I'm going to review records in my collection, and you'll be able to decide if they're worthy of your collection. These records are what I consider "must haves" for any jazz aficionado, and would be found in their collections. I wont review any record that's not on CD, nor will I review any record if the CD is markedly inferior. Fortunately, I only found 1 case where the CD was markedly inferior to the record.
Our first album is "Moanin" by Art Blakey and The Jazz Messengers. We have Lee Morgan , trumpet; Benney Golson, tenor sax; Bobby Timmons, piano; Jymie merrit, bass; Art Blakey, drums.
The title tune "Moanin" is by Bobby Timmons, it conveys the emotion of the title like no other tune I've ever heard, even better than any words could ever convey. This music pictures a person whose down to his last nickel, and all he can do is "moan".
"Along Came Betty" is a tune by Benny Golson, it reminds me of a Betty I once knew. She was gorgeous with a jazzy personality, and she moved smooth and easy, just like this tune. Somebody find me a time machine! Maybe you knew a Betty.
While the rest of the music is just fine, those are my favorite tunes. Why don't you share your, "must have" jazz albums with us.
It was on a real nice spring day and these heavy weight "aficionados" were having a discussion about jazz, and I wanted to get in on it. One of them was a famous St. Louis disc jockey by the name of Leo Chears. I was in my late teens at that time, and wanted to impress them with my knowledge of jazz.
I began by talking about "Paul Quinichette" ; I went on and on, pronouncing his name each time like it's spelled. While I was talking, I noticed Leo had a smirk on his face.
"You mean Paul Quinishay, don't you", and from that time on I never forget the correct pronunciation.
Acman, I spent a lot of time listening to John Zorn's music and considered it infinitely variable while revolving around music that would have been popular at the time of Christ in the Middle East; the music never got boring.
The highest honor that I can give any music is to say that I will buy it, and that's what I intend to do about John Zorn's music.
Although it's hard for me to classify this music as "jazz", that wont make me any difference, but it might to some. The bottom line is the fact that I think it's good music that will stand repeated listens.
John Zorn has written quite a few "mainstream jazz" arrangements played in an "accessible" manner by excellent musicians. The "Book Of Angels V12", links courtesy of acman3, is proof of that.
Further proof can be found on BOA V11 featuring Medeski, Martin, and Wood. Not as "easily accessible" as BOAV12, MMW sound more like jazz fusion but still nowhere near some of the "way out there" Zorn compositions/arrangements/music.
Pjw, very good selection; I've been listening to it, and while it consists of some fantastic music, I would call it "jazz fusion".
Presently, I'm deep into defining music; the difference between jazz, fusion, and modern music. There is no "dictionary definition of jazz", but "jazz musicians" know the definition internally within themselves; the same can be said for fans; it's comparable to the transmission and reception of radio and television.
While I could listen to the music you submitted all night, it's not jazz. The fact that jazz has so many unique requirements, eliminates a lot of music; but that doesn't mean the other music is not as good, it's just not jazz in the strictest sense.
BTW, we don't bar any kind of music on this thread, but I guess you knew that.
In the 50's and 60's, the best jazz was determined by "The word on the street", not some writer or book. Those two decades were before the decline of our major cities, and whatever the consensus was on the street in those cities, was it; like "Who was the best musician on which instrument"? or whatever.
While I can't, nor will I try to define jazz in it's strictest sense; I know it when I hear it; however, it seems that the musicians that Alex locked in on made real jazz.
Orpheus10, I posted this on the last page but it was overlooked.
I know this is "real jazz", played by excellent musicians, and every one of them puts "emotion/feeling/soul" into their solo's. I have the album and I think its a gem.
nsp, Thanks once again for introducing me to Grant Stewart. I have been listening to a lot of his music last couple days.
Grant is living proof of what you have repeatedly been posting - there is no shortage whatsoever of jazz musicians of today that can and do play old school jazz and play it well.
alex I hope you take note of the above. Not saying you should buy albums from current jazz musicians but there are plenty of them playing "Real Jazz" similar then your extensive collection of jazz LP's from the 50’s and 60’s. And they can play it with "emotion"
Whenever any jazz musician stretches the boundaries in search of a new sound, Coltrane’s last 2 years for example, it is not going to have that "Real Jazz" sound rooted in blues. And this was just as true in the 50’s - 60’s, Ornette Coleman as another example, as it is in 2019.
BTW I had that exact same suit Grant Green is wearing. This album was recorded in 1963, and I recall buying that suit in 62 as close as I can remember; we probably bought them at the same store.
As I explained before, my collection is not nearly as good as it should be; that's because I was always seeking whatever was the latest, instead of just looking for the best.
Oh I totally understand "why should I listen to that when I can listen to this" as a reason to never buy any "jazz" album after 1969.
