What is a good turntable preamp under $500?


I am dipping my toes in analog and want to upgrade my turntable preamp for a second system. I currently have a cheap Cambridge Audio preamp that I think cost just over $100. I am using a Pioneer Elite receiver. At the time I just wanted to see if I could get my old Gerrard turntable up and running. Sound is pretty mediocre. Would I notice much difference if I went up to to something $300-$500. I have a high end digital system in my main rig. I don’t need to go to that level but would like to improve it some. Any you would recommend?

128x128bwguy

Hello?  Garrard is not a name associated with quality turntables unless you have a pro transcription model, which I doubt. Your CA preamp is MUCH closer to the best available than any Garrard mass market player. For $500.00 get a decent turntable, put your Grado on it and see what you have. 

Hagerman cornet I, II, III used if possible and the biggest deal is the bugle

 

Rega FONO, in either MM or MC flavors (MC is slightly over your budget, MM is well under).

Yes, the turntable is very old.  So, based on crustcoot’s comment, would I be better off getting an upgraded turntable first before upgrading the preamp?  I have been all digital for many, many years and my turntable is from the Stone Age😁.  Just want to get a decent analog system for a second system.

Yes, upgrade TT first. Then get a equally expensive phono preamp (or an newer integrated amp with phono stage). Throwing $500 at just a new phono preamp probably will keep you wondering/expecting more.

Original OP question: get a used "ifi phono2". I have one and love it, very configurable for different cartridges.