All the passive radiators I have seen use acoustic stuffing material in the the cabinet and/or transmission line. Just because you have a passive radiator, it doesn't change the need for damping cabinet resonances. You can use fiberglass insulation, its cheap!, but the dedicated acoustic stuffing material is better and you don't have the working with fiberglass problems. I use it in all the speakers I have built.
How properly covered internal sides of enclosures for speakers with a passive radiator?
My question to people who have practical experience to build a sealed (closed) cabinets for speakers with passive radiator?
I have experience to build speakers with ported cabinets, but now I've decided to build a three-way sealed cabinet using one woofer in the middle of the front panel and one passive radiator below the woofer. When I built the cabinets with ports, to minimize reflection and etc, I put felt material on all interior panels : left, right, rear, bottom and top panels (except the front panel). I know, passive radiator works using air pressure from woofer.
Hi, thank you for quick response. Usually I cover inner panels of speakers using 10mm felt, it work good to absorb reflection but because the principle operation of the passive radiator is based on the air pressure produced by the woofer. If I understand correctly, if all the internal sides of the speaker are covered with sound-absorbing material, then this reduces the air pressure on the passive radiator and reduces the efficiency of its operation. Please answer if I am wrong and what you recommend that should be done to reduce the loss of air pressure. |
Check my enclosures, shown here, 9th photo, back off, innards shown:
Polyfill, be careful of staples, get them straight, hammer them in if needed. Prior enclosure, on 8" legs, woofer facing down, I had a buzz once, it was a loose staple on the woofers cone Now, shorter base, woofer facing front, slightly tilted back (to aim tweeters at seated ear height and time alignment if you believe in that). No special bracing in that big box. I put lots of Donna's pricey beloved objects on the slightly slanted top, they don't vibrate or move. Very very slight sensation if holding hand on their side. Cabinet has a rear port, used in prior room 'no wall behind' location. Port closed for this location with wall behind. |
JBL used 1’’acoustic fiberglass insulation in their speakers with passive radiators, (except the front baffle). See below: 😎 Mike https://www.lansingheritage.org/html/jbl/plans/1960s-manual.htm https://www.lansingheritage.org/html/jbl/catalogs/1979-home.htm https://www.lansingheritage.org/html/jbl/plans/jbl-plans.htm |
When I use passive radiators, I peel fiberglass in about a 3 to 3 inch sheet and line the box with fiberglass. Remember, anytime you add glass or any type of stuffing, you change the effective box size and how the woofer reacts to that box. Also, a passive radiator, works similarly as a port, as you lengthen a port, you lower its effective tuning frequency, by changing the size and mass of a passive radiator, you are also raising or lowering its effective frequency. |