price as well.
I don't quite understand your post. Do you want us to comment on other DAC's that might have a higher bang-for-the-buck? If you do have a budget and a rank-ordered list of DAC's you want to get, then simply get the highest-ranking DAC that falls within your budget.

Michael
Is this a wanted ad? Why wouldn't you just get number 1 on your preference list?