SONUS FABER BOOKSHELF SPEAKER ADVICE: Lumina II; Sonetto I; Sonetto II; Venere 1.5


SONUS FABER BOOKSHELF SPEAKER ADVICE: Lumina II; Sonetto I; Sonetto II; Venere 1.5

I would appreciate advice from readers who have direct experience with any or more of the following Sonus faber bookshelf speaker models:
Lumina II
Sonetto I
and/or Sonetto II
Venere 1.5

NEED:
Bookshelf speakers with great musicality, in a normal living room, especially off-axis (I do not sit in a set position), front-ported.

I have recently heard and really liked a pair of older Sonus faber Cremona M stand-mounts, as well as KEF R3 (the KEF are out of our budget). The speakers I directly compared to which I did not like much were various Bowers & Wilkins (606 S2; 607 S2; 705 S2) models, Monitor Audio Silver 100, and Martin Logan. Focal Chora 806 were recommended by a friend, but we could not listen to them anywhere. Both stores I visited stated that if I preferred the Sonus faber Cremona and the KEF R3 and did not like B&W and Monitor, I would very probably like any of the other Sonus Faber models, and not so much the Focal.

Based on this and other research, inexperience in audio matters, and fatigue from research/etc., I would like to narrow the list down to just the Sonus faber models. The max $1200 budget allows for either new Lumina II or used Sonetto I, Sonetto II, or Venere 1.5. I am trying to gather information between these models as I cannot audition any of those.

The Lumina II seem to garner universal praise, and I have been told I would enjoy them. What appeals to me a bit more about the Sonetto I, Sonetto II, and Venere 1.5 (but only if they are acoustically equal to or better than the Lumina II) are the slightly larger size and the classic Sonus faber "lute" shape.

PURPOSE:
Music almost exclusively. The speakers would connect to the TV but HT is not a requirement at all.

ASSOCIATED EQUIPMENT:
Cambridge Audio AXR100 stereo receiver
Rotel 955 CD player
2 x Rythmik L12 subwoofers

ROOM:
The room is a standard small/medium living room (not a "listening room") of ~240 sf with a 60 sf dining area diagonally away from where the speakers would be. So, ~290 sf total (~2,500 cf). The speakers would have to sit on 16" maximum deep solid shelves, so front-ported is good. Speaker stands are not a viable option, for both space and budget reasons.

Any advice and impressions from those who have experience with any of the Sonus faber models listed above would be welcome.

venessian

I'm also very interested in this comparison and would be curious as to the sound comparison of the lines. However, I do want to use these for home theater as well. Center channel intelligibility is therefore important too. 

I previously landed on Dynaudio Emits for their warm and lively sound without being too harsh or bright. Didn't like Kef, Paradigm, B&W, Monitor Audio... Listening fatigue is a definite issue.

I've only heard the Olympica towers and Amator bookshelfs ($10k) which sounded great. They were warm & detailed without being harsh in the high end. But way out of my price range. 

I don't care where the cabinets were made. I care how they sound. 

One reason I'm considering the Sonus Faber over Dynaudio for another set up is that the vocals seem a bit more forward and lively while still being warm which I'm hoping will translate to more clarity in movie dialogue.

 

The Sonetto II is a fine speaker. My son has a pair driven by a Simudio ACE and he loves it. Calls his speaker Stiletto's.

 

I think you choice of Sonus Faber is appropriate. I have now owned three pair and have learned to appreciate their uniquely natural sound and beautiful construction. All the SF I owned are full sized so, I can’t directly contribute on the smaller ones. Although a short cut that can save a lot of time is to simply buy the most expensive ones. Every company makes sure that each model up i. A line sounds better than the last.

I’ve owned the Venere 2.5’s and the Sonetto V’s, both full range speakers though, and the sonetto’s are a definite improvement.  The Veneres are no longer in production, but, unlike the other SF lines, they were assembled in China.  The Sonetto’s while somewhat similarly priced, are made in Italy.

I’ve owned the Venere 2.5’s and the Sonetto V’s, both full range speakers though, and the sonetto’s are a definite improvement.  The Veneres are no longer in production, but, unlike the other SF lines, they were assembled in China.  The Sonetto’s while somewhat similarly priced, are made in Italy.

I would not suggest the Venere line.  I had the 2.5 in my system on demo, and you should know they are NOT voiced at all like SF’s more upscale models, which have a warmer, fuller and more musical sound.  Also, the cabinets are very lightweight with subpar build quality.  Can’t speak to the Sonetto line, but I’d definitely do some research given my experience with Venere.  Hope this helps, and best of luck.