Sugden amp to pair Harbeth SHL5? Not too thick?


HI,

I bought Harbeth SHL5, positioned it properly on filled skylan stands.

Now I drive it by DIY SET GM70 based tube amps, Audio Note tube PRE (M8), Linn Sneaky DS with modified Audio Note DAC 2.1x via SPDIF.

Sound is very refined.
I tried to use analog Linn Sneaky outputs, but it failed due to very average sound quality. AN DAC works much much better in all aspects.

Because Harbeth is a rather thick sounding speaker (I had before Audio Note E and Tannoy DC 15" drivers based horns), high frequencies are rather shy, I had to changes very civilized speaker cables from Audio Note silver litz (SP+SPe) to silver plated van den hul The WIND. WIND made speakers much more coherent , dynamic and a bit more open.

I wanted to simplify a bit my setup and make the sound more open. Tubes with Harbeth is a rather too thick sound combination. These speakers rather requires a lighter sounding setup and there is no need to warm sound with tubes or too relaxed cables.

AD rem:
I'm thinking about Sugden Masterclass IA-4 to combine power amp, pre-am and RIAA in one box. Tonality it should be similar to tubes (midrange quality)

IS Sugden warming up the sound a lot by working in A class?
Do you think, this is a good Harbeth match which gives well balanced sound with open and extend top-end?
Any advice, what would be the other good choice of integrated SS amp with good RIAA?

thanks
maciekp2
I recently changed from an IA-4 to an Accuphase E350.
Whilst the Sugden is a very good amp for all of the above mentioned reasons, but the E350 has a much tighter grip and control of my SHL5's.
This may sound like an odd recommendation, but a BAT 300x integrated would probably be a very good choice. It has a phono option and 3 different preamp options. Its built like a tank and is very powerful. Also, its neutral enough to work with just about anything.
As much as I like and respect Noel from Skylan, I never thought his stands worked well with Harbeth for me. My dealer demonstrated the SHL5s with the old EPOS ST12 open-frame stands and to my ear, they yielded a much clearer sound. When I got the speakers home, I ordered the Skylans because they were the ones you were "supposed" to get with Harbeths, but I ended up changing to the Epos. Before you jump ship, you might consider placing a hard interface between the speakers and the Skylans. I found that casino chips worked well or you could use metal cones with the points facing up if you don't mind putting pinpricks in the speaker. Have fun.
I run the Sugden A21SE and it will not thicken the sound. Of oourse I cannot speak about your DIY tube amps. One would presume the Sugden would be much quicker with extended high end. But then I also run Manley tube amps and they are very quick indeed.

I will say the Sugden is very speaker cable sensitive and does not like silver much. Bright. The Sugden is not a warm sound. Very open and the bottom end is not warm or thunderous, just very fast and accurate. Hope this helps.