Tube Amp or Tube Pre Amp


For those of you who have experience with tubes, what would be your preference.

Tube Amp with tube preamp, Tube Amp with solid state preamp, or Solid state Amp with tube preamp

My system currently is Mcintosh MC352 Amp Solid State, Mcintosh C49 Pre Amp SS, Klipsch Cornwall IV speakers. 

I want to try tubes so with my current set up should I go tube amp or tube preamp?

Thanks

referee1

I am experienced with both. It kind of depends. I definitely recommend a tubed -preamp (Audio Research my preference, or Conrad Johnson or VAC). This will add a more musical and natural sound to your system. Hard to see a downside. Definitely the first step. Buy used to reduce cost. They are made to last decades.

My first tube amp was revelatory and put an end to me ever wanting another solid state amp again, after over forty years of great and powerful solid state amps. But there is a trade off. That is the artificial brick wall slam goes away. It is replaced with a more nuanced, natural and real sounding bass… likewhat you experience in the real world. But if you sit in front of your system waiting for the next fast wall of bass to hit your chest it might leave you wanting. For me, I noticed the absence and instantly didn’t care because of all the incredible aspects of sound quality I gained. Again, I prefer Audio Resesrch… detailed, powerful and incredibly natural and musical… Conrad Johnson and VAC…. VTL, Cary… the list of great tube amps goes on. There are also budget brands.

By far, the most important choice is the right amp for the particular speaker.  The sound of the system will be primarily determined by the amp-speaker matchup.  If you want to hear what tubes can do for the sound, start with the proper tube amp for your system.  Tube amps vary greatly in sound, much more so than do good solid state amps. 

While I am a tube amp fan, I find that there are many that do not suit my taste such that I would take most solid state amps over such tube amps.  I generally don't like most high-powered tube amps that use a lot of tubes in parallel pushpull to achieve very high power; most sound hard and brittle to me and I would be more likely to take a solid state amp.

Fortunately for you, you have speakers that will work with fairly low-powered tube amps.  You will have to audition some to get a feel of what amps you like.  I have my own preferences which are for some single-ended triode (SET) amps and pushpull amps running EL 84, 6L6, or KT 66 tubes.  The EL 84 tube is run in a lot of more reasonably priced amps and it delivers a lively sound.  SET amps that I like tend to be quite low in power, which may be an issue even with your high efficiency Cornwalls if you have a large room and like to play music at very high volume.  Also, although SET amps appear to be very simple, so they should be affordable, they demand a very good output transformer so decent sounding ones are NOT cheap.  You should at least audition a good SET amp, but, they might be a bit of a risk when it comes to compatibility.

I like using my tube preamp with my solid state amp.The sound is alot better..The power of solid state amp makes the tube preamp sing  out.But that's just me,perhaps. 

If cost of ownership is of any concern, it is worthwhile noting that preamp tubes last a very long time while amplifier power tubes have definite lifetimes.

I say this having recently replaced 8 kt88s in my amp.

I will also say that I wouldn't have it any other way.

Bill