2. amps-preamps
  3. 191929-133920

Phono stage comparisons

I'm looking at 3 possible used phonostages.  In order of price least expensive to most - Sutherland 20/20, PS Audio Stellar, and Manley Chinook.  I am leaning towards either the Stellar or the Chinook but the price on the Sutherland is hard to pass up.  

All three get very good reviews.  I am hoping someone has actual experience with them and cares to share.  FYI I am currently using a Musical Surroundings Phonomena ll pre.  

Thanks 

pkatsuleas
ckr1969
50 posts
 

sutherland

 

dayglow
1,893 posts
 

Don't let price be the determining factor. IMO the biggest issue with phono preamps is the noise floor. At the lower price point SS is a much safer(quieter) choice than tube phono stages. If still considering the Manley Chinook you must demo the current replacement, the Manley Oasis which claims a much lower noise floor.

vair68robert
624 posts
 

Are you using a MM or MC cartridge ?

pkatsuleas OP
252 posts
 

Thanks for the replies.  Rega P6 with MM Exact cart.  I do enjoy tube gear so certainly not ruling the Chinook out.  I don't have an uber detailed system and prefer it that way.  But yes, noise floor can be a problem. 

As of now, the Stellar is off the table.  I may just go for the Sutherland and see how I like it.  That leaves me cash to add another sub.  ;-)

I can always wait for another Chinook (or better) in the future.   

Thanks

vair68robert
624 posts
 

If you enjoy tube gear Tavish Designs Adagio is all tube with 44 db gain for MM cartridges and it cost less than Manley .   

More to discover