You will not get consensus on this. There are many ways to get the "direct" effect, and it can be done quite well with nearly any type of amp. The key is the quality of the amp and the rest of the system.
As far as the "you are there" or "they are here" discussion, imo it's fairly worthless.
As far as the "you are there" or "they are here" discussion, imo it's fairly worthless.