I would highly recommend the Musical Fidelity M6si. It's got similar power to your Anthem but has a far more refined sound. It's got a nice touch of warmth for a solid state integrated, but it doesn't gloss over details. I love mine and have had no interest in looking for something better. And it's got a DAC and an MM/MC phono input if that's important.
Good luck,
Scott
Good luck,
Scott