I am not sure about Polk but I had a NHT sub years ago that only sounded right if wired amp to sub to main speakers and you set the crossover on the sub.
Wiring question : amp-sub-speakers
I am pretty new to audio world and am looking for an advice regarding wiring Denon PMA 2000 IVR integrated amp, Polk PSW 550 sub and JBL studio 530 speakers. Current wiring is, Amp to JBL using the main binding post and Amp to Sub using preout. It sounds great up to certain volume level and JBL 5" woofer starts over-excursion, aka bottoming out, at a higher volume(knob 11 o’clock & >90 decibel) to fast tempo low frequency sound like drum kicks. I am not sure how to improve this situation. Sub manual suggest "Speaker-level" connections, i.e., Amp to Sub and Sub to JBL. Is it connection issue, JBL issue, or Amp issue? Thanks in advance.
18 responses Add your response
ubee, your problem is that you are not using a high pass filter in front of your amplifier. You need to get the bass out of your main speakers. The PSW 550 does not have a high pass filter in it's cross over. I believe your integrated has a preamp output and a direct amp input. You could use an outboard cross over in a loop using the preamp out/amp input. You would then disable the crossover in the subwoofer. The only other way to deal with this would be to put an appropriately sized capacitor in series with the woofers in your main speakers to roll them off at 6 dB/oct. |
I am not sure how to improve this situation.Easy: new speakers. Your bookshelf speakers are max'd out. Your amp has tone controls so what you might try short term is turn the bass down. Your little speakers can't handle it. Then turn the sub up to compensate. Its a crap solution but all there is without better speakers, since fundamentally your problem is nothing to do with the speakers its you. Play them within the range they are intended for, or buy ones designed to play within the range you want. |
I tried what millercarbon suggested - reduce bass down from amp and increase bass up at Sub. It worked but I do not like the sound quality. Eventually I hooked up speakers through Sub speaker level out, aka high level out. It does not fix bottoming out issue but, instead I feel Sub and speakers timings are in sync and it appears to be recommended method for 2channel stereo setup. |
ubee, It does not matter what speakers you have or get. In order to match up a subwoofer correctly the crossover has to have a high pass filter that rolls off the bass to the satellite speakers. Then you will not have a problem overloading them. This business of just putting the subwoofer on a low pass filter and doing nothing with the satellites is a cheap silly solution that as you have discovered does not work. You can get a stand alone cross over like the dbx DriveRack and fix the problem. Then down the line add a second sub and you will be in business. |
Thanks mijostyn. I found a product, FMOD Crossover which looks to me a worthy trying.
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0006N41KG/ref=ask_ql_qh_dp_hza Will it work this way? I run a y cable out of the R and L pre amp out with one side of y to subwoofer then other end of y through the filter plugged back to amp in which filters the signal to the main speakers. |
| Post removed |
That will work. You will need two y adapters, one for each channel. I have used this Hsu high pass filter with great results. Take a look at the owners guide and it shows how to hook up a high pass filter!! http://www.hsuresearch.com/products/high-pass-filter.html |
| Post removed |
As mijostyn suggested, add a 300uF capacitor in series with your main speakers to roll off low bass at 6 dB/oct. https://www.parts-express.com/300uf-100v-electrolytic-non-polarized-crossover-capacitor--027-371 |
Or use a high pass filter in series with your main speakers to roll off low bass at 12 dB/oct. https://www.parts-express.com/100-hz-high-pass-8-ohm-crossover--266-462 |
What is a bass blocker and what does it do to my speaker? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s_amOnIh1So |
They are just capacitors. They will roll of the bass at 6 dB/oct. You would hook them up in series with your main speakers. The value depends on the impedance of your speaker at the cross over point. You can find charts on the net which will give you the right value, somewhere between 200 and 300 mfd. As im said go to Parts Express and order two. |