But all I am saying is there are plenty of "real jazz musicians" currently touring and recording "real jazz" rooted in the blues. More examples since you brought up Grant Green who I think is awesome - my Grant Green collection of him as a leader is over 30 now - with over 30 as a sideman, just listen to this current "real jazz" guitarist:
pjwGlad you like Grand Stewart. Around the corner is on my short list of his CDs to buy. The first CD of his I purchased was a set of covers of Ellington and strayhorn tunes title Grant Stewart plays the music of Duke Ellington and Billy strayhorn: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dLFmf2jbZ8 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YgPJO1uT6F8 BTW- not sure if you noticed but he's sounds similar to Sonny Rollins which is one of the reasons I really like his style. I'm not the first one to say that as I also read it in one of the interviews of one of his CDs. I also own his CDs in the Still of the Night, live at Smalls, and Planet jazz. Haven't had a chance to listen to them will comment/ post when I do.
Here is one of 109 comments from the Roy Buchanan "Sweet Dreams" song I posted.
"This song by Roy Buchanan is the most soulful thing I’ve ever heard. It sends chills up my Spine! Roy played guitar like he came from a higher plain."
acman3 Pat Martino is one of my favorites and I have seen him live numerous times. I know he is still recording and touring. However, since he got his start in the early 60's, exclusively with one of my favorite tenor sax men, Willis "Gator tail" Jackson, I don't think we could count him as a "new" jazz guitarist.
BTW, I have Willis Jackson and Pat Martino's complete output - every recording session they did - terrific music!
As a matter of fact Albert Collins was dubbed the "Master of the Telecaster" but Buchanan was in a league of his own. If you had been listening to Roy Buchanan since the 70’s, like I have and still do, until he took his own life in 1988, you would hear chords and notes coming from his guitar that are simply unbelievable. He would sometimes sound like 2 guitarists were playing instead of one. He was the master of "pitch bending." And yes, I will admit it, Roy did like his polyester clothing, including bell bottoms and corduroy pants that look like he bought them at Woolworths.
Al Kooper talking about Michael Bloomfield, another great Telecaster player: "Why not do an entire jam album together?" Kooper remembered in 1998, writing the booklet notes for the Bloomfield anthology Don’t Say That I Ain’t Your Man: Essential Blues, 1964–1969. "At the time, most jazz albums were made using this modus operandi: pick a leader or two co-leaders, hire appropriate sidemen, pick some tunes, make some up and record an entire album on the fly in one or two days. Why not try and legitimize rock by adhering to these standards? In addition, as a fan, I was dissatisfied with Bloomfield’s recorded studio output up until then. It seemed that his studio work was inhibited and reined in, compared to his incendiary live performances. Could I put him in a studio setting where he could feel free to just burn like he did in live performances?"
That would be the Duke. :) After all, he wrote all the tunes. Were they, Ellington and Mingus, taking a risk, to their reputation, by doing this? For some reason, I think of Generals doing duty as private soldiers in the Infantry.
Great song orpheus10 Albert King is another of my favorite blues guitar men. And here is one from a man BB King greatly respected and they even jammed together on numerous occasions including the 1969 Newport Jazz Festival:
Pjw, I guess I could say that I was a fan of ’guitar heroes’ as well,in my youth,but somehow later came to a conclusion that I prefer ’jazz sensibility’ (in lack of better expression) much more. It would be interesting to know (maybe somebody does, or can dig some article on subject) what the jazz guitarist thought of their counteraparts who played rock or blues rock music. After all, even with decline of popularity of jazz, probably helped by spreading of rock I cant remeber any ’serious’ jazz guitar player who made transition to ’other side’, no matter how they struggld to find work....and also, do not know of any good jazz album played by rock or blues guitarist? I am not making any conclusions about ’value’ of any music type, just ’thinking out loud’...
Maybe Frogman can answer that, but as far as I am concerned, I cant understand how is possible that this music was put aside by general audience, not to take any credit from guys like Hendrix, or Allman, Buchanan,Gallagher or any other....I can understand the raw energy, but still...its a mistery to me....
I've been listening to everyone's jazz posts most of the day; everyone submitted top musicians, and I like them all, but I liked Rok's the best.
When it comes to music, I have discovered that it's best to be guided by your sub-conscious and not to ponder; everything that went into making the music, also goes into the reason why you like this better than that.
Jeff Beck comes the closest as far as rock which Jeff played. Jeff also played jazz/rock fusion. Another would be John McLaughlin although he never put out a pure "rock" album just jazz/rock fusion.
There are others alex like Alvin Lee who crossed over rock - jazz/rock fusion.
I could go on and on as to my thoughts on Page and Led Zeppelin but this is a jazz aficionado thread. Suffice to say "my" 2 favorites are Jimi Hendrix and Jeff Beck and there are many reasons I feel this way.
