Marantz SA-10 vs Marantz SACD-10


I have a Marantz SA-10 CD player and I am really pleased I made that decision. However, I can not help but wonder If anyone here thinks that the Marantz SACD-10 player is actually $4,000 better than a SA-10. And why? Inquiring minds want to know.

 

ckkt66

replaced my Marantz SA-10 with a Teac 701T transport combined with the Yggdrasil MIB DAC connected by a Shunyata Theta SPDIF cable and am glad I made the change; more organic sounding, closer to high end analog, more detail and better soundstaging, great combination !

I just got the Marantz SACD-10.....can only compare to PS AUdio SACD transport via Holo Audio May DAC.  The SACD-10 to Holo Audio Serene Pre amp via balanced outs....first impressions, an absolute winner.  Still breaking in, but am testing various formats, etc.   I have many SACD and still buying, for me it is THE format.  I have an ability to process and format to 5.6 DSD as well, More to come!!

I have an Esoteric UX3 which is the same as an X3 but the UX3 also has DVD Audio playback. A good audio friend brought his Marantz SA10 over to compare. Both players were connected to the Aux inputs on my Mac C2500 tube preamp. We used the exact same power cords and audio cables on both players. I was able to match the levels exactly on each player because my Mac allows you to fine tune each audio input. Levels were matched and we began. We used duplicate CD’s in each player and got them synched pretty easily. We both found my Esoteric player to sound better in all aspects to the Marantz. Same for SACD’s. I think the main reason are the Burr Brown PCM1704 R to R ladder dac’s in my Esoteric. It had a very analog flow and sound you just could not get from the Marantz. The Marantz sounded sharper but not better.

My friend left very disappointed with his tail tucked between his legs. I believe my friend spent $7-8K for his Marantz. I got a better deal from Spearit Sound in Northampton, MA back in July 2012. I paid $4K for an exhibition stock unit that went for $8500.00. The best purchase I have ever made. My friend now owns one of the newer Esoteric players and is very happy.

I have a SA10 which I thought sonically bettered my Esoteric K1. The new Marantz has an even better power supply than mine, but a $4000 increase in price. It is also as ugly as a bread box. A big no for me.