The problem with Be in speaker driver diaphragms is that it is so brittle that it atomizes, making it float in the air and easy to breathe, so your chances of getting a health risking dose when they break is non zero, but even then the risk of toxicity is low.
Beryllium-Copper: How safe?
now more and more hifi accessories like power plug, receptacles has Beryllium-copper in them. just curious how safe are beryllium-copper in our normal household? say receptacles with BE-copper contact, and with constant plugging in/out of the plug, will it be a concern?
just me being paranoid....
cheers
just me being paranoid....
cheers
8 responses Add your response
Keep in mind that beryllium copper connectors are generally plated with either gold, silver or rhodium (sometimes very heavily plated - as in the case with Furutech). So, even though beryllium alloy may have a slight risk of being toxic, you would really never get to that "beryllium" metal through the plating, unless you used a grinder or scraper against that metal (which is highly unlikely unless you just wanted to ruin your connector). |
Though it is commonly believed that Copper Beryllium alloys are safe to handle, evidence suggests this is not true. There are many factors that make copper beryllium dangerous such as corrosion, microscopic amounts of dust on the copper beryllium that can enter through open pores or cuts and product specific problems, such as shaving from a copper beryllium tool slipping and causing exposure to beryllium particles that can be breathed in. OSHA has recently reduced exposure limits to beryllium to 0.2ug/m3. Here is a study in the Chest Journal outlining a case study of two women who developed Chronic Beryllium Disease from just handling Copper Beryllium products. https://journal.chestnet.org/article/S0012-3692(15)38252-0/fulltext#cesec10 Apple, the tech giant, has removed all Beryllium including Copper Beryllium. https://www.apple.com/environment/safer-materials/ |
The information about beryllium dust vs the beryllium/copper alloy is correct. Take a ride with me in my way-back machine. Decades ago when I worked in environmental control one of the sites I inspected was a beryllium smelter. I think it was the only one in the United States. Since I was told the ore came from South America, I always thought it was funny that the plant was located in my territory in a small town in northwestern Ohio. The smelting and machining processes required strict environmental controls and personal protection including respirators and skin protection. The finished beryllium/copper alloy products (non-sparking hand tools)were safe to use without gloves. In fact I saw their non-sparking drum wrenches in use at many of the other sites I inspected. Bottom line, don't worry about the alloy. |
From Wikipedia As beryllium is toxic there are some safety concerns for handling its alloys. In solid form and as finished parts, beryllium copper presents no particular health hazard. However, breathing its dust, as formed when machining or welding may cause serious lung damage. [1]Beryllium compounds are known human carcinogens when inhaled. [2] As a result, beryllium copper is sometimes replaced by safer copper alloys such as Cu-Ni-Sn bronze.[3] |