It's been a long time.

If your digital sounds less fleshed out and natural. Then it is the components... streamer and DAC that are the reason. These days it isn't the source medium but the components that determine the ultimate sound. So, I would first look at getting a warmer more natural sounding DAC. If that doesn't pull ahead your digital leg, then upgrade your streamer. 

I have extremely good analog and digital ends, both of which are detailed, natural and musical. I can switch back and forth and not tell which is which... or do that for a friend and they cannot tell. 

I decided to go all digital streaming several years ago, and I've loved every minute of it.  Digital (streaming) has come such a long way over the past 15 years or so.   I don't miss my old analog and CD set-ups one bit.  As a matter of fact, I strongly believe that the evolution and emergence of high quality, audiophile caliber streaming, via Tidal and Qobuz, is one of the greatest and most brilliant inventions in the history of high end audio music reproduction.  The trick is to assemble a streaming audio system which consists very high quality cables and components in order to achieve the very highest level of sound quality out of your digital streaming audio system.  Happy listening.         

In my experience, it costs quite a bit more money to equal a vinyl rig sound with a streaming one.

@kennymacc

+1 I never thought of it that way... you are right. It is really that big. It has completely changed the high end. I collected my 2,000 vinyl albums and 2,000 CDs over fifty years... then one day a few years ago my library went from 4,000 albums to well over a million... at the same or better sound quality. Sure was a long time in coming. 

@ghdprentice ....and it's nice to have no real storage issues for a 1M+ media, either... ;)
Nice growth in SSD's as well....Multi-terabyte drives are becoming a bit less $'s....