Pretentious "classical/progressive" guitarists like Yngwie Malmsteen I detest.
I know this is a jazz aficionado thread but I just cant keep from posting the following regarding the rock group Led Zeppelin and how they stole so many of their signature licks from the greatest African American blues masters of the 1920 - 1950 era. I hope its ok with you.
Here it is Led Plagiarism:
Blatant Thieves! Seriously in this song alone, ironically entitled because they stole 4xs for this 1 song "How Many More Times" they were successfully sued by Chester Burnett aka Howlin Wolf for his "How Many More Years" & for "Killin Floor " which is the beginning of Led Plagiarism’s "The Lemon Song" & of course, the ending is Robert Johnson’s, "Travelling Riverside Blues". Who Blatantly Steals from the man who made Muddy Waters & was the impetus for The Rolling MFG Stones 3xs? Willie "I AM The Blues" Dixon
1. "I Cant Quit You Babe" 2. "You Shook Me" 3. "You Need Love" Dixon & Muddy Waters = "Whole Lotta Love"
Again, successfully sued in out of court (admission of guilt) settlement. . . AGAIN! Little Richard’s, "Keep A Knockin" is blatant plagiarized in the opening drum solo in "Rock & Roll" Eddy Cochrans "Nervous Breakdown" stolen by Led Zep "Communication Breakdown."
Bert Jansch’s "White Waterside" blatantly plagiarized by Zep’s "Black Mountain Side" as well as "The Waggoner’s Lad" Zep STOLE & renamed it, "Boogie With Stu". Hell Page even stole from Bob Dylan. "Jesus Gonna Make Up My Dyin Bed" (originally from Sonny Boy Williamson originally published "Jesus Gonna Make Up My Dyin’ Bed" Dylan held the copywright when Led Plagiarism did "In My Dyin Day". Christ Page, all u had to do was ASK!
Seriously though Dylan wrote 200 + songs & Hendrix asked him for, "All Along the Watchtower" Robert Johnson yet again (the man is to the guitar as Bernard "Buddy" Rich became to the drums. Keith Richards and Jimmi Hendrix BOTH asked HOW many people were playing the guitar when they 1st heard Robert Johnson...Just 1.
"Terraplane Blues" (a terraplane was a race car or duece & heavily inspired "Trampled Underfoot". Moby Grape’s "Never" ("workin from 11 to 7 kinda makes life a drag" ... plagiarized by Zep "Since I’ve Been Lovin You" ("workin from 7 to 11 kinda makes life a drag") Of course, not to mention "Dazed and Confused" which was originally that guy who wrote the "Army jingle be all that you can be" & others. Blind Boy Fulller’s "Drop Dowm Mama" stolen to be "Custard Pie" for Zep. Sonny Boy Williamson "When The levee Breaks" same as Zep’s version of the same name.
His playing of a violin bow on an electric guitar...done b4. Imagine that? Same with Spirit’s "Taurus" B4 they were the Mighty Led Plagiarism...oops, I meant, Zeppelin...they traded music with Spirit. The opening riff is descending chords in A minor, so is "Taurus". Its so disgusting. I wish I NEVER was a fan bc the more I learned, the more unoriginal and mediocre Page became to me. He’s not even a Top 10 Guitarist Of All Time personally bc he was NOT original. At least "Kashmir" is theirs ... as far as we know. Then when Tool redid Led Zep’s "No Quarter" ... holy s--t Maynard & the boys knocked it out of the ballpark! 40xs better. That’s some Karma for you Jimmy, Robert. The unwritten hero is John Paul Jones. He made Page spund good.
Roy "The Lemon Song " is an EXACT replica to the gr8 Robert Johnson’s "Travelling Riverside Blues " if you think it’s OKAY to steal blatantly plagiarize from Robert Johnson, you need schoolin’ in the Mississippi Delta black bluesman’s influence on the classic rock genre ... at the end of Robert Johnson’s "Travelling Riverside Blues", you’ll hear Robert croon the exact same lyrics.
... about "squeeze me baby til the juice runs down my leg. Word for word. My my my I bet Robert Johnson, Willie Dixon, Howlin Wolf & Muddy Waters are rolling over in their graves. Disregard or complete lack thereof, for the music that made this genre. Lax copywrite laws does NOT mean you can steal.
By the way I would not like to follow Led Zeppelin's footsteps and blatantly plagiarize - the above was not written by me even though I have know about Zeppelins plagiarism since the 80's. But the author of the above sure gets it right! Full link (source) for the above here:
You must have a verified phone number and physical address in order to post in the Audiogon Forums. Please return to Audiogon.com and complete this step. If you have any questions please contact Support.